I might be a bit controversial here lads but I only saw Hodgy from 1966 onwards and from what I saw of him live he didn't fill me with confidence.What about Worksop's finest - Alan Hodgkinson? Capped five times for England has to be worth something.
He was small for a keeper and his handling especially crosses was poor I don't know whether it was them green cotton gloves but compared to Gordon Banks , Pat Jennings ,Tommy Lawrence, Gordon West he was never in that class.
How he performed pre 66 I don't know