(BBC) Premier League - "Manager of the Season", Chris Wilder takes second place

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?




What are the awards?
There are 10 awards up for grabs - including the Premier League and Women's Super League players of the season.
You also voted for your teams of the season in both leagues. Here's the full awards list:
  • Premier League Manager of the Season
  • WSL Manager of the Season
  • Premier League Moment of the Season
  • Premier League's Surprise Package of the Season
  • WSL Young Player of the Season
  • Premier League Young Player of the season
  • Premier League Signing of the Season
  • Premier League Goal of the Season
  • WSL Player of the Season
  • Premier League Player of the Season
  • WSL Team of the Season
  • Premier League Team of the Season
 
These are voted for by the fans aren't they...
 
The BBC are becoming increasingly irrelevant and this is particualrly highlighted in their coverage of sport - everything about it is miles behind other rival broadcasters.

This is perhaps best typified by their end of season awards. I don't think too many will argue with Klopp receiving the managers' award but Fernandes being allowed to be in team of the season (having played a grand total of 5 games) over Kavacic, Maddison and even Fleck is frankly ridiculous.
 
Fernandes being allowed to be in team of the season (having played a grand total of 5 games) over Kavacic, Maddison and even Fleck is frankly ridiculous.

They lost all credibility when they published that. That and shortlisting John Lundstram for PL Player of the Year. He’s not even been in our top 7.
 
Agreed - reminded me of players' ratings in newspapers when reporters obviously hadnt been to the game - whoever scores gets the highest mark.
 
How many Blades fans honestly believe Klopp could possibly have done what Wilder has achieved?
I suspect the answer would be "Zero"

It's not really a measured argument though. There's good reason Klopp & Pep are at the levels they are.

I couldn't confidently say that Wilder would be able to achieve what Klopp has. He has no track record managing big budgets, international dressing rooms and superstar egos.

Klopp's league record has been outstanding this season, almost perfect. He deserved the award.
 
How many Blades fans honestly believe Klopp could possibly have done what Wilder has achieved?
I suspect the answer would be "Zero"
Sorry. Under the right circumstances I think he might have.


Upon his retirement playing for Mainz 05, Klopp was appointed as the club's manager on 27 February 2001 following the sacking of Eckhard Krautzun.[24][25] The day after, Klopp took charge of their first match, which saw Mainz 05 secure a 1–0 home win over MSV Duisburg.[12][26][27] Klopp went on to win six out of his first seven games in charge, eventually finishing in 14th place, avoiding relegation with one game to spare.[28] In his first full season in charge in 2001–02, Klopp guided Mainz to finish 4th in the league as he implemented his favoured pressing and counter-pressing tactics, narrowly missing promotion. Mainz again finished 4th in 2002–03, denied promotion again on the final day on goal difference.[12] After two seasons of disappointment, Klopp led Mainz to a third place finish in the 2003–04 season, securing promotion to the Bundesliga for the first time in the club's history.[12][29]

Despite having the smallest budget and the smallest stadium in the league, Mainz finished 11th in their first top-flight season in 2004–05. Klopp's side finished 11th again in 2005–06 as well as securing qualification for the 2005–06 UEFA Cup, although they were knocked out in the first round by eventual champions Sevilla.[28] At the end of the 2006–07 season, Mainz 05 were relegated, but Klopp chose to remain with the club.[30] However, unable to achieve promotion the next year, Klopp resigned at the end of the 2007–08 season.[31]He finished with a record of 109 wins, 78 draws and 83 losses.[32]
 
I couldn't confidently say that Wilder would be able to achieve what Klopp has. He has no track record managing big budgets, international dressing rooms and superstar egos.
I couldn't either - that's not my point at all. I'm merely questioning the "magic" of Jurgen Klopp being able to pick up Sheffield United and do what Wilder has done under the same circumstances and not
Under the right circumstances
 
We actually have a thread asking if we could do better with another manager.
 



All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom