Referee

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?


It was a dive. To be fair to Sky they called it right. The refs positioning was as shocking as it was all night. He guessed.
No excuse for the linesman looking directly at it with a good view though. Then again what is the point in linesmen these days? May as well scrap them. All they do is ins and outs and odd offside (which they don't even do that in the prem). & even ins & outs they wait for ref to signal which way.
 
On Pecks disallowed goal, he couldn't wait to disallow that. Could you imagine him disallowing that at Anfield if Liverpool had equalised with that same goal in the last minute? No, me neither.
Could u imagine him sending klopp or pep off for booting ball oht of frustration?

Could u imagine him not giving the blatant push on haaland or salah as they was about to break into the box 1 v 1 or a blatant drag down wirh 2 hands around on van dyke. Could u imagine 85th min at city/ arsenal or Liverpool the ref doing 8 yards for wall then to recount and still only doing 8 at a blatantly. Could u imagine him giving penalty that Allison has pulled out of for the player to dive. Could you imagine him not booking opposition players against those teams for consistently kicking ball away.

Nope neither can I.
 
The pacing out for the wall was ridiculous.

He took one full pace, realised that he was never going to get another 9 of those in, so made the rest smaller and still only got up to 8 with the kop counting them out for him.

That's not incompetence - although that shouldn't be an excuse at this level, it's cheating or soiling yourself when the bigger boys in the wall said no.

If they want consistency and accuracy a laser measure tool fits easily in the pocket.
 
I've never seen a ref so blatantly bent in my life
I hope he wasn't bent but he was certainly incompetent. Watching the video of him counting out the steps, his final step was about half the length of the previous 7 - and even they had been short steps and only 8 in total!

If there is some sort investigation into events last night, I'll guarantee it will be looking at CW's behaviour and the refereeing will be ignored.
 
The pacing out for the wall was ridiculous.

He took one full pace, realised that he was never going to get another 9 of those in, so made the rest smaller and still only got up to 8 with the kop counting them out for him.

That's not incompetence - although that shouldn't be an excuse at this level, it's cheating or soiling yourself when the bigger boys in the wall said no.

If they want consistency and accuracy a laser measure tool fits easily in the pocket.
When he was originally marking it out, he allowed the Southampton wall to dictate where he drew his line, rather than moving them back. Then compounded it with his ridiculous pacing to “prove” his point, and didn’t make them stand behind it anyway!
 
It's bad enough only pacing 8 steps but when each step is only about 3/4 of a yard...
Full weight bellend
The players pointed out that the cut of the grass is in 6 yard strips he placed the ball a yard out from the edge and the wall yard from the other edge 8 yards ,then did 8 steps .not sure how he could ever ref again .
 

The players pointed out that the cut of the grass is in 6 yard strips he placed the ball a yard out from the edge and the wall yard from the other edge 8 yards ,then did 8 steps .not sure how he could ever ref again .
I was doing my nut over the pitch markings. It made it so obvious the ref was wrong and him recounting his steps reemphasised it
 
I was half expecting them to follow this up by giving us Matthew Donogue on Saturday but we got Gavin Ward (he did our cup game at Birmingham).
 
On Pecks disallowed goal, he couldn't wait to disallow that. Could you imagine him disallowing that at Anfield if Liverpool had equalised with that same goal in the last minute? No, me neither.
He blew the whistle before Peck "scored"

No celebration from me when the ball went in.
 
The players pointed out that the cut of the grass is in 6 yard strips he placed the ball a yard out from the edge and the wall yard from the other edge 8 yards ,then did 8 steps .not sure how he could ever ref again .

Though when Hamer took a free kick earlier the 'ref' went and moved the ball 4" because Hamer had not placed it in the centre of his spray mark.

Not 4" back but to one side...
 
Seriously, it's about time some of the refs in this league and the PL start getting reprimanded.

At the moment most refs seem to think they ref every game perfectly, including their officials some of whom seem to struggle to keep up with play and seem to just guess whether its offside or a foul.
Could this be a ploy to get VAR into the championship?
 
Though when Hamer took a free kick earlier the 'ref' went and moved the ball 4" because Hamer had not placed it in the centre of his spray mark.

Not 4" back but to one side...
Yes I commented at the time ! The ref is a joke on us ! just where do they get them from .After the disallowed goal the free kick was taken at least ten yards forward than whre the supposed push took place !more or less on the goal line ! I think the ref had gone by then.
Alan Knill commented afterwoods ! " maybe the game was too big for him"
Knilly was being kind.
Having said all this we are in peril of being in a dog fight to stay up.
 
He was a prick of the highest order but got all the big decisions right barring Ogbene - that was a definite shove in the back. Linesman should have seen that 100%.

It was a pen. It was a foul on the keeper and Wilder deserved to be sent off - he’ll never learn.
 
Guys, we didn't lose because of the referee.......... we gave this game away ourselves...
Debatable. He gives a dubious penalty.( Ok it was missed) He can't count to ten. He disallows a goal that we've all seen given numerous times. Mee yellow card. Ogbene fouled in front of his eyes.
He was incompetent at best. Way out of his depth at least.
 
For the pen, the ball is going away from the goal for one, as the Southampton player touches it to his left, heading out of play from the weight of the touch (which did happen).

Two, Cooper pulls out of challenge (Likely because he realised point number one). He turned his back to the player and ducks his head quickly to protect himself.

Three, Their player then topples over Cooper due to momentum and no where for either player to go. he then has no choice but to "dive" over Cooper almost in slow motion like it was half-assed. It doesn't make sense that Cooper thought "Alright I'll leave the ball and just go for the man instead" in the position he was in. Manufactured penalty (hence the various cries of "Cheat" from the Kop who saw straight through it)

He's on the dartboard now with Michael Oliver and Graham Poll.
 

Hamer was apoplectic at how close the wall was. What a joke.
I couldn’t understand why Hamer didn’t move the ball back. Would have been a better position to get it over and down . That said, the “highly qualified professional referee destined for the EPL and beyond” would no doubt have booked him.
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom