Porterfield said when he was fired that he had worked miracles for the club. We won Division 4 in his first season and then finished higher every season than the season before.
As I have said before, in 40 or 50 years when no one who remembers the Porterfield era is still alive, people looking at his record will wonder why he was fired. The same might also apply to Blackwell and Clough. The answer is that you had to be there to understand it.
I have never heard a team and a manager get so much abuse as Porterfield and the team got that season. The Millwall home defeat was so toxic that the crowd were cheering Millwall in the last 10 minutes, and when Jeff Eckhardt scored our consolation there was even some ironic booing. The team were booed off after beating Fulham just after Christmas and beating Carlisle on New Years Day. After their purple patch in October and November where we went second and had some impressive wins, particularly away, the team reverted to its early season patchy form and the Norwich performance, albeit against a good team, saw the car park demonstration afterwards. The team was certainly underperforming at that point, and selling Glenn Cockerill was a huge loss.
For all that, I do agree that the sacking was harsh, but I think Brealey was driven to it by the supporters. Incidentally, the day Porterfield was sacked, we were seventh, 2 points behind Hull (who had played a game more) and Brighton (who had played a game less). The playoffs came in the following season. I always wonder whether had the playoffs been in operation Brearly would have left Porterfield where he was on the basis we were on the cusp of them.