Worst Centre Back of our L1 years?

[Slim Man]

God. We've had some stinking centre halves.

 

[FMBlade1]

Andy Butler? Never even got onto the pitch was that bad XD

 

[Smirth]

Has to be McGahey, Harry Maguire's replacement. Has there ever been a bigger downgrade?

 

[JohnDenver]

That McCarthy fella we had on loan from Palace was atrocious.

 

[Tyler Durden]

David Edgar probably would've been quite a bit better had he not had Collins and McEvely at his side. He wasn't particularly good by any means, but I think that was a factor.

 

[HolmesfieldBlade]

Jay McEverly.

 

[Slim Man]

David Edgar probably would've been quite a bit better had he not had Collins and McEvely at his side. He wasn't particularly good by any means, but I think that was a factor.

Edgar was a decent player I thought. That's why I've not included him. Definitely our best centre half last year not that it was difficult.

 

[Bladesman]

Collins, considering he was part of the pathetic Championship squad that got relegated.

 

[Damski]

Let's have it reight, lads. Collins was part of the back 4 that had that run of 9 (possibly 10?) clean sheets in Clough's first season. That was a club record, was it not? Shouldn't even be on't list.

 

[Ricky]

Not sure any player's made me as angry as often as McEveley did.

 

[Blade 62]

Jay McEverly another one absolutely stealing a wage in professional football.
But you could have said that about all of the above .

 

[Gimli]

McGahey was terrible. McCeveley runs him close in this competition but for sheer dross it has to be McGahey. He was that bad I wanted to bring my boots and get a call to come down from the stands to take his place.

 

[1973Blade]

Sean Mcginty looked poor the few times we saw him. Now at Torquay United.

 

[Slim Man]

Let's have it reight, lads. Collins was part of the back 4 that had that run of 9 (possibly 10?) clean sheets in Clough's first season. That was a club record, was it not? Shouldn't even be on't list.

He was shit

 

[Rodders]

Alcock's brief stint?

 

[Ginger Gnome]

Paddy McCarthy's turn up when he felt like it and play crap when he did deserves a mention. Higginbotham was dire too. McGinty was hopeless.

 

[mancunianblade]

Is Joe Farmer on here??????? Top lad if so

 

[Tyler Durden]

I thought it would've been much closer between Collins and Bombscare to be honest.

 

[sitwell]

People forget that up to Spurs away ,McEveley was quite good. Magahey never was.

 

[JohnDenver]

People forget that up to Spurs away ,McEveley was quite good. Magahey never was.

He was one of our better and more committed performers in the second half of Adkins' season. Faint praise, but praise nonetheless.

 

[Alfreton14Blade]

Got to say that, although he wasn't the worst, Edgar's rightly on the list. Soft as shit - and representative of just how soft our underbelly had become during the Division Three years, up until this last season.

What a contrast with what we've got now.

 

[Damski]

He was shit

A compelling argument.

 

[DeanLearner'sCat]

Calamity Jay.

 

[Harry's Game]

Alcock's brief stint?

The genius that was Nigel Clough's man management left us in a crucial play off semi with McEverly and Alcock as our centre back partnership.... ouch!

 

[BalancedBlade]

 

[SB_90]

Let's have it reight, lads. Collins was part of the back 4 that had that run of 9 (possibly 10?) clean sheets in Clough's first season. That was a club record, was it not? Shouldn't even be on't list.

but carried by maguire massively. as we found out when he left
----
if i couldve voted for both collins & mceveley i wouldve easily the worst centre back partnership ive ever seen, i knew something had gone pearshaped under adkins as i said post swindon mceveley should never play for us again & that arse made him captain.. but collins just shaded it because it was becoming laughable at times as opposition couldnt believe their luck. as collins was their best offensive player

 

[Grappler]

Got to say that, although he wasn't the worst, Edgar's rightly on the list. Soft as shit - and representative of just how soft our underbelly had become during the Division Three years, up until this last season.

What a contrast with what we've got now.

I will never forget Edgar being subbed at half time, Port Vale, being bullied, we brought Terry Kennedy on, who sorted the problem in a couple of minutes

 

[SwissBlade]

Collins, considering he was part of the pathetic Championship squad that got relegated.

Relegated when he was at the club, couldn't get out of league one whilst he was here.

Get rid of him, lo and behold we get promoted.

 

[Tray]

That McCarthy fella we had on loan from Palace was atrocious.

He was on a par with Nyron Nosworthy, absolutelty dire.

 

[1danewhitehouse]

Didn't think Edgar was too bad at all to be honest. Would have probably done well in the current team.