Roy's View From... Palace and Arsenal Fans Views On Rob Holding

[Roygbiv]

Crystal Palace and Arsenal Fans Views On Rob Holding — The View From

PALACE FANS "Thank You Rob Holding!!- 2 Years At The Club- 4 Million Pounds- 0 League Appearances- 1 Cup Match- 1 Yellow Card- Frozen Out For Not Warming Up- Countless U21 Games PlayedA TRUE PALACE LEGEND" "What a monumental loss to the club" "Best £4m we ever spent" "Nobody cares, he’ll go down...

roysviewfrom.com

 

[SUFC Guy]

Sounds promising

 

[FTPE]

Cheers Roy.
Putting in the over time

 

[Blackheath Blade]

Cheers Roy. Lovely salty and bitter comments. They certainly love the bloke.

 

[Aston max]

Do you ever sleep

 

[1973Blade]

Not the best comments I've seen!

 

[BiggerBladeThanThou]

Mixed bag. Expected the Palace reaction as he’s played fuck all. I think he’ll do fine with us. Remember similar vibes re: Souttar. Think Holding is Champ level and will fit in well. Up the Blades.

 

[Boxer Blade]

He sounds crap,we'll see.

 

[metty]

Cheers Roy

 

[BiggerBladeThanThou]

Good luck on latest signing’s fans view Roygbiv

 

[Bladesman]

Crystal Palace and Arsenal Fans Views On Rob Holding — The View From

PALACE FANS "Thank You Rob Holding!!- 2 Years At The Club- 4 Million Pounds- 0 League Appearances- 1 Cup Match- 1 Yellow Card- Frozen Out For Not Warming Up- Countless U21 Games PlayedA TRUE PALACE LEGEND" "What a monumental loss to the club" "Best £4m we ever spent" "Nobody cares, he’ll go down...

roysviewfrom.com

The transfer to Palace just seems like an Andy Butler / Geoff Horsfield situation. A fallout with the manager and that was that no way back.

Some Arsenal fans saying he was crap meanwhile with him they went and won the FA cup.

 

[Bladesman101]

Doesn’t sound like a great signing does it!

 

[Bladesince59]

Another Dean Hammond?

 

[raimond]

So he's either a) absolutely shite or b) was a bit of a lucky charm but now absolutely shite. GLTTL

 

[Blade56]

Ok

 

[Ron_Justice]

Fleck

 

[BigBed]

Crystal Palace and Arsenal Fans Views On Rob Holding — The View From

PALACE FANS "Thank You Rob Holding!!- 2 Years At The Club- 4 Million Pounds- 0 League Appearances- 1 Cup Match- 1 Yellow Card- Frozen Out For Not Warming Up- Countless U21 Games PlayedA TRUE PALACE LEGEND" "What a monumental loss to the club" "Best £4m we ever spent" "Nobody cares, he’ll go down...

roysviewfrom.com

Cheers Roy.
Underwhelming signing for me.

 

[Bladesman]

Doesn’t sound like a great signing does it!

You are right, we don't need an experienced FA cup winning Premier League defender.

We should have got Ryan Porteous instead.

 

[alcoblade]

150 plus appearances for Arsenal. Not many of our recent squads would have managed to hold that down in the premier league

 

[Bladesman101]

You are right, we don't need an experienced FA cup winning Premier League defender.

We should have got Ryan Porteous instead.

Based off those comments, he doesn’t look like a good signing. Really sorry if you have made a different assessment from the reviews of the fans of the club he’s been at for 2.5 years.

Bear in mind palace have had different managers in that time, never even close to a sniff of playing.

 

[Greg.]

To be fair I'm not sure the 'fans view on' is a particularly useful indicator of how good a signing turns out to be for us. Soton fans on BBD: https://roysviewfrom.com/2025/01/20/southampton-fans-views-on-ben-brereton-diaz/

 

[alcoblade]

Based off those comments, he doesn’t look like a good signing. Really sorry if you have made a different assessment from the reviews of the fans of the club he’s been at for 2.5 years.

Bear in mind palace have had different managers in that time, never even close to a sniff of playing.

It's 1.5 years isn't it? And he's clearly had a falling out - but given that how can we put any weight on their judgement of him as a player?

 

[Caveblade]

Palace fans really are entitled Wankers. Cheers Roygbiv

 

[Bladesman]

Based off those comments, he doesn’t look like a good signing. Really sorry if you have made a different assessment from the reviews of the fans of the club he’s been at for 2.5 years.

Bear in mind palace have had different managers in that time, never even close to a sniff of playing.

True but I just don't think his time at Palace has gone well at all. Although I am fairly sure he was injured during Roy's time in charge.

 

[Bladesman101]

True but I just don't think his time at Palace has gone well at all. Although I am fairly sure he was injured during Roy's time in charge.

Hope I’m wrong, but he’s going to need a long long time to get up to speed. We’re not strong enough at centre half unfortunately.

 

[SirNibletsO'Korne]

Thanks Roy.
Er.
Okay...
Well,let's just see eh?

 

[Millhousesblade1889]

He played more for Arsenal than Trusty did so hopefully he’s an improvement on that.

 

[BladeInIreland]

Palace fans haven't really got a clue how good or bad he is.

Arsenal fans are judging him from the perspective of a top 4 Premier league side.

I think every player apart from maybe Clarke has had an overall negative feed back (apart from the entity) Let's wait and see.

 

[Champagneblade]

Crystal Palace and Arsenal Fans Views On Rob Holding — The View From

PALACE FANS "Thank You Rob Holding!!- 2 Years At The Club- 4 Million Pounds- 0 League Appearances- 1 Cup Match- 1 Yellow Card- Frozen Out For Not Warming Up- Countless U21 Games PlayedA TRUE PALACE LEGEND" "What a monumental loss to the club" "Best £4m we ever spent" "Nobody cares, he’ll go down...

roysviewfrom.com

Take these with a pinch of salt.

One club he was ex communicated from not long after arriving and those oh so notoriously easy to please Gunners fans!

He’ll probably love playing for a team that isn’t self-entitled!

 

[Cheeky Blade]

“He spent his entire summer getting hammered over in the states”

It’s all starting to make sense now…