Cooper or Dyche

[Bertie Mee]

We should arrange a meeting with Cooper and lock him in a room and not let him out until he says yes. It would be perfect for him, and us he just needs to be convinced as such.

Dyche would no doubt do a job but the football would be BAF

Sausage would be interesting if not only for the hilarity it would cause across the city especially if he did well.

As for Wilder - that ship has sailed, let’s move on.

 

[Wards]

It doesn’t, but I think that money would better deployed making Cooper an offer he couldn’t refuse.

I would well imagine both sums would be available if needed

 

[Rodley]

Cooper was approached before. He had no interest then. Why would he come to a club like us now?
Serious question.

It’s already been confirmed this didn’t happen.

 

[HarryHaslam]

This must be one of the only times that Cooper has been seen as the attractive option from 2 choices

 

[William Large]

I want us to win.

I’m at the point where I couldn’t give a fuck how we play. It’s not a beauty contest.

I want to see us come away from games with 3 points.

If anyone wants aesthetics then go watch Dancing with the Stars.

This supposed improvement on Wilder has been an abject failure.

So pick me a winner. I don’t care about how many times we play well. It’s a results business. We played well and at least well enough 31 times last year because we won. That’s all that matters.

Don’t complicate it, pick someone who wins at all costs, all sorts of games, rain or shine.

Best three out there are Dyche, Wilder and Cooper. Get one of them and we’ll be fine.

 

[Mumbo]

Cooper now…but if the owners sit with there finger up their arses nursing their ego
untill we are staring relegation in the face,then probably Dyche.

 

[blAdes96]

All that matter is results, I'd rather be "boring" and win games 1-0 than what we are currently experience.

I'm not against a Dyche, or Cooper. Fine. This experiment has been dire, the Spanish Slav and I'm sorry it's not worked for him but we can't afford to have more of that.

Having a gaffer who knows the club, core of the squad and can get results for us, so be it. Winning is ALL that matters. So, even bringing Wilder back. Shouldn't have sacked him anyway...

The people who bitch and moan and slander him, suck it up. We just need to get points on the board.

 

[HOT CURRIE 10]

And yet we came 3rd, got 90 points and had a threadbare squad until January. Pretty remarkable considering managers were making a mockery of him eh

And still got nothing for it after a usual backwards retreat after 35 minutes in the play off. Leave it alone,your old girlfriend is still single,having a good time without you in the Summer house,thinking what could have been .

 

[Berkshire Blade]

And still got nothing for it after a usual backwards retreat after 35 minutes in the play off. Leave it alone,your old girlfriend is still single,having a good time without you in the Summer house,thinking what could have been .

I would take any season we have had under Wilder in the championship and even the first relegation to this crap and so would you.

Where did this Chrissy Wilder touch you to be so against it because if a totally random guy came in and did the same everyone would be very happy

 

[HOT CURRIE 10]

I would take any season we have had under Wilder in the championship and even the first relegation to this crap and so would you.

Where did this Chrissy Wilder touch you to be so against it because if a totally random guy came in and did the same everyone would be very happy

I would take the Chris Wilder mark 1 any time,the best I’ve ever seen us,since his return it’s been dire and clueless. I remember him waving the white flag a few times in the premier after Hecky especially against Arsenal. Excruciating. Yes,he did well to get to 90 points last season but he had the squad to do it,even before the transfer window in January. I love seeing good football but there was hardly any of that,his cringeworthy behaviour was embarrassing and financially hurtful,the use of players in wrong positions,retreat after going in front, making Robinson club captain and continually playing him. With that squad,we should have pissed it but in many critical situations he wasn’t up to it. I really don’t like what is happening at the moment from seemingly a ridiculous appointment,we have league 1 written all over it as he is totally out of his depth,it’s blatant and the players are showing they don’t like it either. The ‘totally random guy ‘ is certainly not at our club at present. This blandness we need to get away from. End of essay.

 

[Berkshire Blade]

. Yes,he did well to get to 90 points last season but he had the squad to do it

I really think people forget how half built the squad was first half of the season ( especially with the blaster injury) Peck made 45 appearances and he is miles away from what a promotion chasing championship side needs same with Brooks and seriki who got 25 or so each

 

[Brian Deane]

Is Robins available

 

[Colombia Blade]

Ah, the free-flowing football of a Sean Dyche side.

Don’t get me wrong, I think Selles is useless, but I certainly don’t want him replacing with Sean Dyche. I’m sure he’s a lovely man, but his football isn’t. Admittedly it’s better than losing to everyone, but personally he’s not the one for me.

In the Premier League yes, and he worked miracles keeping Burnley up playing like that - something a club our size with our resources would also have to do to have a chance of survival. But in his two full seasons in the Championship, Burnley scored the third highest and then the highest amount of goals in the league as well as bossing it defensively. I think people forget about his time in the Championship (where we are) and his reputation comes almost entirely from his Premier League campaigns where he had no choice but to play that way

 

[CaptainMorgans]

They've tried old school, then they tried the modern philosophical type, so next it'll be the big name ex-pro.

Welcome, Steven Gerrard/Michael Carrick.

I'll probably get crucified for this, but I really like the idea of Southgate.

I think he could unite the club, create a great dressing room atmosphere etc.

But he was linked with the Man Utd job not long back. I doubt we could afford him, or he'd entertain it.

My no.1 choice would be Steve Cooper, but it sounds like he wouldn't be interested either.

 

[Booker4]

Some have suggested Carrick?! What's he done other to even be mentioned over Dave Challinor for example that has multiple promotions with unfashionable clubs.

Wilder should definitely be in the mix too because he's a damn good manager and knows many of the players and did well before.

Cooper and Dyche great but doubt either would consider it but might be wrong.

Rohl is clearly a talented manager that should at the very least be interviewed.

I think the Pompey manager is a good shout but not sure we'd get him. Please not Gary O'Neil.

 

[Blade58]

Dyche because points make prizes

 

[DW Blade]

They've tried old school, then they tried the modern philosophical type, so next it'll be the big name ex-pro.

Welcome, Steven Gerrard/Michael Carrick.

I would be happy with Steven Gerrard. I think he commands the room and players would listen to him. How could you not listen and learn from a player of his ability and his list of honours.
On the flip side do we need an old head such as Dyche to go back to basics, set us up so we don’t look like a piece of Swiss cheese in the centre of midfield and make our wide players track back and build from there. Hope something comes quickly as we don’t want to enter years of mid table obscurity.

 

[bigblade]

Even Tommy cooper would do better..

 

[Large Mendonca]

 

[nopigfansintown]

It's such a frustrating question as we already had the perfect antidote on board last season. He'd have only left for a big four club in the future and did a magnificent job all things considered. There really isn't a likely better scenario for us than what we already had. Even if we get a good one we're a short term stepping stone to a WHAM, Everton etc and then you're back playing manager roulette. The one window rebuild last season to make us competitive was miraculous and with another summer building on great foundations, with more permanents... The people calling him in such disrespectful ways throughout last season must feel really embarrassed now.

As frustrating as it is at the moment I'd give Selles another half a dozen games. Sacking managers is expensive and I'd feel even more sick if we'd unnecessarily paid of Wilder and then Selles without even giving him a proper chance. There's not much to hang your hat on so far admittedly... Looking at who might be available if it goes to shit I'd probably go sausage or Cooper . CW won't be back imo. That would take an enormous amount of humility from the owners few people possess.

 

[madeinsheffield]

Jose is free , he doesn't need the money but it'd be back to basics with a project for him , but at least life would be interesting

But dyche all the way for me

Jose could even buy a big stake in us. Has it been done before?

 

[LBA_Blade]

Dyche at 3/1 and Cooper 7/1 to replace Selles if sacked. However although stranger things have happened it would be a bit of a shit house type of move to give you a job let you train your “employees” to your style for a month before getting rid of most of the best and not replacing them for 3 weeks before giving 2 days training and expect you to deliver immediate results.

If they get rid they have to do now with a full explanation also a press release signing a new manager tomorrow/Monday along with a couple of “his type of signings” before the international window. Have an abroad training camp to take away distractions and the board need to seriously think about apologising for getting it so wrong. If not you give Selles until the October international break and the fixtures in between to pick up 2 or 3 results and start to look like the players that have been picked are with him. Apart from the craziness against Bristol although today could have been easily 4-0 we have only been losing 1-0, the major problem lies with getting the ball up the other end and creating chances although we got better and ended up having 8 shots none were on target which simply isn’t good enough. Under that do or die promotion season with Hecky we had a few snatch and grabs and got lucky but if you don’t hit the target you can’t do it. 8 corners today too

 

[Tony_Kaufman]

Cooper over Dyche everytime.

 

[Harry's Game]

Only one choice

 

[Broomhall Blade]

Dyche for me. More suited to SUFC

And there lies the problem.

 

[Broomhall Blade]

Wilder No
Dyche No
Cooper No

Don't get the fascination with Cooper he has one promotion to his name when backed by a rich owner but ultimately failed at Forest, how long did he last at Leicester ? he was even under pressure at Swansea.

Dyche is just Wilder but without the pissed up in the boozer singing about rival managers, boring football.

Wilder boring football, no plan B, negative substitutions, absolutely useless when given any substantial amount of money to spend.

There are other managers out there other than those three, ask yourself this why are they all unemployed.

 

[JayGreen17]

Cooper, please for the love of god COH, go get him!

 

[JayGreen17]

Wilder No
Dyche No
Cooper No

Don't get the fascination with Cooper he has one promotion to his name when backed by a rich owner but ultimately failed at Forest, how long did he last at Leicester ? he was even under pressure at Swansea.

Dyche is just Wilder but without the pissed up in the boozer singing about rival managers, boring football.

Wilder boring football, no plan B, negative substitutions, absolutely useless when given any substantial amount of money to spend.

There are other managers out there other than those three, ask yourself this why are they all unemployed.

Go in then, you’ve criticised these - who has a better record that you’d choose - than three promotion winning mongers?

 

[LondonRoad]

This must be one of the only times that Cooper has been seen as the attractive option from 2 choices

And there lies the problem.

In what way?

 

[Sportbilly /Detroit Blade]

Jose could even buy a big stake in us. Has it been done before?

I will chop my cock off at half time in the centre circle if Jose is involved in anything at our club.