Two goals chalked off

[Sheff de party]

Can anyone remember us having two goals disallowed in the same game? I’m sure it’s happened before, but never when I’ve been I don’t think.

Incidentally, I was there last night and I celebrated five goals last night. 2 chalked off, 2 actual goals and Sharp’s glancing header which was right in front of me and I still thought went in, much to the delight of the Reading fans when me and about 100 others realised it had in fact gone wide.

 

[Slug]

Didn’t we beat someone (Port Vale?) 4-0 in league one and also have 4 disallowed goals on top? Remember Matt Done having a couple chalked off

 

[Sabella's Socks]

Can anyone remember us having two goals disallowed in the same game? I’m sure it’s happened before, but never when I’ve been I don’t think.

Incidentally, I was there last night and I celebrated five goals last night. 2 chalked off, 2 actual goals and Sharp’s glancing header which was right in front of me and I still thought went in, much to the delight of the Reading fans when me and about 100 others realised it had in fact gone wide.

Port Vale in the 100 points season? Won 4-0 and had four disallowed? Or summat.

 

[boo radley]

Conor Coady against Charlton, FA cup.

 

[Fanny magnet]

Isnt it funny how when these tight margins are spotted by the referee and assistants but not for the likes of Liverpool and man utd

I'm 45 now and it's been happening all my life so it cant be a anonomaly

Look at yesterday's Liverpool game 2 of their goals should have been disallowed including their crucial first but no one even mentions it



Except me

 

[Maidenhead]

Didn’t we beat someone (Port Vale?) 4-0 in league one and also have 4 disallowed goals on top? Remember Matt Done having a couple chalked off

Yeah but that was so long ago that no one can remember it

 

[Maidenhead]

Isnt it funny how when these tight margins are spotted by the referee and assistants but not for the likes of Liverpool and man utd

I'm 45 now and it's been happening all my life so it cant be a anonomaly

Look at yesterday's Liverpool game 2 of their goals should have been disallowed including their crucial first but no one even mentions it



Except me

Nowt tight about the first one, he was miles offside.

Second one a tight call but credit to the lino, he guessed right.

Also Sharp's goal was a tight call, and I'm not sure if they got it right or not but that doesn't matter now.

If Goldie had got a touch on the cross then Sharp would definitely have been offside.

Small margins.

 

[Sheff de party]

Nowt tight about the first one, he was miles offside.

Second one a tight call but credit to the lino, he guessed right.

Also Sharp's goal was a tight call, and I'm not sure if they got it right or not but that doesn't matter now.

If Goldie had got a touch on the cross then Sharp would definitely have been offside.

Small margins.

Sharp’s goal looked close to me and I haven’t seen it back yet, but at the actual game I was certain Goldie did touch it. It came across quick but it looked like he should have buried it himself to me.

 

[HodgysBrokenThumb]

Isnt it funny how when these tight margins are spotted by the referee and assistants but not for the likes of Liverpool and man utd

I'm 45 now and it's been happening all my life so it cant be a anonomaly

Look at yesterday's Liverpool game 2 of their goals should have been disallowed including their crucial first but no one even mentions it



Except me

Eddie Howe certainly mentioned it on Match of the Day...

 

[Pinchy]

Nowt tight about the first one, he was miles offside.

Second one a tight call but credit to the lino, he guessed right.

Also Sharp's goal was a tight call, and I'm not sure if they got it right or not but that doesn't matter now.

If Goldie had got a touch on the cross then Sharp would definitely have been offside.

Small margins.

I’m delighted to say the officials missed that Billy was marginally but definitely offside for our first goal.

 

[bromtom]

Isnt it funny how when these tight margins are spotted by the referee and assistants but not for the likes of Liverpool and man utd

I'm 45 now and it's been happening all my life so it cant be a anonomaly

Look at yesterday's Liverpool game 2 of their goals should have been disallowed including their crucial first but no one even mentions it



Except me

Dele Alli for his header yesterday was as offside as McGoldrick was for his goal.

That one got through.

 

[Fanny magnet]

Dele Alli for his header yesterday was as offside as McGoldrick was for his goal.

That one got through.

You normally get one or two a season.
Liverpool and man yoo get one or two a game

 

[WhiteHawk]

As has already been mentioned, we beat Port Vale 4-0 and also had 4 goals disallowed in the 100 points season.

 

[COME BACK CHED]

Any match wher Mike { look at me } Dean isthe Ref is , always worth a couple to the opposiition he would give us a minus score if he could .

 

[CopenhagenBlade]

Isnt it funny how when these tight margins are spotted by the referee and assistants but not for the likes of Liverpool and man utd

I'm 45 now and it's been happening all my life so it cant be a anonomaly

Look at yesterday's Liverpool game 2 of their goals should have been disallowed including their crucial first but no one even mentions it



Except me

I think Eddie Howe mentioned it.
Let’s see if VAR makes a difference from next season

 

[loyalblade95]

Had two chalked off against Brentford at home last season Sharp and Clarke

 

[Bladepicker]

If Goldie had got a touch on the cross then Sharp would definitely have been offside.

Sharp’s goal looked close to me and I haven’t seen it back yet, but at the actual game I was certain Goldie did touch it. It came across quick but it looked like he should have buried it himself to me.

I’m delighted to say the officials missed that Billy was marginally but definitely offside for our first goal.

Nar he was level with the ball when Bash crossed it. Hard to tell here but you can just abput see from the pitch lines.

They showed the replay from exactly along the line on Sky and it was just on. Fine margins though.

 

[Maidenhead]

Nar he was level with the ball when Bash crossed it. Hard to tell here but you can just abput see from the pitch lines.

They showed the replay from exactly along the line on Sky and it was just on. Fine margins though.

But if Goldie had got a touch he was in front and would have been offside.

Just as well he missed it by millimetres

 

[Joshp]

Last season vs Brentford. We won 2-1, first game of the season.

 

[Pinchy]

Last season vs Brentford. We won 2-1, first game of the season.

Many caps were doffed...

 

[Pinchy]

Nar he was level with the ball when Bash crossed it. Hard to tell here but you can just abput see from the pitch lines.

They showed the replay from exactly along the line on Sky and it was just on. Fine margins though.

Yes I think the defender nearest the camera may have played him on as well. However I strongly suspect Goldie feathered it. Can Reading call for Ultra Udge?