"Culture"

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

I know I spent most of 1998 off me tits on alco pops and 50p a bottle pils in Berlins, but how the fuck did I miss that Blades party! ;)
We must have crossed paths in there. In fact I think I may have got engaged in there one Sunday night. Bottle of house Champers, but so excited I couldn't drink anything, I was so tense. Felt like I'd been inhaling Co2.
 



There are lots of things about the club that need to move forward , they're on most posts , we know what they are and there's general consensus.

Nevertheless the club needs to be identifiable to its supporters, the essence of what makes it , the DNA of sufc , I think thats what referred to as culture.

It matters as much as any ingredient, not more or less, its not either or , you can have both.
We have a very clear identity

Amateur and living in the past
 
“Getting the club” is the biggest load of bollocks ever. I remember hearing “the West Ham way” being spouted by their fans many years ago, again, just bollocks.

Every club wants the same thing, win matches, have a successful season and hopefully play some entertaining football while winning. It’s very simple!

No club is unique, we could get a player or manager from anywhere on the planet and he’ll know that it’s all about winning. You don’t need to be from Sheffield to work out that United fans want to see their team win.
 
“Getting the club” is the biggest load of bollocks ever. I remember hearing “the West Ham way” being spouted by their fans many years ago, again, just bollocks.

Every club wants the same thing, win matches, have a successful season and hopefully play some entertaining football while winning. It’s very simple!

No club is unique, we could get a player or manager from anywhere on the planet and he’ll know that it’s all about winning. You don’t need to be from Sheffield to work out that United fans want to see their team win.
This.

And what people perceive as being “our culture” is surely a generational thing, depending on what things were like in our formative years. For quite a few of us, that’s rooted in the fantastic football we played under John Harris. We weren’t “plucky little underdogs with a chip on their shoulders and wanting to fight the world” then, we were highly respected. But that changes and evolves down through the generations. The culture changed under Bassett, again under Warnock and again under Wilder. And it will change again, hopefully in a more progressive way than where we are right now.
 
Interesting debate

Culture , mmmm

I think of some clubs and the first thing that comes into my head

Leeds - dirty
West Ham - entertainers
Chelsea - Kings road , flamboyant
Liverpool - entitled egotists
Man U - buccaneers
Man C - boring machine
Sheff U - old fashioned grit
Sheff W - entitled wannabees


Based on my experiences as a 65 year old

The shadow / impression created by Utd on others is not very attractive or exciting. We’re rather dull and 🫤 I would imagine. Hence the lack of driven and wealthy owners and recruiting from the fingers crossed dregs of the pensioners barrel.

We are designed to be all this
 
I don't know what the club culture is or what Wilder was on about.
I do know that in my lifetime we've only had success with Dave Bassett, Neil Warnock and Chris Wilder - all managers cut from the same cloth.
And I know that Selles, Jokanovic etc - players from a different cloth got us nowhere.

If we're going to change, who might be successful with us? Sean Dyche, Fat Sam?
Slav wasn’t given the opportunity to bring his players into the club he tried our limited players in the systems he wanted to play because the promises made to him were never followed through by the owners
Selles was a uck up ft the moment his name was leaked we all knew that and so did Betis
 
We must have crossed paths in there. In fact I think I may have got engaged in there one Sunday night. Bottle of house Champers, but so excited I couldn't drink anything, I was so tense. Felt like I'd been inhaling Co2.

Royal Gold wasn't it?

The same shit that Bobby Brown allegedly drank next door in Isabella's.
 



It's not just Wilder who speaks like this. I've heard the same this season from the supposedly progressive Davies at Birmingham. That was something along the usual lines about being "honest" because their fans are down-to-earth and like players who run around a lot and don't shirk tackles. I'd like to hear from fans of any club, anywhere in Europe, who don't expect that as a given. I don't know if Davies is equally wary of foreigners, cockneys, jocks or taffs who might not know what it means to come from Sheffield (or Birmingham in his case). I suspect not.

I agree with lots of the posts above. When I was first introduced to the club we were considered a rather stylish and exciting team and even when Harris left the club tried to recruit managers in the same mould like Haslam and Sirrell, if unsuccesfully.

Our reputation seems to have been permanently changed by the appointment of Bassett and reinforced by the tenure of Warnock despite what might have happened inbetween all that. I wonder if Howard Kendall knew he managed a hoof-ball side of honest triers? Mind you poor old Howard probably wouldn't have known either way by that stage. Nor would Robson later on for that matter.

I wonder if Wilder was so interested in the club's culture when he was being feted by the national and international press and praised to the skies by Guardiola and Bielsa? That's all a bit of a faded memory now as everyone has seen behind the curtain, so we're left with hard work, determination and as many puns as Sky commentators can shoe-horn in around something to do with steel.

Anyway, to summarise; it's complete bollocks.
 
Lovely to see a decent response to the question on what appears to be another excuse for yet another anti-wilder thread for the anti-wilder moaners to engage with. Enjoy (and yes, I think his time is up, but this cloaking an anti-wilder thread is just sad...)

Whilst some will take any opportunity to have a dig i think this has been born out of his comments this last week about British players and Everton's model from 20 years ago.

Both comments smacked of ignorance and were also factually incorrect.

In the current climate, ill advised remarks imho as it's just provided further ammunition for those who think he's over the hill in managerial terms.
 
Interesting debate

Culture , mmmm

I think of some clubs and the first thing that comes into my head

Leeds - dirty
West Ham - entertainers
Chelsea - Kings road , flamboyant
Liverpool - entitled egotists
Man U - buccaneers
Man C - boring machine
Sheff U - old fashioned grit
Sheff W - entitled wannabees
Notts Florist - still think they're European Champions
 
Interesting debate

Culture , mmmm

I think of some clubs and the first thing that comes into my head

Leeds - dirty
West Ham - entertainers
Chelsea - Kings road , flamboyant
Liverpool - entitled egotists
Man U - buccaneers
Man C - boring machine
Sheff U - old fashioned grit
Sheff W - entitled wannabees


Based on my experiences as a 65 year old

The shadow / impression created by Utd on others is not very attractive or exciting. We’re rather dull and 🫤 I would imagine. Hence the lack of driven and wealthy owners and recruiting from the fingers crossed dregs of the pensioners barrel.

We are designed to be all this
Yes but all of the labels are now out dated and don't still apply to the above clubs, with the small exception of the Two Sheffield clubs.
 
Royal Gold wasn't it?

The same shit that Bobby Brown allegedly drank next door in Isabella's.
No idea mate. I've been married 34 years so it was well before that! I had fuck all money back then so it wouldn't have been an expensive one.
 
Whilst some will take any opportunity to have a dig i think this has been born out of his comments this last week about British players and Everton's model from 20 years ago.

Both comments smacked of ignorance and were also factually incorrect.

In the current climate, ill advised remarks imho as it's just provided further ammunition for those who think he's over the hill in managerial terms.
Completely agree and its great when people ysena thread appropriately. Too often though it is merely an attempt to cloak a simple Wilder out view which makes the thread incredibly frustrating to read even if you agree with the underlying proposition!
 
No idea mate. I've been married 34 years so it was well before that! I had fuck all money back then so it wouldn't have been an expensive one.

It was cheap stuff they used to knock out as champagne when I went in 1991-97, just pomagne or other fizzy shit.

When Berlins was linked to Isabella's next door they had the same stuff. Legend has it, or more to the point an old mate of mine swears blind he was there and saw it (I'm not claiming authenticity!) that when Whitney played the Arena early 90s, Bobby Brown was in Isabella's with minders and was in the VIP area (loosely termed) drinking Royal Gold from the bottle 😄
 
It appeals to the less aware members of the fan base, which in this sport make up a large percentage of the stadium. It's knuckle dragging, primitive man in cave rhetoric. If Chris could actually verbalise what this 'culture' is he talks of, it would be helpful.
So it would 😉
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom