January departures

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Hoping we can get rid of players such as..

Campbell
Doherty
Shackleton
Ayew

*I know... who would want them? But we have to try.

And bring in some younger players that are more available.

Also wouldnt be against sending BBD back and using that loan spot from a prem winger.

In reality I can see burrows, One sold.

More than likely though no outs and 1 loan in (depending where we are in league).

Wilder will probably still push for McGuinness to leave but id keep him for now until end of the season (unless we hsve s replacement lined up), hes doing a job filling in when required and odd 10/20 off the bench.
Campbell is making enquiries whether his running style would qualify him for the Paralympics.
Doherty had an audition last week for the new series of the 'Invisible Man'.
An updated version of 'Kerplunk' will be based on Shackleton's body , once they can find which carpark he's currently hiding in.
I've asked if Cannon can be loaned to me for running around pointlessly with my crazy Working Cocker Spaniel.
Chong & Choudhury's hair will be harvested for stuffing cuddly toys.
All these players have attributes which cannot be overlooked
 



Campbell is making enquiries whether his running style would qualify him for the Paralympics.
Doherty had an audition last week for the new series of the 'Invisible Man'.
An updated version of 'Kerplunk' will be based on Shackleton's body , once they can find which carpark he's currently hiding in.
I've asked if Cannon can be loaned to me for running around pointlessly with my crazy Working Cocker Spaniel.
Chong & Choudhury's hair will be harvested for stuffing cuddly toys.
All these players have attributes which cannot be overlooked
Not sure about Doherty, he has to fight Shackleton for the invisible man role, but who'd see it?
 
In a perfect world we move on the following, to trim down the numbers and improve quality. But shifting a few of these won't be easy:

- Doherty & Shackleton - replace with one better RB option

- McGuiness - replace with better

- Rothwell - replace with an athletic and creative box to box player

- Chong - replace with a proper winger

- Campbell & Cannon - replace with one proven goalscorer

So that would be 8 out and 5 in.

I would add Choudury to the above list too, but Chris clearly loves him and he is our only fit RB at the moment. Ideally we see a few a few academty prospects in the matchday squad to cover injuries etc.

I also expect we will lose one of Peck or Burrows, so they will need replacing too.
 
I don't anticipate loads of action in January.
Could be a big sale potentially. Peck or Cooper. Which then could result in a few in.

Do expect us to bring in another Right back. Either on loan or transfer.
Because we cannot expect Doherty and Shackleton to play more than 10 games between them.
 
In a perfect world we move on the following, to trim down the numbers and improve quality. But shifting a few of these won't be easy:

- Doherty & Shackleton - replace with one better RB option

- McGuiness - replace with better

- Rothwell - replace with an athletic and creative box to box player

- Chong - replace with a proper winger

- Campbell & Cannon - replace with one proven goalscorer

So that would be 8 out and 5 in.

I would add Choudury to the above list too, but Chris clearly loves him and he is our only fit RB at the moment. Ideally we see a few a few academty prospects in the matchday squad to cover injuries etc.

I also expect we will lose one of Peck or Burrows, so they will need replacing too.

The thing is, Stretch , the only player we have who can continually head balls clear, when we are defending a corner, is McGuinness.

He needs an "organizer" alongside him, and that is not Tanganga. Kitching, McGuinness (for the height) and one other, let Tanganga go.

McGuinness can go in Summer, when we have more time to plan.
 
The thing is, Stretch , the only player we have who can continually head balls clear, when we are defending a corner, is McGuinness.

He needs an "organizer" alongside him, and that is not Tanganga. Kitching, McGuinness (for the height) and one other, let Tanganga go.

McGuinness can go in Summer, when we have more time to plan.

I actually think he has been better than many claim, but if we can get an upgrade we should. I don't see Tanganga being moved on as the captain, and Kitching is the best of the bunch at the moment.
 
In a perfect world we move on the following, to trim down the numbers and improve quality. But shifting a few of these won't be easy:

- Doherty & Shackleton - replace with one better RB option

- McGuiness - replace with better

- Rothwell - replace with an athletic and creative box to box player

- Chong - replace with a proper winger

- Campbell & Cannon - replace with one proven goalscorer

So that would be 8 out and 5 in.

I would add Choudury to the above list too, but Chris clearly loves him and he is our only fit RB at the moment. Ideally we see a few a few academty prospects in the matchday squad to cover injuries etc.

I also expect we will lose one of Peck or Burrows, so they will need replacing too.
i think youve hit on the 8 that need moving on if we can all of them are only bench warmers anyway
 
Given the 26 man squad, with 25 who are 21 and over, for any January additions there would have to be departures. Otherwise we’d be paying a senior pro a full wage to not play.

Who are your candidates?

Keeper - can’t see any movement there.

Defence - if Wilder doesn’t fancy McGuinness then I’m you can imagine us open to offloading him once more. Tanganga, for me his contract still worries me. Surely this is the last chance to maximise his value and replace with a player on a longer deal? Conversely Seriki and Burrows also move into final 18 months so they must be vulnerable if we don’t make headway.

Midfield - having effectively made the no confidence list, you’d say Rothwell and Jairo could be vulnerable. As he’s persevered with Choudhury through a difficult spell, you’d imagine when right backs are readily available he might be in the mix for midfield. I’m sure we’d be open for Chong too.

Forwards - this is an interesting one. Can’t see Bamford, Ayew and BBD off anywhere. But teams pushing may fancy Cannon in the same way we did and with money for the stand and Dore needed, it may be a sensible move in my opinion especially if whatever chance we do this window still doesn’t kick him on too much. I don’t see him ever being worth any more than what we paid. You’d also have to say Campbell could be offloaded but who’d take him?

Any thoughts?
Definitely will be movements with the Keepers or at least an extension as Faxon is on loan to Boston until January, so he will return. With him only playing against U21 Academy teams in the cup, not quite sure where he will go. Unless a National League/North team gets a keeper injury, he could in theory go back to Boston but I really don't see what it is doing for his development they are 19th in the National League currently and he isn't getting any 1st team match action other than being on the bench.

Looking at the last window, there was interest in Burrows (not the end of the world), Cannon (Bids apparently from PNE) but not sure if that will materialise and Peck (West Ham amongst others) that would be the biggest dent in terms of footballer to lose. Seriki possibly might not get any bids unless he seriously impresses in the next few weeks after being injured buyers might be put off. There are few in the academy that could replace certain players however our CB partnership needs work.

When you look at the out of contract 2027/Back to parent club loan deals it makes bleak reading for how the squad will reshape.
Kitching
BBD
Seriki (https://www.sufc.co.uk/news/2024/february/01/new-contract-for-femi/)
Donovan
Choudhury
RND
Jairo (option of further year)
Phillips
Doherty (option of further year)
Bamford (option of further year)
Shackleton
Ayew
Rothwell
Davies
 
If the season isn’t going anywhere and we don’t look like being relegated then perhaps January is a good time to sell him, if we’re intent on getting the best price we can for him which I’m sure we’d be acutely aware of.

Personally don’t feel we’ll be clear of any relegation worries until much later in the season so it’s a definite keep for me. I think if someone offers £10-12m plus add ons then we’d find it very hard to turn down knowing that the player will probably push for a move too.

To add onto this, January values are increased. I said in the Summer we should sell Peck and still think we need to sell him this January to get a very good fee to be able to re-invest in the squad.
 
If the season isn’t going anywhere and we don’t look like being relegated then perhaps January is a good time to sell him, if we’re intent on getting the best price we can for him which I’m sure we’d be acutely aware of.

Personally don’t feel we’ll be clear of any relegation worries until much later in the season so it’s a definite keep for me. I think if someone offers £10-12m plus add ons then we’d find it very hard to turn down knowing that the player will probably push for a move too.
With the Play offs now down to 8th position - I'd imagine the majority of the league will have some chance of something (be that play offs or relegation) up until at least March
 



To add onto this, January values are increased. I said in the Summer we should sell Peck and still think we need to sell him this January to get a very good fee to be able to re-invest in the squad.
Its a fair point but do you really trust wilder with the dosh ?
 
The thing is, Stretch , the only player we have who can continually head balls clear, when we are defending a corner, is McGuinness.

He needs an "organizer" alongside him, and that is not Tanganga. Kitching, McGuinness (for the height) and one other, let Tanganga go.

McGuinness can go in Summer, when we have more time to plan.
I agree , we need Guinness height for now.
Tanganga has flattered to deceive and if we could get a fee for him , I'd sell.
Kitching has at least some brains , but whether he's our missing "organiser" , I can't say yet.

For a club that had Basham , Wright , Egan , JoC , Souttar , Anel etc , I can't believe how we've ended up with such a deficiency at CB.
 
I agree , we need Guinness height for now.
Tanganga has flattered to deceive and if we could get a fee for him , I'd sell.
Kitching has at least some brains , but whether he's our missing "organiser" , I can't say yet.

For a club that had Basham , Wright , Egan , JoC , Souttar , Anel etc , I can't believe how we've ended up with such a deficiency at CB.
mcguinness is ok in a back 3 and thats it a liability in a back 4 which imo is the system we should be using with seriki(when fit) and burrows/mcallum as wing backs that way we would have a solid 3 in midfield and possibly allow donovan up front just behind a lone striker also think kitching if we could get him next summer make an excellent captain think we would get more out of tanganga without the captains responsibility
 
Don't know their contract status, but I'd let go/ hopefully get a fee for.: Doherty
Shackleton
Ayew
Rothwell
Reidewald
RND
BBD
Campbell
Faxon

Any monies raised Maybe try for someone like Connor Roberts (RB)
Exchange Cannon for Wooton or Salech etc
 
Coventry Sold there 2 best players and 2 years later won the league?
I'm not sure if they were Coventrys best players but I take your point.

The difference there was that they reinvested the money in quality replacements.

We rarely get the luxury of the money back to build the squad and as my original post said if you sell your best players you go backwards.

Over the years at BDTBL, Mick Jones, Tony Currie, Glen Cockrill, Brian Deane, Micheal Brown, Iliman Ndyaye. There are many others but all these resulted in relegation after they were sold because the money was not adequately reinvested.

"Let history be the guide to shape the decisions of the future"
 
I'm not sure if they were Coventrys best players but I take your point.

The difference there was that they reinvested the money in quality replacements.

We rarely get the luxury of the money back to build the squad and as my original post said if you sell your best players you go backwards.

Over the years at BDTBL, Mick Jones, Tony Currie, Glen Cockrill, Brian Deane, Micheal Brown, Iliman Ndyaye. There are many others but all these resulted in relegation after they were sold because the money was not adequately reinvested.

"Let history be the guide to shape the decisions of the future"
We sold Currie after we got relegated, got relegation three years after selling Cockerill and we didnt get relegation after selling Brown, we got promotion 3 years later.
 
We sold Currie after we got relegated, got relegation three years after selling Cockerill and we didnt get relegation after selling Brown, we got promotion 3 years later.
Re Currie... once he went we eventually found our way all the way into Division 4
Fair enough, to be be factually correct I should have added "got relegated or went backwards"

Dispute the words/detail, its purely semantics, the sentiment remains

"In general, sell your best players, without reinvesting, and you'll go backwards"
 
Definitely will be movements with the Keepers or at least an extension as Faxon is on loan to Boston until January, so he will return. With him only playing against U21 Academy teams in the cup, not quite sure where he will go. Unless a National League/North team gets a keeper injury, he could in theory go back to Boston but I really don't see what it is doing for his development they are 19th in the National League currently and he isn't getting any 1st team match action other than being on the bench.

Looking at the last window, there was interest in Burrows (not the end of the world), Cannon (Bids apparently from PNE) but not sure if that will materialise and Peck (West Ham amongst others) that would be the biggest dent in terms of footballer to lose. Seriki possibly might not get any bids unless he seriously impresses in the next few weeks after being injured buyers might be put off. There are few in the academy that could replace certain players however our CB partnership needs work.

When you look at the out of contract 2027/Back to parent club loan deals it makes bleak reading for how the squad will reshape.
Kitching
BBD
Seriki (https://www.sufc.co.uk/news/2024/february/01/new-contract-for-femi/)
Donovan
Choudhury
RND
Jairo (option of further year)
Phillips
Doherty (option of further year)
Bamford (option of further year)
Shackleton
Ayew
Rothwell
Davies
Jesus Christ , you can measure the incompetence of dem Blades - when you compare the £half a billion we've chewed through - to what we've ended up with - a squad worth the square root of feck-all and the need to find players next summer , just to be able to field a team.
Still , at least we have an option on Doherty , the invisible man 😂.
If there was a league table for clubs who've been in the PL twice recently and wasted a fortune , we'd be clear top.
I do believe that a couple of half-wits chosen at random could have done better than Bettis & Wilder.
Repeating the Brewster mistake with Cannon ought to be an imprisonable offence under the Insanity Act.
 
Jesus Christ , you can measure the incompetence of dem Blades - when you compare the £half a billion we've chewed through - to what we've ended up with - a squad worth the square root of feck-all and the need to find players next summer , just to be able to field a team.
Still , at least we have an option on Doherty , the invisible man 😂.
If there was a league table for clubs who've been in the PL twice recently and wasted a fortune , we'd be clear top.
I do believe that a couple of half-wits chosen at random could have done better than Bettis & Wilder.
Repeating the Brewster mistake with Cannon ought to be an imprisonable offence under the Insanity Act.
100% it’s crazy! I think Wilder really needs to work out his formation for attack and defence that are interchangeable as one whether that’s a 5-3-2 or whatever variants of this. Once he has done that he needs to select the current squad to fit the round holes and only get players in, if they fit the system. Fair enough if you have a RWB that can also play RW but can’t assume as a lot of problems with Cannon have been playing out of position
 
I'm not sure if they were Coventrys best players but I take your point.

The difference there was that they reinvested the money in quality replacements.

We rarely get the luxury of the money back to build the squad and as my original post said if you sell your best players you go backwards.

Over the years at BDTBL, Mick Jones, Tony Currie, Glen Cockrill, Brian Deane, Micheal Brown, Iliman Ndyaye. There are many others but all these resulted in relegation after they were sold because the money was not adequately reinvested.

"Let history be the guide to shape the decisions of the future"

Name two better players that year that were better than Gyokeres and Hamer for Coventry... I'll wait. I was absolutely over the moon to get Hamer!
 
Name two better players that year that were better than Gyokeres and Hamer for Coventry... I'll wait. I was absolutely over the moon to get Hamer!
OK, point made, I'd forgotten about Gyokeres. I thought you were referring to Hamer and O'Hare.
Ben Sheaf was class for Coventry at that time and I was classing him above O'Hare.

My point is still valid that if you just sell your best players you only go backwards.
The only way it works is if you reinvest in quality replacements
 
My point is still valid that if you just sell your best players you only go backwards.
The only way it works is if you reinvest in quality replacements

Generally selling players and replacing them with those of lower quality is going to effect a teams performance and results.

I dont suppose its what any club chooses to do unless their hand is forced through financial restrictions, happens in the PL and EFL. ( Villa and Newcastle for example).

In fairness with Coventry they could sell and the sales were a bit of a windfall to re invest.

They hadn't just had the cliff edge of losing parachute payments to overcome .
 
In reality yes if you sell your best players then it's a gamble weather you are able to re-invest correctly. We are in a market where it's cheaper to find a player in the Danish topflight than it is to find a player with the same stats in league 2.

This is where I do get annoyed with CW with not using the European market to our advantage.

Even the Japanese league! The amount of good quality Japanese players going under our radar is a joke. They beat Brazil last week and performed very well in the world cup.
 



All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom