Been going since around 83-84
My list of worst to best of the main keepers that played would go something like:
Leaning - thought he was awful. Small and any high balls would lead to goals
Howard - he had maybe 4 or 5 decent games to start his career and since then he has been abject and every time he comes in he makes an error
Simonsen - although decent when on loan; he made so many errors and also was shocking on crosses
Bunn - never have I seen a keeper manage to miss so many shots!
Tomlinson - young and made some spectacular saves but often made errors when I watched him
Gerrard - only a back up but recall more errors or lack of communication than great saves
Kite - not the best as above. He was another keeper that did not make saves!
Benstead - started ok but got worse and Bassett replaced him with Tracey
Burridge - made some ricks but a real character who made some spectacular saves
Bennett - never really let us down and thought he was a steady keeper
Long - improving, Good shot stopper but needs to communicate and dominate more
Waugh - he was ok and prob did better in lower leagues before I saw him and was replaced eventually
Rees - Short spell but looked a top keeper and but for what happened would have had a really good and long career
Kenny - despite way he left and some odd mistakes he was a good keeper and if he had ever taken game seriously could have been even better
Kelly - superb shot stopper and had some unbelievable individual displays. Felt he just lacked that domination a top, top class keeper needed
Tracey - controversial but I preferred him to AK. I know he had some 'brains of a rocking horse moments - Bassett' but he was superb as we won 2 promotions and but he was a top class keeper and could command his box, take crosses, brave and made those saves you did not expect.
Also played (again in order of worst to first):
Baxter - worst 45 mins of a Utd player ever?
Day - played one game a 0-3 at Wimbledon (or Palace as it was then) and was awful
De Vogt - looked dreadful. 6 foot and could not catch
Davison - remember him being part of the man city 6-0 was it?
Fettis - did better than Baxter and then he too looked shaky
Barnes - barely played
Hansbury - as above
Talia - as above
Wright - poor when he played and looked a far cry from good keeper that was at Ipswich
Ikeme - thought he was ok and doing well for Wolves now
Mercer - quite small but a decent shot stopper
Goram - end of career but could see why he had played top level
Segers - he was excellent in his brief spell at the Lane on loan but later events saw him not as liked by us lot!
Missed anyone? Carl Muggleton played one game as an outfield sub!