A few thoughts about the 'good old days', and also about the current situation, for anyone who has the patience to read all this. The best days for me were the late 50s and early 60s, no doubt largely because it was my youth, and I loved football above all else. And also, the United of that time earned that love. Ask any Blades fan who was watching United at the time, and rather like reciting times-tables, they will be able to reel off the starting line-up: Hodgkinson; Coldwell, Shaw (G); Richardson, Shaw (J), Summers; Lewis, Russell, Pace, Hodgson, and Simpson. For several seasons that 11 seemed to start every league and cup match (the Cup was very high profile), and even in Division 2 we had 2 England internationals (Hodgy, Graham Shaw), and arguably one player even better (Joe Shaw). There were, I think, no scapegoats, as the players were so familiar that they were accepted for their strengths, rather than jeered for their weaknesses (Simpson was a direct winger who crossed well and had a hard shot, but never headed the ball; Richardson was not a great passer, but a superb tackler). But, they were not a total success - they used to finish in the top 6 of Div 2, finally won promotion (runners-up), and then finished around mid-table in League 1 (5th was the highest). They were also a consistently good Cup side. What they lacked was a creative genius - if only Hagan had been 10 years younger, or Currie 10 years older...
Since that era there have been more downs than ups, but we are now back in a similar place to the late 50s, on the fringe of the promotion race in the second tier. So much has improved (stadium, pitch), and McCabe, Wilder, Sharp have re-created the sense of unity and connection between club and fans. We have a good and committed team, without individual stars and big egos. My wish would be that Wilder in particular is given time to develop that feeling of unity; we are never going back to a first team of 11 regular players (though it almost felt like it last season), but a tight-knit squad of committed players, with the very best of the academy players developing a career here, could produce a solid platform for several years, re-creating something of the spirit of the 'good old days'. The good news for young and old alike is that we are in one of those moments where things might, just might, be going our way...