Ndiaye v Hamer - who scored the most spectacular goals?

[1973Blade]

It has been a privilege in recent years to see some of the best goals I've seen supporting United.
But who scored the most spectacular goals - Ndiaye getting past half the opposition (eg Fulham away) or a long range spectacular from Hamer (eg Birmingham this season or yesterday's goal)
Both are brilliant, but for me you can't beat a dribbler and Ndiaye just shades it!

 

[Menage a petit pois]

Ndiaye all day for me. Was a privilege seeing him in red and white.

 

[KMC-1889]

Hamer has the better goals but N’Diaye was far and away the better player, which is why one is a regular player for a premier league team and one is a championship player that can’t find a move higher.

 

[AWetFlannel]

Can't decide either, but both should be playing top division football.

Hamer strikes the ball better and more consistently than any player I've seen for us.

 

[Gimli]

The Ndiaye goal v Blackburn was a joy to watch.

 

[N20 Blade]

Can't decide either, but both should be playing top division football.

Hamer strikes the ball better and more consistently than any player I've seen for us.

I don't think Hamer is of PL quality, good squad / bench player, but a flat track bully (when he fancies it). I might be wrong and if so, he'll be bought in January. But with the possible exception of Leeds or Burnley, I can't think of a PL team he would start for regularly. Suits me as I want him to stay with us.

 

[bakeblade]

The Ndiaye goal v Blackburn was a joy to watch.

Watching that goal live was worth my season ticket alone, to see it was an absolute privilege

 

[Gavlar]

Watching that goal live was worth my season ticket alone, to see it was an absolute privilege

I watched it live too on a rare outing to brammal lane (I live down south). What a goal.

 

[Berkshire Blade]

Ndiaye scored some belting goals but I'd argue that wasn't even his best asset. So many levels above Hamer or anything I have seen in the championship recently

 

[joe casey]

I don't think Hamer is of PL quality, good squad / bench player, but a flat track bully (when he fancies it). I might be wrong and if so, he'll be bought in January. But with the possible exception of Leeds or Burnley, I can't think of a PL team he would start for regularly. Suits me as I want him to stay with us.

Hamer - much like Anel, is definitely a player who would be better placed at a team seeking european football outside of England

 

[UmbrellaDan]

Not to take anything away from Hamer, but I feel anyone can twat one once in a while and catch it sweetly, although Hamer does do it quite often.
But the skill it takes to score like N'Diaye did is something really special

 

[CrookesBlade]

Hamer. I’ve mentally erased everything Ndiaye did playing for us.