Pros and Cons - Charlton away

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Today was an indication, once again, as to how much rot has set into United.

Cooper beaten by a signposted shot. Sure, it happens, but Burrows has a stake in this too. Okay, let's just put their first down to our recent propensity to give an early goal away to wakken oursens up a bit. But we didn't, did we? Charlton, as many have said, aren't much. And out of the ten or so similar unimpressive teams we have played against and failed to dominate this season, today was no different. Teams turn up and you can see how surprised they are how shit we really are.

The back four today was fragile as chipsticks. I still cannot understand what Hamsa Choudrhey gives us at right back. He is slow, doesn't go out to his winger, doesn't offer him the weak foot and doesn't stop the cross. That's four things what, in my manual of soccer requirements, full backs have to do - just in defence. They are also supposed to support the attack. Remember George Baldock and Enda Stevens? Japhet Tanganga to me is a mistake signing. He came here surfing on a wave of assumed capability but is, in fact, bang average if not less than that. Next to him Kitching is underwhelmingly poor, either doing the basics, like picking up attackers at the near post who suddenly have a yard to kick a chest high cross into the goal to win the match, or do the simple basics of centre-backing. Burrows didn't have that much of a bad game, maily because he had a fit, mobile, nippy right winger in front of him and could play off him. But again, ask him to jockey his man out wide or get his foot in front of the cross ... aint happening.

I thought Saide Peck didn't do too badly today in our 'established' central midfield pairing but Philips was not as great. As said out wide on the left you have the only bright spark on white-with-a-red-and-black-diagonal-stripe, and in that, Donovan shows us all the massive gulf between what Brentford can't find a place for, and what we desperately cling onto as treasured goods. Again, Charlton put two on him whenever he had the ball and did their best to kick him up in the air, but he continued to thwart scything challenges and get round them in a mesmerising manner. He is an absolute class footballer and by far the best thing on the pitch.

Over the other side we have a similarly mesmerising form of Tathith Chong. Mesmerising in a manner that he leaves you wondering what the cane-top-hat-and-dickie-bow-tapdancing-fuck Wilder is thinking when he makes the teamsheet up. Is Chong the first on there? Or is there a gap at right wing and Adam Davies can't find it in him to run up and down and cross it into the danger area. Because I am struggling what Wilder sees in Chong, either as a winger, or even as a footballer. Every time he has the ball, it's not 'what is he going to do with it?' it is more 'when is he coughing it up?' He clearly can't play in the English game at this level. Positionally he is diabolical. Possession-wise, he is a catastrophe and just having any sort of impact from and area of the pitch that screams 'fucking do something!' he can't do anything. With Choudhrey behind him, they make an astounding pair of footballing fuckwits. Neither read each other, neither can hold the position they have and neither are any good for the squad. Just watch though. They will be there again, versus Watford. They'll fail to mark and they'll fail to penetrate and have any effect, coughing up possession and wasting decent opportunities.

Brereton Dias and the ageing Jordan Ayew gave us precious little to get out of your seats about. Our goal was opportunist stuff ... and largely down to the shitness of Charlton's defence than it was to the brilliance of our attackers. Both our front line were a clear measure again of how far we have fallen from grace. We had a few chances, but we fail to put it in the net. That's why we lost. Full stop.

Substitutions? Do they ever make much of a difference? Campbell looked knackered warming up, Arblaster is a done deal now in terms of what he once could have been, we even played McGuinness in the '10' role when we went behind and Cannon ... oh, Tommy Cannon. I thought Brewster and Mousset were both bobbar in a breadcake with salt and Hendoes. I just can't wait to celebrate when he leaves United. There. I've said it.

In short, don't get too giddy by our position whilst Wilder has his hands and feet still on the controls.
Good summary but as discussed with fellow Blades at Charlton the root problem is the owners who have no interest in our club just sell up and fuck off
 



Good summary but as discussed with fellow Blades at Charlton the root problem is the owners who have no interest in our club just sell up and fuck off
They thought they were going to make a quick buck by us going up and then flip the club, but that plan failed.................................tossers! You just cant trust yanks, on many levels!
 
One of my takeaways from yesterday was that the majority of the fans blamed the players not Wilder. I'm not convinced this site is representative of the fans that go to games. Personally I blame the players more than Wilder for the performance but granted the two are inextricably linked.

Also why did so many fans stay to clap the players & Wilder at the end. Me and my two sons included?

I guess for me it's about supporting the club. We have been in way worst places over the last 40 years I've followed them. We need to stay united. United.

If a supporter is so afronted then just don't go. Your choice. But with our current owners we might reflect that where we are now is a good place. Be careful what comes next.
 
Despite the very disappointing result yesterday, and the awful journey home to Norfolk which took best part of eight hours, by shank's pony, trains, a bus and taxi at the end, when the train was stuck at Norwich due to signal failure.

However, despite my woes - I will not forget, for a long-time the fantastic Blades away support. I reckon we must have just about sold out our allocation of three-thousand. There seemed more in our end than the home end. Great noise and support.

The injury to Seriki was terrible. I understand he will be sidelined for the rest of the season, at least. Very sad news.

HH
 
Welcome to the club. The end of his reign can’t come soon enough.
And the poor chuff will be remembered not for the wonderful , lovable squads of the 16-20 era ,
But for saddling us with Brewster , Cannon and a pile of expensive old feckers whilst talking shite.
 
Quote of the week for me was Wilder saying "I see in the player(s) what no one else can see".
SHOULD have gone in Wilders ludicrous quotes
BUT
I empathize for once
I see Wilder as the WORST MANAGER in the history of the club
BY A MILE
I cannot comprehend how ANYONE cannot see he has been a total disaster at least since his moronic return
and how he is destroying the club
Endless threads about bad performances, bad players and lack of fitness
But no blame for the imbecile in charge
Just deflection
That back 4 are ALL Wilder signings and the basis of the clubs long term future according to him
They should not even be playing as a back four!
Three of the four at least are NOT TOP championship players in any position
let alone the long term answer to anything but failure
How off course can you get?

ps Don't give me any crap about Tanganga and others not mentioned here as not his signings
There is none so blind as those that will not see.
And NOBODY can dispute he is ALWAYS CAPTAIN and ALWAYS PLAYS
The second preseason video was ALL about him
putting a dampener on all expectations and hope for this season
for anyone who knows about football
 
Agree on the whole.

Philips, Ayew and Donovan all put in a shift. I actually thought Burrows did ok going forward, but agree about his defending. It seems plainly obvious to me that he is a better LM/LW than a LB. Put him in front of McCallum, and then we can drop Chong on the other side and put Donovan there.

Cooper has been superb so far this season, but that first goal was inexcusable.

BBD, completely, absolutely fucking wretched today.

The rest were all under par.

Totally gutted for Seriki, a shocker of an injury and I wil be surprised if we see him within the next 12 months. We also now have a crisis at RB.

Overall, a dreadful game of football and a largely hopeless performance. The ref lost control early on and was all over the place for both sides.
agree totally on the mcallum/burrows idea especially if were going to carry on this 20 year out of date 442 set up burrows was good going forward but he isnt a lb hes a lwb and it cost us a point saturday but charlton bullied us out of the game and were lucky to finish with 11 on the pitch but they also wanted it so much more than us we thought we only had to turn up to get the 3 points get burrows further forward down the left drop the waste of a shirt that chong is and put donovan down the right
 
One of my takeaways from yesterday was that the majority of the fans blamed the players not Wilder. I'm not convinced this site is representative of the fans that go to games. Personally I blame the players more than Wilder for the performance but granted the two are inextricably linked.

Also why did so many fans stay to clap the players & Wilder at the end. Me and my two sons included?

I guess for me it's about supporting the club. We have been in way worst places over the last 40 years I've followed them. We need to stay united. United.

If a supporter is so afronted then just don't go. Your choice. But with our current owners we might reflect that where we are now is a good place. Be careful what comes next.

I don't think there is a huge majority furiously wanting Wilder out. I think most are completely non plussed whether he stays or goes because they are aware that the major problems go higher than him.

If Wilder is still here next season then we will lose some supporters because a fair amount of people have had enough of him but currently , the next manager is set up to fail too. I thought a few months back that we'd start seeing fighting between the fans but I think it's more likely that a chunk of fans will just stop going.
 



If Wilder is still here next season then we will lose some supporters because a fair amount of people have had enough of him but currently , the next manager is set up to fail too. I thought a few months back that we'd start seeing fighting between the fans but I think it's more likely that a chunk of fans will just stop going.

My Dad didn't go to a single game last season for the first time in nearly 30 years and he hasn't been since.

And this was someone who worshipped Wilder.

It's not because he hates Wilder, he's just fed up with it all.
 
I don't think there is a huge majority furiously wanting Wilder out. I think most are completely non plussed whether he stays or goes because they are aware that the major problems go higher than him.

If Wilder is still here next season then we will lose some supporters because a fair amount of people have had enough of him but currently , the next manager is set up to fail too. I thought a few months back that we'd start seeing fighting between the fans but I think it's more likely that a chunk of fans will just stop going.
were already losing supporters including some season ticket holders who are not turning up for games plus from having 4/5k potd fans were now down to roughly 2k and these facts are a combination of discontent with the owners and wilders brand of football and i think theres a bigger chunk of our fanbase unhappy with wilders style of play than you think roy its so dull and a millions miles away from wilders teams in his early years with us when he played fast attacking innovative football i dont see him taking us anywhere im afraid utb ftp ⚔️⚔️⚔️
 
were already losing supporters including some season ticket holders who are not turning up for games plus from having 4/5k potd fans were now down to roughly 2k and these facts are a combination of discontent with the owners and wilders brand of football and i think theres a bigger chunk of our fanbase unhappy with wilders style of play than you think roy its so dull and a millions miles away from wilders teams in his early years with us when he played fast attacking innovative football i dont see him taking us anywhere im afraid utb ftp ⚔️⚔️⚔️

You could well be right. I saw Rob Staton say it's only a few people online who want him gone and it was proven that people were behind him because the team got clapped off at Charlton. In reality, loads of fans had already left by full time.

I think the fact the home and away support has decreased substantially since the start of the season is an indication thousands are fed up with Wilder. People can argue all day about whether he's the right man or not but pretending it's only a small minority of fans that have lost faith in him doesn't help anybody when the evidence is clear that the fanbase is split
 
You could well be right. I saw Rob Staton say it's only a few people online who want him gone and it was proven that people were behind him because the team got clapped off at Charlton. In reality, loads of fans had already left by full time.

I think the fact the home and away support has decreased substantially since the start of the season is an indication thousands are fed up with Wilder. People can argue all day about whether he's the right man or not but pretending it's only a small minority of fans that have lost faith in him doesn't help anybody when the evidence is clear that the fanbase is split
Just like 1995 when there were infighting and arguing about Bassett.
 
You could well be right. I saw Rob Staton say it's only a few people online who want him gone and it was proven that people were behind him because the team got clapped off at Charlton. In reality, loads of fans had already left by full time.

I think the fact the home and away support has decreased substantially since the start of the season is an indication thousands are fed up with Wilder. People can argue all day about whether he's the right man or not but pretending it's only a small minority of fans that have lost faith in him doesn't help anybody when the evidence is clear that the fanbase is split

There’s also a lot of dishonesty in people’s statements on this. Wilder is just the public face of an inevitable period of decline. For a lot of folk it could be someone else in charge and they’d still present reasons not to go. The fundamental problem is the fact we’re a mid table outfit, and people are used to better.

Wilder isn’t the single factor holding the club back. Ditching him won’t unleash enough untapped potential to make us contenders.

Yet it’s somehow taboo amongst fans to simply say “I’m not going because I don’t like us being really bloody ordinary”. So they’ll embellish their reasoning.

I’ll be honest - I’ll always have a season ticket but I’m missing a couple of games this month that in previous years I’d have found a way to attend. And the reason is we’re really bloody ordinary. And that ain’t changing quickly, Wilder or otherwise.
 
Just like 1995 when there were infighting and arguing about Bassett.


Yeah it's really similar to that at the moment without it yet coming to proper violence and just all being played out online. Like Bassett, It's really sad to see a manager who was so loved by everybody just a few years previous now driving fans away
 
There’s also a lot of dishonesty in people’s statements on this. Wilder is just the public face of an inevitable period of decline. For a lot of folk it could be someone else in charge and they’d still present reasons not to go. The fundamental problem is the fact we’re a mid table outfit, and people are used to better.

Wilder isn’t the single factor holding the club back. Ditching him won’t unleash enough untapped potential to make us contenders.

Yet it’s somehow taboo amongst fans to simply say “I’m not going because I don’t like us being really bloody ordinary”. So they’ll embellish their reasoning.

I’ll be honest - I’ll always have a season ticket but I’m missing a couple of games this month that in previous years I’d have found a way to attend. And the reason is we’re really bloody ordinary. And that ain’t changing quickly, Wilder or otherwise.

Totally agree. People are bored of Wilder, his style and the approach to recruitment but the next manager would soon lose his shine because the club isn't in a position to succeeed. The problems go far deeper than whoever the manager is. Again, there are similarities with the fag end of the Bassett era when he probably had ran his course but the main issues were above him.

I understand why Wilder is seen as a safety blanket for some because the Selles disaster shows how much worse it can be. I also understand why people want to try something different because it's all so boring and stale. The reality is though that people are disinterested in watching us because there's nothing to look forward to. We're not going to be challenging anytime soon and it's hard to get excited as a fan when just a few years ago we were always in contention for promotion or in The Premier League
 
yes i think its more than a small minority that want.wilder out at least 70/30 in wilders favour but think the discontent with him is gathering pace weve got a really tough run of games coming up soon which more.than likely will see us sliding down the league we could then have a similar situation as when bassett's tenure had run its course personally despite being a big wilder fan in his 2 previous tenures with us i dont see him succeeding this time round with us or any other club at this level
 
I want to want to go again because I know I'm going to enjoy watching a team who gives everything rather than going to see mates of 20 odd years' standing or because I feel I ought to.

I'm less concerned with the name of the manager who effects that change.
 
Totally agree. People are bored of Wilder, his style and the approach to recruitment but the next manager would soon lose his shine because the club isn't in a position to succeeed. The problems go far deeper than whoever the manager is. Again, there are similarities with the fag end of the Bassett era when he probably had ran his course but the main issues were above him.

I understand why Wilder is seen as a safety blanket for some because the Selles disaster shows how much worse it can be. I also understand why people want to try something different because it's all so boring and stale. The reality is though that people are disinterested in watching us because there's nothing to look forward to. We're not going to be challenging anytime soon and it's hard to get excited as a fan when just a few years ago we were always in contention for promotion or in The Premier League
Sad, but very true.

There is little to get excited about at the moment. We’ve been blessed with some good times over the last 10 years. Much of which should be attributed to Wilder… but those days have gone and they’re not coming back.

We might not have the money we want or need but there is still a different approach we could be taking.

Currently, we are boring and predictable. Both in terms of recruitment and style of play.

It’s not the anti-Wilder vs Wilder fanboy bullshit that concerns me, it’s growing sense of apathy.
 
I think this is an excellent post. It puts into focus exactly where we are now.
That is, going nowhere.
I had a lot of time for Wilder. He did great things with us for quite a while.


Well nip down to the Lane slip em 250m quid and see if that helps

you gets what you can afford, in a game based these days on what the club can afford
we kidded ourselves that now wed got US owners wed take off, they turned out to have less investment money than mccabe
 



All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom