So basically down to perspective which is exactly what I said in my post, when I was younger they were 2 divisions above us and an established top flight team then the roles reversed around 1990 and by 1993 they reversed again and probably for the next 7 years, so in my 40 years of following united we have both been predominantly championship teams with the odd season in league 1 and odd season in the Premier league, they have still spent mores seasons in the Premier league despite not being in it for 25 years and it only being 33 years old which kind of says it all, and they have been to 3 cup finals and won 1 and played in Europe in the last 35 years we have in the same timeframe won league 1, so for me yes they are slightly bigger but no better
Agree about perspective but that’s the point.
People at Jordan’s age…..50 years old and above will think Wednesday are bigger.
Where as people under 50 will think United are bigger.
The facts show overall, from 1890 to date…Wednesday edge United in virtually every big club stat but it’s very close….closer than what some people think.
Seasons in the top flight Sheff Wed 66 seasons Sheff Utd 63
Major trophies won Sheff Wed 7 Sheff Utd 5
Seasons in Europe Sheff Wed 2 Sheff Utd 0
Historical average attendances 21.5K Sheff Utd 19.5K
However this century, since 2000, the last 26 years…..which is quite a large sample size.
United edge Wednesday in every big club stat, bigger attendances, better league and cup record, better finances, etc.
So it depends how much weighting/ importance is given to recent history.
Surely recent history is more important that something that happened 100 years ago?