Our best goal scorer. Bill or Ol.

[DronnieBlade]

Pointless thread

At this rate, it might make it on to pointless .

UTB

PS pointless response .

 

[Silent Blade]

At this rate, it might make it on to pointless .

UTB

PS pointless response .

Majority in here know that you are just stirring up shit!

 

[DronnieBlade]

Majority in here know that you are just stirring up shit!

And you speak for said majority ?

Righdo !

UTB

 

[Scooter_mcgavin]

And you speak for said majority ?

Righdo !

UTB

He's not wrong though is he.

. UTB

 

[DronnieBlade]

He's not wrong though is he.

. UTB

And your evidence for such a statement is .......

UTB

 

[Scooter_mcgavin]

And your evidence for such a statement is .......

UTB

Don't need the evidence. Surprised you didn't include Clarke in there tbh.

 

[DronnieBlade]

Don't need the evidence. Surprised you didn't include Clarke in there tbh.

 

[sufcboy95]

Obviously over his career Sharp has done a lot more. However If your asking for right now then it’s Mcburnie

 

[jt64]

Sharp could have scored any of the three goals McBurnie has scored this season.

None of them were exceptional.

Doubt Sharp even gets into the position McBurnie did against Brighton, at least legally

 

[PeterNdlovu081]

Doubt Sharp even gets into the position McBurnie did against Brighton, at least legally

Perhaps.

It still wasn't an exceptional goal though.

 

[DronnieBlade]

Where’s mi unstable, arrogant, aggressive, narcissistic mate gone toneet ?



UTB

 

[Bruce Wayne]

There are desperate posts and then there are stupidly desperate posts. This falls into the latter.

 

[DronnieBlade]

There are desperate posts and then there are stupidly desperate posts. This falls into the latter.

McB it is .

UTB

 

[Berlin Blade]

At this level Oli, below Billy.

Do the nets get smaller in the prem?

He’s asking for who the best finisher is.

Yes Mcburnie can possibly offer more to the team over 90 minutes at this level (possibly). But if you’re asking who would score more if you offered them both 100 of the same chances in the same circumstances, then billy would dick all over Oli.

Yes Oli is about 10 years younger so has probably a higher ceiling and is worth more money in the market because of that, but that isn’t the question is it.

 

[United Aren't Back.]

Just goal scorer. Nothing else.

Assume your life depended on it.

So quite important !

Leon.
Oh sorry that's not an option.
Billy.

 

[Woodwardfan]

Just goal scorer. Nothing else.

Assume your life depended on it.

So quite important !

In the air or on the ground?

In a team on the break or well on top?

Now or next season and the season after?

Shame we can't play them together but pace rules at this level.

 

[BladeInIreland]

Do the nets get smaller in the prem?

He’s asking for who the best finisher is.

Yes Mcburnie can possibly offer more to the team over 90 minutes at this level (possibly). But if you’re asking who would score more if you offered them both 100 of the same chances in the same circumstances, then billy would dick all over Oli.

Yes Oli is about 10 years younger so has probably a higher ceiling and is worth more money in the market because of that, but that isn’t the question is it.

Actually, the Op asks who our best goal scorer is. Not if they had the same chances who would be the better finisher. That isn't the question, yes sharp could possibly beat McB at this (possibly).

Now ignoring the rest of a strikers game a goal scorer just needs to score right? I made one assumption in this post and that's the Op is referring to them playing for us. In that case I stick by McB as he probably more capable of getting and taking chances at this level in our team.

 

[DronnieBlade]

Righdo.

Not sure how much legs this has left so here goes.

As things stand, it’s 103 Bill, 12 Ol. This is because 4 posters chose to “spoil” their ballot papers and vote for all the candidates !

My bad really for not setting the poll up correctly .

So what did it prove ??

Well, fuck all in all honesty. Was just a bit of fun when all said and done .

And what was gleaned ?

I was honestly expecting, within the 4 walls of S2 4SU for an entirely different outcome. For it to be much closer. I would have had no
doubt that casting the net to a wider footballing audience would have resulted in a landslide (and fully understanding of the reasons why this would be so) but was much less sure of the outcome from “within”.

Which got me to thinking why is this so ??

The only answer I could come up with is that the forum, much like life in general, is heavily influenced by a minority that make a disproportionate amount of noise. That this disproportionate amount of noise distorts the perception of reality. It creates an untruth.

Now volume on a football forum can’t be measured in Db.

But it can be created by a minority of posters that, quite literally, live on the forum. That spend unhealthy amounts of time on here racking up a post count and monopolising shout box, mostly (But not always) being aggressive, rude and down right disrespectful directly to other forum members.

So, if this is anywhere near hitting the nail on the head, my personal learn from this is to drown out the noise. It really isn’t worth the dignity of any sort of response .

As always, UTB.

 

[DronnieBlade]

In the air or on the ground?

In a team on the break or well on top?

Now or next season and the season after?

Shame we can't play them together but pace rules at this level.

There is no shame about it.

The quicker that you, and the gaffer realise that this is our worst front pairing, our most “sub optimal”, the better !

UTB

 

[Woodwardfan]

There is no shame about it.

The quicker that you, and the gaffer realise that this is our worst front pairing, our most “sub optimal”, the better !

UTB

Dronnie. With respect that is what I said.

 

[DronnieBlade]

106/12.

90%.

10%.

.

UTB

 

[Jim Chimmerney]

Are we including Bill's 1st 2 spells with us

 

[DronnieBlade]

Are we including Bill's 1st 2 spells with us

Your own interpretation.

There is no context to the question.

UTB

 

[Brian Deane]

Messen....

 

[DronnieBlade]

Messen....

Probs.

But is it close ??

UTB

 

[Brian Deane]

Probs.

But is it close ??

UTB

No. Billy just a fat lad from Sheffield now stealing a wage as a bench warmer.....He'd be better off going to dirty Weeds .......oh hang on a minute UTB

 

[Charlieblade]

Agree.....there’s this fashion these days where everything must be a polarised view/ opinion.
So it’s either Sharp is brilliant or Sharp is crap.

Don't think it’s ever as simple as that....all our strikers have different styles...different strengths and different weaknesses.
If we set tactics playing to a players strength then they start to look better than their normal standard.
If we don’t or can’t use their strength then that player starts to look very average.
All our players should be valued because they all have the potential to offer something to the team.

I think your earlier post was better. What you now seem to be inferring is that Wilder has a pool of “horses for courses” strikers to match the perceived weakness of any opposition?
That being the case, why have we not scored a lot more goals?
Maybe I’m just being argumentative, but your earlier post nailed it, despite calls for evidence to prove your case.

 

[Torrix1889]

Pointless thread

Absolutely correct.

Nothing more than a platform for the Sharp lovers to bang the Sharp drum.

How can you compare a 33 year old "veteran" of the game with 240+ career goals to his name, with a "rookie" (in comparison) striker 10 years his junior?

 

[Torrix1889]

Righdo.

Not sure how much legs this has left so here goes.

As things stand, it’s 103 Bill, 12 Ol. This is because 4 posters chose to “spoil” their ballot papers and vote for all the candidates !

My bad really for not setting the poll up correctly .

So what did it prove ??

Well, fuck all in all honesty. Was just a bit of fun when all said and done .

And what was gleaned ?

I was honestly expecting, within the 4 walls of S2 4SU for an entirely different outcome. For it to be much closer. I would have had no
doubt that casting the net to a wider footballing audience would have resulted in a landslide (and fully understanding of the reasons why this would be so) but was much less sure of the outcome from “within”.

Which got me to thinking why is this so ??

The only answer I could come up with is that the forum, much like life in general, is heavily influenced by a minority that make a disproportionate amount of noise. That this disproportionate amount of noise distorts the perception of reality. It creates an untruth.

Now volume on a football forum can’t be measured in Db.

But it can be created by a minority of posters that, quite literally, live on the forum. That spend unhealthy amounts of time on here racking up a post count and monopolising shout box, mostly (But not always) being aggressive, rude and down right disrespectful directly to other forum members.

So, if this is anywhere near hitting the nail on the head, my personal learn from this is to drown out the noise. It really isn’t worth the dignity of any sort of response .

As always, UTB.

But the question asked was "who is our best goalscorer"....?

Billy has scored over 100 goals for the club where as Oli has scored 3.....so that's why the poll has returned the results it has.

if the question was "who is our best finisher at PL level" then you would have had a different response...

 

[DronnieBlade]

But the question asked was "who is our best goalscorer"....?

Billy has scored over 100 goals for the club where as Oli has scored 3.....so that's why the poll has returned the results it has.

if the question was "who is our best finisher at PL level" then you would have had a different response...

FACT .