I agree with this to a degree but it certainly isn't like that around us. As I say, the issue exists because people who want to sit down sit 8 rows from the back & there isn't enough rows for people to stand before people start demanding they sit down. Which results in the 7 standing rows being too congested.OK, so you say 17 in 15 seats isn't a problem. What about when it's 20 in 4 seats, as it is at the back of gangway D on the kop these days. And these aren't ST holders trying to get in their seats, these are "lads" who think it's fine to force 4x the capacity cos "I wanna stand wiv my mates innit?"
Do any of them give a shit when my 64 year old dad is getting landed on from behind by these "lads" whenever we score? My dad paid for his seat, he's perfectly happy to stand all game, and go nuts when we score. What he shouldn't be subjected to is the "LIMBS" brigade throwing themselves everywhere, arms and legs flailing, for the sake of an instagram video.
Best solution safe standing as has been mentioned many times.
Second best would be to stop automatic renewals one year & asking people who want to sit down/not make any noise to stop buying tickets in the most atmospheric area of the ground. Leeds have two full stands & corners with everyone on their feet, we can't even have 8 rows on the KOP. It's ridiculous & a big part of the reason for our under par atmosphere