Agree with the list. Would change the order as follows
1 EEL has been significant
4 the game is all about goals, only Sharp is scoring and there is no loan window
3 pace to change a game
2 Agree that with the formation we play, it's a critical creative position
6 We can just about cover but not with the same quality
5 We already have 5 (given 1 happens) plus Semple. Pretty low down but last of the "needs"
outside of this list, sometimes the right guy is available in any position. then you grab him.
I agree that goalscoring is the main thing we need to make sure we improve or at least maintain. If anything's going to cost us it's not scoring enough at home - we've scored 18 in 11 and had a number of warning signs. I've got no concerns about us away from home, I've maintained that since Gillingham - we're perfectly equipped to do well away. But then again, adding more goals will only help because we do concede at least one a game away from home.
I'd want to make sure we sign a striker if I was Wilder. I think Lavery and Clarke will chip in but we could do with someone who's ideal to play alongside Sharp while being able to score plenty himself. Someone we could also rely on to replace Sharp if he was injured. Basically, a quality striker. One of those is more likely to single handedly win you points than any other player.
I'd be looking at getting a wing back who's quick and good going forward, which would reduce the need to replace Chapman with someone who's a natural winger. We could instead focus on signing an attacking midfielder, who could also cover for Fleck and Coutts, with an ability to play wide being a bonus. Then we also have David Brooks.
I would also be open to signing a second wing back if the right player is available. Although this would possibly mean going a bit too far numbers wise with the recruitment if we signed players in the other positions mentioned.
I'd also like a centre half and I think Wilder would too, regardless of whether EEL stays or not. It would be a sensible insurance policy. We only have four players I'm happy playing in the back three - EEL, Wright, J'OC and Basham. Wright could well pick up injuries. Basham isn't a natural CB and sometimes gets caught out. I'd like another option who's comfortable playing in the middle of a three - I think only Wright is.
So ideally for me...
Centre back
Wing back/winger - one player
Chapman replacement/Cover for Coutts and Fleck - one player
Striker
Something like...
Byron Webster - 450k
Tendayi Darikwa/Elliott Bennett - loan
Emyr Huws - loan
Ched Evans - 350k
That would do me. And us. We'd go up for sure.