You Be The Manager - Scenario #3

[Tony_Kaufman]

Scenario 3 - Right Backs

You have to decide, as the manager, who to keep, who to sell, who to loan out and post your rationale or pros and cons for each player to back up your decision, and most importantly why.

George Baldock (29) - Contract ends Jun 24

Jayden Bogle (21) - Contract ends Jun 24

Femi Seriki (19) Contract not known

(I won't include all academy players)

 

[bakeblade]

Scenario 3 - Right Backs

You have to decide, as the manager, who to keep, who to sell, who to loan out and post your rationale or pros and cons for each player to back up your decision, and most importantly why.

George Baldock (29) - Contract ends Jun 24

Jayden Bogle (21) - Contract ends Jun 24

Femi Seriki (19) Contract not known

(I won't include all academy players)

Keep Bogle, we've missed his attacking flair.
Sell George if we can get decent money for him and/or make a big savings on wages.

 

[Gavlar]

Keep them all.

 

[jt64]

Status quo

 

[bertieblade]

Cannot have two players on the anticipated High salaries when we are in dire need of three good quality midfield players and a centre back.
if someone offers more than £2.5m for baldrick he must be moved on, if Bogle learns to defend he could be valued At in excess of £10m after a good season. We have to sell to survive until we get back to the premiership.

 

[South Sea Blade]

Cannot have two players on the anticipated High salaries when we are in dire need of three good quality midfield players and a centre back.
if someone offers more than £2.5m for baldrick he must be moved on, if Bogle learns to defend he could be valued At in excess of £10m after a good season. We have to sell to survive until we get back to the premiership.

If we sell George for £2.5m and/or Bogle for £10m I will be pretty sure that McCabe is back in charge

 

[bertieblade]

How much would you value them at?

 

[robbiez666]

This depends on Bogle's injury really. There's no guarantee it's not going to give him further problems.

Unless we get a good bid for Baldock in the range of £2-5 million, I'd keep them both, it would be stupid to sell him for less unless he wanted to go.

Send Seriki on a League 1 loan for 6 months.

 

[South Sea Blade]

Bogle - £15-20m
George - £7-10m
Anything less and we are being bent over.

 

[bertieblade]

Bogle - £15-20m
George - £7-10m
Anything less and we are being bent over.

The only clubs with that amount of money to spend are in the premiership.
as I stated bogle could be worth in excess of £10m if he learns to defend but at the moment he is a liability as a defender as he loses his man too often.
George has no idea how to create once he gets into the final third And for that reason he will not attract interest from premiership clubs. But I acknowledge that we are all entitled to our opinions

 

[South Sea Blade]

The only clubs with that amount of money to spend are in the premiership.
as I stated bogle could be worth in excess of £10m if he learns to defend but at the moment he is a liability as a defender as he loses his man too often.
George has no idea how to create once he gets into the final third And for that reason he will not attract interest from premiership clubs. But I acknowledge that we are all entitled to our opinions

Fair enough Bertie blade....as you say we all have opinions and yours are not unreasonable. Personally I think George is better than a lot of people on here think. I'd like to keep them both as I reckon we will struggle to find comparable replacements for the money we would receive. There doesn't look like anybody to fear next season..... will the Prince be willing to gamble on keeping the higher earners in a bid to get promoted??

 

[3Cheers4Ramirez]

Play Baldock lwb

 

[bertieblade]

We had enough problems playing Osborn at RWB, neither can use the required Foot.

 

[jono_t2000]

Keep Bogle
Sell Baldock
Loan Seriki

 

[Nelson1889]

Keep them both unless we are planning on bringing another right back in.

Bogle won't be fit for the start of the season and has had a few niggley injuries these past 2 years and we don't want osborn at RWB again.

Seriki needs to be out on loan but can't see him getting higher than national league at the minute.

 

[robbiez666]

Bogle - £15-20m
George - £7-10m
Anything less and we are being bent over.

Halve those and you'd be about right.

 

[bonobo]

If we can sell Berge for a decent fee, keep Bogle as 1st choice If there is a sort of 2-3 mill bid for Baldock, sell otherwise know he will always bring a competitive edge to the squad and fight for his place. If he goes, sign a number 2 who can cross and provide decent cover/competition, like Nathan Byrne. Seriki loan, Conference or League 2.

 

[RammyBlade]

It sounds like most would keep Bogle and sell George and then loan out Seriki - however I would keep Seriki as cover for Bogle

 

[Hodgesleftpeg]

Keep them both, If Berge goes, Baldock at rwb, Bogle at right side midfield

 

[blades78]

Sell Baldock, loan Seriki. Get Cyrus Christie on a free, covers RB,RWB and RCB.

 

[jt64]

If we sell George for £2.5m and/or Bogle for £10m I will be pretty sure that McCabe is back in charge

Indeed on Baldock, he's got two years left on his deal

 

[Eels]

Again, wages might be more than we really want to be paying so we might take an offer for one of the two B's and hope Seriki steps up. Doubt it though - reckon we'll keep all three - maybe loan out Seriki if the other two both get fit.

 

[LudlamBlade]

We have to keep Bogle, think he'll be crucial to our successes next season if he comes back from injury even half as good as he was before it.

Keep Baldock for his threat from throw ins

 

[JJBlade]

Sell all three
We can buy one player cheaper and then shove a midfielder in there when he gets injured before the season starts