Mcatee should he have seen red?

[Frank the tank]

What replay?

The slow motion one ,wasn't even a foul

 

[Harry's Game]

The slow motion one ,wasn't even a foul

Where ? No replay been shown on Sky

 

[bibbity bobbity boo]

100% a yellow but I'd have given a red.

 

[Frank the tank]

Where ? No replay been shown on Sky

I watched it on sutv

 

[robbiez666]

He’s a kid, he laying against blokes… or that’s how it appears. It’s as though he feels that he has to throw himself in a bit stupidly in order to stop himself getting hurt.

What good is a midfielder if he can't tackle? That's two yellow cards for two reckless challenge. He will get sent off because it looks worse than it is.

I actually give him more credit for tonight. There's an insurmountable issue with him playing in the centre.

However, he put a right shift in. The highlight was running half the pitch to cover for a lumbering Doyle.

Did a couple of decent things going forward

We're just dreadfully short in the centre when it comes to defensive qualities.

 

[Harry's Game]

I watched it on sutv

Ahh the unbiased opinion then..

 

[Frank the tank]

Ahh the unbiased opinion then..

Ahh the biased slow motion replay

 

[100% part time blade]

He evened it up, fair play

Definitely. If he’d given McAtee a red, the ref would 100% have given Dabo a second yellow. He kept his card in his pocket because he was thinking about how he’d given McAtee the benefit of the doubt. Weird that he’s not really allowed to say that, but I think most people would agree that it’s the right way to actually go about reffing the game.

 

[metalblade]

Bollocks............. yellow was the correct decision, don't be fooled by the Coventry bench going nuts.

 

[robbiez666]

Definitely. If he’d given McAtee a red, the ref would 100% have given Dabo a second yellow. He kept his card in his pocket because he was thinking about how he’d given McAtee the benefit of the doubt. Weird that he’s not really allowed to say that, but I think most people would agree that it’s the right way to actually go about reffing the game.

Second one wasn't a yellow really. Osborn knew what he was doing. I'd rather refs are lenient and both teams keep 11 on the pitch.

 

[100% part time blade]

Bollocks............. yellow was the correct decision, don't be fooled by the Coventry bench going nuts.

Not sure if this is in reply to me saying ‘definitely’…
I meant in reply to bakeblade that the ref ‘definitely’ did ‘even it up’ in the second half and ‘fair play’ to him.
I didn’t mean it was definitely a red card in response to the original question. Mcatee kept his feet on the floor as he slid, didn’t connect with the player with his leading boot, but was possibly out of control so it could have been a red, but was by no means a definite one.

 

[wizadry]

Usually, when it’s been discussed on a forum of the team you support you know there’s a chance it could’ve and more than likely should’ve been a red.

 

[Harry's Game]

People lying about where they have watched the game is hilarious

 

[Sheff de party]

Borderline. Yellow on watching it back. In real time, I’m sending him off.

 

[Bladesman]

Could be worse:

 

[Jake Richard Cuthbert]

Looks like he did

 

[Alan Birchenall's hair]

Could be worse:

Ahh, I remember Sunday morning at Graves Park. Looks like a Wyvern vs Springwood Hotel match from 1983

 

[metalblade]

Not sure if this is in reply to me saying ‘definitely’…
I meant in reply to bakeblade that the ref ‘definitely’ did ‘even it up’ in the second half and ‘fair play’ to him.
I didn’t mean it was definitely a red card in response to the original question. Mcatee kept his feet on the floor as he slid, didn’t connect with the player with his leading boot, but was possibly out of control so it could have been a red, but was by no means a definite one.

No not aimed at you it was aimed at the thread title.

 

[A_Bladesman]

Personally, yellow is fair but easily a red

I think I agree with you mate. What do you think of our current position, will.