Marc mcnulty poor signing

[S18BLADE]

I know some may say this is harsh after just 1 game but really can't see it working out here for this lad I've seen every preseason game he's played in and he lacks pace strength and ability on the ball he might be a decent finisher if it's put on a plate for him but that doesn't happen often the way we play think he will be another lyle Taylor although hope I'm wrong!

 

[S18BLADE]

UTB

 

[Blackheath Blade]

I know some may say this is harsh after just 1 game but really can't see it working out here for this lad I've seen every preseason game he's played in and he lacks pace strength and ability on the ball he might be a decent finisher if it's put on a plate for him but that doesn't happen often the way we play think he will be another lyle Taylor although hope I'm wrong!

Based on 20 fuckin minutes?? It is harsh, your comments are totally misplaced FFS.

 

[Jon Bon]

I know some may say this is harsh after just 1 game but really can't see it working out here for this lad I've seen every preseason game he's played in and he lacks pace strength and ability on the ball he might be a decent finisher if it's put on a plate for him but that doesn't happen often the way we play think he will be another lyle Taylor although hope I'm wrong!

Fucking hell, where's my oxygen inhaler? Do they not do full stops and commas in S18..???

 

[bricktop]

Still think Gary Madine would be a great signing

Nowhere near as good as resigning Ched Evans though M8!

 

[dublin 10 blade]

Should try him at the back , he did manage to kick one of the line .
20 mins leave it out , give the lad a chance .

 

[S18BLADE]

Based on 20 fuckin minutes?? It is harsh, your comments are totally misplaced FFS.

I've seen him play against fenerbahce Dundee and Huddersfield and it's my opinion looks like a player with limited ability but like I said could be a great finisher

 

[Bladesman]

 

[S18BLADE]

Fucking hell, where's my oxygen inhaler? Do they not do full stops and commas in S18..???

It's a football forum mate not an a level English essay

 

[Jon Bon]

It's a football forum mate not an a level English essay

Not that you've ever been anywhere near one of those, obviously...

 

[S18BLADE]

I'm just making a prediction on how I think it will work out for him here before everyone else starts saying it in a month or so

 

[S18BLADE]

Not that you've ever been anywhere near one of those, obviously...

No

 

[Blackheath Blade]

I've seen him play against fenerbahce Dundee and Huddersfield and it's my opinion looks like a player with limited ability but like I said could be a great finisher

Then why not give the lad a chance then at this level, instead of writing him off so quickly?
Fuck pre-season friendlies, it all counts from today onwards so reign it in a bit eh? If he's not cutting it after a dozen games then fine, come on here and ram my comments up my arse. You're out of order saying he's a waste of space after approx. 20 minutes league football.

 

[S18BLADE]

Then why not give the lad a chance then at this level, instead of writing him off so quickly?
Fuck pre-season friendlies, it all counts from today onwards so reign it in a bit eh? If he's not cutting it after a dozen games then fine, come on here and ram my comments up my arse. You're out of order saying he's a waste of space after approx. 20 minutes league football.

I see where you coming but on the basis of what I've seen so far he will be another flop of a striker! Hope he proves me wrong

 

[Blackheath Blade]

S18 - please take a balanced view mate.
I acknowledge that we are all entitled to our opinions but I hope you can see that with nine new players, it will take time to get things to click,
Today was frustrating agreed, but we will get it right.

 

[S18BLADE]

I think we will get top 2 this season Higdon should get at least 15 goals if he stays fit

 

[JOEYDEE]

I see where you coming but on the basis of what I've seen so far he will be another flop of a striker! Hope he proves me wrong

He will piggie !

 

[Living In a Fantasy World]

Too early to say, but he certainly won't do well if our wingers keep the same standard of play from today.

 

[S18BLADE]

He will piggie !

Lol

 

[lawlessdan]

I'm embarrassed by our fans sometimes

 

[Greeny96]

Plenty of players who have limited footballing ability have gone on to make a career.
Henderson
Marcus Williams
The list goes on!!!

 

[Kev Gee]

I smell pork.

 

[ScoobBlade]

I agree with the original post, with the huge transfer fee we paid for him I expected him to come off the bench yesterday and score at least 3. Maybe Gary madine would score 60-70 goals in this division but do you really want his caravan parked in front of the club shop for the rest of the season. I think I'll leave it

 

[Fife]

I remember the same being said about Flynn when he arrived. McNulty did well at Livingston so give him a chance to prove himself.

 

[FTPE]

I know some may say this is harsh after just 1 game but really can't see it working out here for this lad I've seen every preseason game he's played in and he lacks pace strength and ability on the ball he might be a decent finisher if it's put on a plate for him but that doesn't happen often the way we play think he will be another lyle Taylor although hope I'm wrong!

I do understand where you're coming from.
It's hard to pin down what the kids strengths are going to be but to make an assessment this early is crazy.
I thought miller was fantastic then last season he got stuck out wide and looked a shadow of his former self, some players adapt well out of position- some go missing.
I think until we see him up top, maybe with another striker as well then we can't really judge

 

[crucialkneeligaman]

Got high hopes for this lad, just needs that first league goal to settle him. Having said that I would have liked to see Porter come on as sub instead of McNulty and thrown two big lads at them for the last ten minutes or so, but water under bridge.

 

[Darthblade]

I do understand where you're coming from.
It's hard to pin down what the kids strengths are going to be but to make an assessment this early is crazy.
I thought miller was fantastic then last season he got stuck out wide and looked a shadow of his former self, some players adapt well out of position- some go missing.
I think until we see him up top, maybe with another striker as well then we can't really judge

I would suggest that unless we play 4-4-2 and partner him with Higdon, we will not see the best of him. I think he said himself that he's a player who likes to play off a central striker and he seems to be a finisher, not an all round athletic 30 goal a season striker.
UTB & FTP

 

[Roygbiv]

Jesus

 

[S5Blade]

Jesus

are we signing him?

 

[Roygbiv]

are we signing him?

No he is staying at Cardiff