I think everybody (Karl Robinson, Chris Wilder, both sets of fans) would be happy from a footballing point of view with a deal which saw Carruthers and Holmes trade clubs with Charlton receiving £100-200k. But reading between the lines of Karl Robinson’s interview, I think their outgoing Chairman would rather receive full monetary value for Holmes, he’s looking for returns.
Could be wrong, but we’re in the Rumour Mill and that’s my guess.
KR quote - “But what I won’t do is just sell a player for the money. I’m sticking to my guns on that. I will need a replacement, immediately, and then we will use the money to strengthen the team.”
Could be a 2+2=5 situation, but the pieces do seem to fit.