Andy Carroll is the most over-hyped and over-rated player this millenium.
Anyway, moving on, I'll tell you a little story about Billy Whitehurst.
At the tail end of his career, he was playing in Hong Kong. In one game, which turned out to be his last, he put in a tackle against one of the local players. He went in knee high, went straight through him and smashed his knee to bits. The players career was finished in an instant. The word went out and Billy was on the next plane out before he ended up as one of the ingredients in a bowl of noodle soup.
Make of that what you will. He never was and never will be a hero of mine.