Two good teams - Who would win?

[Sothall_Blade]

Which team do you think would win and why?

Team X:-
Howard
Flynn Basham Kennedy Harris
Davies Coutts Reed Holt Murphy
Higdon

Subs:- Long, Dimaio, K.Wallace, Diego

Team Y:-
Turner
Brayford McGahey McCevely Freeman
JCR Scougall Doyle Baxter Adams
McNulty

Subs:- Willis, Cuvelier, J.Wallace, Khan

 

[mattbianco1]

This was done the other day wasn't it?

Edit - http://s24su.com/forum/index.php?threads/who-would-win-this-game.38084/

 

[Grecian2000]

Bloody hell Sothers. I'm sure you were arguing how good Alcock was after the first couple of games of the season and now he can't even make either imaginary bench!

FWIW 0-0 draw.

 

[Hodgyman]

We will probably never know the real answer, but being able to pick the best from both teams should give a team able to beat Preston in the cup and most Division 1 teams. Maybe Manure too

 

[wizadry]

It would be a 0-0 draw,both sides in the first half wouldn't press high up,they'd pass it about in their own half for ages,this draws a stalemate.In the second half the teams look to attack more but they cancel each other out after defensive lapses in concentration brought good saves from Howard and Turner.

 

[Sothall_Blade]

Bloody hell Sothers. I'm sure you were arguing how good Alcock was after the first couple of games of the season and now he can't even make either imaginary bench!

FWIW 0-0 draw.

You’re right, I forgot all about him. I thought he did well at Centre Back in the first two matches (Man of the Match in the S24SU ratings).
I think he’s a better option at the moment than McGahey, so would replace him in my team Y.

 

[wizadry]

You’re right, I forgot all about him. I thought he did well at Centre Back in the first two matches (Man of the Match in the S24SU ratings).
I think he’s a better option at the moment than McGahey, so would replace him in my team Y.

Still a 0-0 draw mate

 

[Sothall_Blade]

Still a 0-0 draw mate

Alcock, man of the match?