He's talented, I'm sure he'll carve out a decent career. But you're right that no Stoke fan would want him back because apart from a few fleeting glimpses, he just didn't have any impact on games. Being a young developing player, he could burst through this season in the right team but it's a bit of a gamble. We've recently had a number of promising young players on loan who were flops with us but went on to star for other teams - Alfie Doughty, Harwood-Bellis, Delap.. there are others.. you have to catch them at the right point.