Blades Squad Values

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

coaxingstar71

First 10 yards are in the head
Joined
Apr 19, 2015
Messages
7,429
Reaction score
13,562
Location
Norton, Sheffield
I think this has kinda been done before but not for a while and I think with a new manager coming in and talk of an overhaul or refresh required, it's perhaps quite relevant at the moment. Just thinking about our squad and as we know most of them are still under contract so in order for most of them to leave, we'd be looking to get some fees. I wondered what people thought about a. how much do you think is reasonable or realistic for particular players, and b. how much do you think the club might sell them for, based on their age, contract length, potential release clauses in some cases and their current 'stock' if you like.

Here are my initial thoughts :

Ramsdale £25-30m - bought for £18.5m and we'd have to be looking at more considering the latter half of the season and on fringe of England squad.
Baldock £5-8m - Celtic were apparently interested and I think his stock remains fairly high.
Stevens £1-2m - wrong side of 30 and in appalling form. However still an Ireland international.
Basham £500k - actually not worth selling as is invaluable to have around.
Egan £8-10m - probably would have said double that at the end of last season. Ireland regular these days and hope we wouldn't sell anyway.
O'Connell £15-20m - difficult as hasn't played, serious injury will put suitors off and now a championship player again. Hope he comes back better than ever but no guarantees and can't actually see other clubs taking the risk until he's back to his best.
Fleck £4-7m - not in good form, but still an international, albeit by skin of his teeth.
Berge £15-30m - big question about a release clause. Obvious potential to leave and would hope to at least recoup what we paid.
Norwood £1-2m - same as Stevens really, apart from retired from international duty. he could of course be key again in the championship
Brewster £15-20m - how much can Liverpool buy him back for? I'll drive him there myself! Seriously though, hopefully he can find some confidence, score goals and be a big player for us.
McBurnie £10-15m - don't think currently we'd get anywhere near what we paid. If Jokanovic can get a tune out of him and Brewster, there is potentially a big partnership there.
McGoldrick £500k - same as Basham really. His worth in terms of experience and ability far outweighs his saleable value.
Sharp £100k - not worth selling and again, should be handy to have around to help the younger players
Burke £4-6m - really difficult to predict. Currently if someone came in with a decent offer, I think we should bite their hand off.
Mousset £4-5m - at the moment don't see anyone taking him off our hands. If he could get back to that player from Oct-Dec 19, he'd tear the champ a new one, albeit in bursts of 60 minutes!

There's a few more obviously but hope that will get a discussion going.
 



Don't think you're far off with a lot of those - but I would put Moussett and Burke in the £1-2M catregory. If anyone offered £4M for the pair I would snap their hand off.
JOC's value is totally dependent on how he recovers. It is step y step - I just want to see him play again in the Championship, that should be a good level for him to get form and fitness back. As good as he is, he wouldn't be ready for Premier League football for a while.
Hopefully he'll get back and will have a good second half to the season - as we push on towards the top 2.
If that happens, his value goes back up to the £35M + point again.
 
Didn't Adam Webster move to Brighton from Bristol City for 20m? (No PL experience)

Egan and O'Connell are proven 20 million pound PL defenders in my eyes.
 
Mousett is worth nothing.

Hecky bombed him out in the end and our new man will do likewise.

He'll end up out on loan with us paying most of his wages.
 
Mousett has more PL goals for us than McBurnie but some consider McBurnie to be worth 15m and Mousett to only be worth 2mill at the same age.

Then the same people value Burke 3 times more than Mousset. :oops:

Baffling.
 
Mousset. Anybody fancy him to come good if he stays?. New man in charge could do him good. Personally think there is a player in there. Lose the chip on his shoulder, knuckle down, lose some timber, buy a Punto, he could be a hero again for a couple of weeks same as 2 seasons ago. Come on Moose show us what you can do. Or bugger off.
 
I think when you consider the need to trim the wage bill, I'd pay any club 10p to take Mousset.
 
Didn't Adam Webster move to Brighton from Bristol City for 20m? (No PL experience)

Egan and O'Connell are proven 20 million pound PL defenders in my eyes.
One of them yes more than 20 if he returns fit and at the same level
The others don’t be silly
 
I don't buy into tagging prices on players this way.. I prefer to look at what a like for like replacement would cost and go with that figure.
 
Bash, Billy and McGoldrick will go on frees in recognition of their service to the club IMO
I sincerely hope neither Bash or Didzy leave and unless the new manager 'doesn't fancy them' I think they will both play regularly next season. With Billy now 35, I think his game time will be even more limited, so could see him going. He's also quite capable of proving me wrong and scoring 20 goals!

One I didn't mention was Jebbison who after impressing in a few starts at the end of the season, apparently has some big clubs sniffing around. I don't think United should sell as presumably we don't need to and the lad obviously has huge potential, however every player has his price and I could see the club considering anywhere between £15-30m but most likely a deal with add-ons and percentage sell-on clauses if the board have any sense.
 
Mousett has more PL goals for us than McBurnie but some consider McBurnie to be worth 15m and Mousett to only be worth 2mill at the same age.

Then the same people value Burke 3 times more than Mousset. :oops:

Baffling.
Both Burke and McBurnie have international caps whereas Mousset does not. Arguably both Burke and McBurnie are more experienced players with more games under their belt.

It wouldn't affect their values that much but doesn't McBurnie have 1 more league goal than Mousset? I think they both scored 6 in 2019/20 and Mcburnie got 1 last season.

I'm just guessing on the values, I don't know and of course any player is only worth what someone is willing to pay for them.
 
Players are only worth what teams are willing to pay for.
Whats the point of posting if you are just going to come up with a throwaway comment like that.
I reckon we should hold out for 35 million for Berge.
Mousset we'd be lucky to get anything for.
Brewster, Can't see anyone paying anywhere near what we paid for him.
Burke, who knows. I wouldn't pay 100 quid for him.
 
Mousett has more PL goals for us than McBurnie but some consider McBurnie to be worth 15m and Mousett to only be worth 2mill at the same age.

Then the same people value Burke 3 times more than Mousset. :oops:

Baffling.
Mousset: 6 PL goals for us.
McBurnie: 7 PL goals for us.

Facts, eh?

Agree on Burke btw. I'd let him and Foderingham leave on frees to get them off the wage bill.
 



Bash, Billy and McGoldrick will go on frees in recognition of their service to the club IMO

I sincerely hope neither Bash or Didzy leave and unless the new manager 'doesn't fancy them' I think they will both play regularly next season. With Billy now 35, I think his game time will be even more limited, so could see him going. He's also quite capable of proving me wrong and scoring 20 goals!

One I didn't mention was Jebbison who after impressing in a few starts at the end of the season, apparently has some big clubs sniffing around. I don't think United should sell as presumably we don't need to and the lad obviously has huge potential, however every player has his price and I could see the club considering anywhere between £15-30m but most likely a deal with add-ons and percentage sell-on clauses if the board have any sense.

I agree.

Looking back I didn't mean they would go; I should have qualified by saying, "If they go"

I'm happy to have them here for another season at least
 
Blades Squad Values .....

Honesty, Cooperation, Integrity, Hardworking, Focussed, Committment.

Get those values in place and then watch the player's values increase.
 
I agree.

Looking back I didn't mean they would go; I should have qualified by saying, "If they go"

I'm happy to have them here for another season at least
Will be sad to see them go,but we need to start looking forward and laying new plans. Start a fresh ,no going back. Great days indeed but let's look forward.
For me that's where Chris Wilder failed , no signings paid off so he was stuck with the old guard. Only my thoughts.
 
Whats the point of posting if you are just going to come up with a throwaway comment like that.
I reckon we should hold out for 35 million for Berge.
Mousset we'd be lucky to get anything for.
Brewster, Can't see anyone paying anywhere near what we paid for him.
Burke, who knows. I wouldn't pay 100 quid for him.
It's not a throwaway comment at all! :eek:
No one said it before me and I think its a valid point.
To be fair your post backs up my point. :p Players values vary per person and so it is the same for each team.
Ta-da!!!!
 
It's not a throwaway comment at all! :eek:
No one said it before me and I think its a valid point.
To be fair your post backs up my point. :p Players values vary per person and so it is the same for each team.
Ta-da!!!!
So go on the, indulge me.
Do you actually have an opinion on any of the player's worth?
 
So go on the, indulge me.
Do you actually have an opinion on any of the player's worth?
Yeah okay okay, I think most players valuations have drastically lowered due to the awful season we had, only a hand full of players are probably worth near the value of what we paid for in Berge, Bogle and Ramsdale.
Burke maybe worth a penny, but I think that may be a slight overpay. :oops:
 
Yeah okay okay, I think most players valuations have drastically lowered due to the awful season we had, only a hand full of players are probably worth near the value of what we paid for in Berge, Bogle and Ramsdale.
Burke maybe worth a penny, but I think that may be a slight overpay. :oops:
 
Yeah okay okay, I think most players valuations have drastically lowered due to the awful season we had, only a hand full of players are probably worth near the value of what we paid for in Berge, Bogle and Ramsdale.
Burke maybe worth a penny, but I think that may be a slight overpay. :oops:
 
Yeah okay okay, I think most players valuations have drastically lowered due to the awful season we had, only a hand full of players are probably worth near the value of what we paid for in Berge, Bogle and Ramsdale.
Burke maybe worth a penny, but I think that may be a slight overpay. :oops:
 
Yeah okay okay, I think most players valuations have drastically lowered due to the awful season we had, only a hand full of players are probably worth near the value of what we paid for in Berge, Bogle and Ramsdale.
Burke maybe worth a penny, but I think that may be a slight overpay. :oops:
I reckon you are completely wrong there.
Berge we'll get at least what we paid, probably more.
Rammers we'd probably get 10 million more than we paid
Bogle we'd easily get our money back
Burke, I'll give you that one
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom