If we sold our squad tomorrow

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
190
Reaction score
172
How much would everyone be worth? (Yes Im passing time over international break).

Moore £750K decent shot stopper but given that he can’t force his way into the side he’s unlikely to command a bigger fee.

Baldock £3M. Good all round full back.

JOC £5M. Very good centre half and in the air. Maybe worth more but his time with Brentford may perhaps count against him.

Stearman £2M. Dependable usually but can be turned inside out by real quality, like at Fulham.

Wright £500k. Useful deputy, deserves more pitch time.

Leonard £750K. Can’t really be worth much more at this stage, looks decent so far but can and will improve.

Fleck £5.5M. Very good centre midfielder, best at the club irrefutably.

Evans £2M. Been impressed with him so far, can improve like Leonard though. Perhaps too early to judge either definitively.

Coutts £4M. Very, very important to the club. Has a very important role and we have missed him massively. Fleck more valuable in my humble opinion. Again, like JOC his time elsewhere (PNE, Derby) may count against him.

Duffy £1.5M. Best attacking mid at the club but his age limits his value.

Stevens £1M Decent wing back but probably due an upgrade if we have serious promotion ambitions next season.

Holmes £600K. Not in Duffy’s class at the moment but useful asset.

Lundstram £750k. Very dependable back up centre mid and should be kept at the club. Underrated.

Lafferty £600K. Again like Lundstram useful as back up.

Clarke £3M. Good striker who has good streaks and bad streaks. Unlikely to cost more due to age and previous poor stints at other clubs limits his value. Notoriously a journeyman.

Sharp £2M. Similar to Clarke.

Donaldson £400K. Probably beginning to lose it a bit.

Ched-Free probably.

Brooks £8M. Shown great potential in first team appearances so far this season, value could soar with greater output but he is on the way to being incredibly valuable.
 



Very low valuations on some given the current market ...

Fleck £7mil
Brooks £12mil
JOC £8mil

I would push £4mil for Baldock too...

Think Sharp and Clarke are high fees given their ages I would say:

Clarke £1.2mil
Sharp £750k

Pretty much spot on with the rest
 
How much would everyone be worth? (Yes Im passing time over international break).

Moore £750K decent shot stopper but given that he can’t force his way into the side he’s unlikely to command a bigger fee.

Baldock £3M. Good all round full back.

JOC £5M. Very good centre half and in the air. Maybe worth more but his time with Brentford may perhaps count against him.

Stearman £2M. Dependable usually but can be turned inside out by real quality, like at Fulham.

Wright £500k. Useful deputy, deserves more pitch time.

Leonard £750K. Can’t really be worth much more at this stage, looks decent so far but can and will improve.

Fleck £5.5M. Very good centre midfielder, best at the club irrefutably.

Evans £2M. Been impressed with him so far, can improve like Leonard though. Perhaps too early to judge either definitively.

Coutts £4M. Very, very important to the club. Has a very important role and we have missed him massively. Fleck more valuable in my humble opinion. Again, like JOC his time elsewhere (PNE, Derby) may count against him.

Duffy £1.5M. Best attacking mid at the club but his age limits his value.

Stevens £1M Decent wing back but probably due an upgrade if we have serious promotion ambitions next season.

Holmes £600K. Not in Duffy’s class at the moment but useful asset.

Lundstram £750k. Very dependable back up centre mid and should be kept at the club. Underrated.

Lafferty £600K. Again like Lundstram useful as back up.

Clarke £3M. Good striker who has good streaks and bad streaks. Unlikely to cost more due to age and previous poor stints at other clubs limits his value. Notoriously a journeyman.

Sharp £2M. Similar to Clarke.

Donaldson £400K. Probably beginning to lose it a bit.

Ched-Free probably.

Brooks £8M. Shown great potential in first team appearances so far this season, value could soar with greater output but he is on the way to being incredibly valuable.

They're aren't many left footed CBs around; couple with him being English and I'd be holding out for £10m for JOC...
 
They're aren't many left footed CBs around; couple with him being English and I'd be holding out for £10m for JOC...

Mawson went for less than 5 million (now in England squad)- reasonable comparison. I am not sure we would get much more than that as much as he is a good player; he still makes mistakes and has poor games amidst a fairly good season.
 
Sorry, the price put for the best midfield player in the league way too low.
Assuming he recovers fitness and form, Coutts is a £10m pound player.[/QUOT

As much as I love couttsy. There is no way he is the best midfielder in the league. Would have Neves, Hourihane, Cairney, Woods and Pearson above him imo. Then I’d have Fleck, then coutts.
 



Very low valuations on some given the current market ...

Fleck £7mil
Brooks £12mil
JOC £8mil

I would push £4mil for Baldock too...

Think Sharp and Clarke are high fees given their ages I would say:

Clarke £1.2mil
Sharp £750k

Pretty much spot on with the rest
I’d have said Coutts £6m on his form at the time of injury, who knows when he comes back. Agree with your values above and most from the OP except our strikers.

I don’t think any of our strikers would command more than a £500k fee. My reason being that I don’t see another Championship club, with a wedge of cash, buying them. For any club to buy them I think they’d need to offset wages against the fee.

Evans is the only one I’m not sure about. If he completes the next 8 games. He’s played very well, so I think we might be looking at a tidy profit. Perhaps around the £4m mark, given age and international experience !
 
much as I like Clarke be lucky to get a million for a striker his age , same with Sharp both are twilight players now
prices have to be realistic

Coutts is worth a lot to us ,but on return from injury would struggle to be near a million

Donaldson should retire, or drop a division now . one of those good 1 in 10 players
 
How much would everyone be worth? (Yes Im passing time over international break).

Moore £750K decent shot stopper but given that he can’t force his way into the side he’s unlikely to command a bigger fee.

Baldock £3M. Good all round full back.

JOC £5M. Very good centre half and in the air. Maybe worth more but his time with Brentford may perhaps count against him.

Stearman £2M. Dependable usually but can be turned inside out by real quality, like at Fulham.

Wright £500k. Useful deputy, deserves more pitch time.

Leonard £750K. Can’t really be worth much more at this stage, looks decent so far but can and will improve.

Fleck £5.5M. Very good centre midfielder, best at the club irrefutably.

Evans £2M. Been impressed with him so far, can improve like Leonard though. Perhaps too early to judge either definitively.

Coutts £4M. Very, very important to the club. Has a very important role and we have missed him massively. Fleck more valuable in my humble opinion. Again, like JOC his time elsewhere (PNE, Derby) may count against him.

Duffy £1.5M. Best attacking mid at the club but his age limits his value.

Stevens £1M Decent wing back but probably due an upgrade if we have serious promotion ambitions next season.

Holmes £600K. Not in Duffy’s class at the moment but useful asset.

Lundstram £750k. Very dependable back up centre mid and should be kept at the club. Underrated.

Lafferty £600K. Again like Lundstram useful as back up.

Clarke £3M. Good striker who has good streaks and bad streaks. Unlikely to cost more due to age and previous poor stints at other clubs limits his value. Notoriously a journeyman.

Sharp £2M. Similar to Clarke.

Donaldson £400K. Probably beginning to lose it a bit.

Ched-Free probably.

Brooks £8M. Shown great potential in first team appearances so far this season, value could soar with greater output but he is on the way to being incredibly valuable.

Interesting topic

Think some are too high and some too low. I dont agree but teams will pay more for the likes of Brooks but not so much for older or injury prone players.

Just about right

O'Connell

Coutts

Stevens

Duffy

Lundstram

Leonard

Evans

Moore

Duffy

Too low

Brooks would prob fetch 10 million plus.

I think Fleck would be more 7-8 million.

Baldock - could be more if he keeps up current form

Too much

Sharp would not be more than a million due to age - Clarke maybe a bit more as more all around player but depends if he gets back to form. If we had sold him in the summer for 500,000 noone would have bat an eyelid - then in January Villa were rumoured to be interested for 3 million. Reality is somewhere in between.

Stearman too - bit of a journeyman at this level - believe we only paid half a million so not sure that his value has gone up since then?

You wont get much more than a few hundred grand for Lafferty - not played at this level and thus only lower league clubs would probably be interested.

Ditto for Wright - not sure teams would pay 500k for him really - sounds harsh as done ok in the few games he has played this season and a good pro but not young and played most of his career lower league/non league.

Holmes - See Wright - only even played lower league - if he moves it will be lower down and a few hundred grand tops is what any club would pay

Donaldson was given away on a free pretty much - and out of contract - days of him commanding any kind of fee long gone.

Agree on Ched not sure who would pay a fee of any sort other than nominal for a striker who has barely played in 2 seasons and not scored for over a year.

No mention of Freeman? Prob 1 million tops but could be a lot higher if he gets back in the side but not proven it at Champ level.
 
I read as far as Baldock £3m

I nearly choked on that one too but managed to stumble on to Wright £500k.
I love Jake, but he's a journeyman defender the wrong side of 30 who has played all his games (a dozen this season apart) in non league and the lower leagues .

Please explain exactly who would pay the £500k, as I have a spare London bridge to sell.
 
I think these are more realistic “Sheffield United sales” prices

Moore £750K

Baldock £800k

JOC £3M.

Stearman £800k (wrong side of 30)

Wright. Free (wrong side of 30 only been a lower league player before)

Leonard £750K.

Fleck £5M

Lee Evans £1M

Coutts £5M (depending on how he recovers from injury)

Duffy £800k (wrong side of 30)

Stevens £800k

Holmes £450k

Lundstram £450k

Lafferty £150K

Clarke £800k (will be less this time next season)

Sharp £1M. (Wrong side of 30, still worth 10-15 goals in mid table Championship)

Donaldson.Free (coming to his twilight days)

Ched. Free. (Legs look gone + still a lot of hassle for those taking him on)

Brooks £10M (even we should get a least this for an improving youngster in this market)
 
Interesting topic

Think some are too high and some too low. I dont agree but teams will pay more for the likes of Brooks but not so much for older or injury prone players.

Just about right

O'Connell

Coutts

Stevens

Duffy

Lundstram

Leonard

Evans

Moore

Duffy

Too low

Brooks would prob fetch 10 million plus.

I think Fleck would be more 7-8 million.

Baldock - could be more if he keeps up current form

Too much

Sharp would not be more than a million due to age - Clarke maybe a bit more as more all around player but depends if he gets back to form. If we had sold him in the summer for 500,000 noone would have bat an eyelid - then in January Villa were rumoured to be interested for 3 million. Reality is somewhere in between.

Stearman too - bit of a journeyman at this level - believe we only paid half a million so not sure that his value has gone up since then?

You wont get much more than a few hundred grand for Lafferty - not played at this level and thus only lower league clubs would probably be interested.

Ditto for Wright - not sure teams would pay 500k for him really - sounds harsh as done ok in the few games he has played this season and a good pro but not young and played most of his career lower league/non league.

Holmes - See Wright - only even played lower league - if he moves it will be lower down and a few hundred grand tops is what any club would pay

Donaldson was given away on a free pretty much - and out of contract - days of him commanding any kind of fee long gone.

Agree on Ched not sure who would pay a fee of any sort other than nominal for a striker who has barely played in 2 seasons and not scored for over a year.

No mention of Freeman? Prob 1 million tops but could be a lot higher if he gets back in the side but not proven it at Champ level.
In hindsight, definitely went too high with Donaldson and most likely too with Lafferty. With Wright, could see a biggish league one club with decent funds paying perhaps £300-500k being that he is proven in that division. £500k is perhaps on the high side though.
 
Interesting topic

Think some are too high and some too low. I dont agree but teams will pay more for the likes of Brooks but not so much for older or injury prone players.

Just about right

O'Connell

Coutts

Stevens

Duffy

Lundstram

Leonard

Evans

Moore

Duffy

Too low

Brooks would prob fetch 10 million plus.

I think Fleck would be more 7-8 million.

Baldock - could be more if he keeps up current form

Too much

Sharp would not be more than a million due to age - Clarke maybe a bit more as more all around player but depends if he gets back to form. If we had sold him in the summer for 500,000 noone would have bat an eyelid - then in January Villa were rumoured to be interested for 3 million. Reality is somewhere in between.

Stearman too - bit of a journeyman at this level - believe we only paid half a million so not sure that his value has gone up since then?

You wont get much more than a few hundred grand for Lafferty - not played at this level and thus only lower league clubs would probably be interested.

Ditto for Wright - not sure teams would pay 500k for him really - sounds harsh as done ok in the few games he has played this season and a good pro but not young and played most of his career lower league/non league.

Holmes - See Wright - only even played lower league - if he moves it will be lower down and a few hundred grand tops is what any club would pay

Donaldson was given away on a free pretty much - and out of contract - days of him commanding any kind of fee long gone.

Agree on Ched not sure who would pay a fee of any sort other than nominal for a striker who has barely played in 2 seasons and not scored for over a year.

No mention of Freeman? Prob 1 million tops but could be a lot higher if he gets back in the side but not proven it at Champ level.
In hindsight, definitely went too high with Donaldson and most likely too with Lafferty. With Wright, could see a biggish league one club with decent funds paying perhaps £300-500k being that he is proven in that division. £500k is perhaps on the high side though.
 
Why is he not worth £3m ? Probably our most consistent player

Thats one I thought would be too low. Fast, athletic, skilfull - could easily do a Lowton who is an established Prem player for a top half club. Baldock has to keep doing it though but he is one of players who has looked comfortable and could step up -pace and atleticism as welll as ability makes him stand out.
 
With the exception of one or two I personally think most of those are high.

Fleck and JOC aside maybe, I think you could halve quite a few imho.
 



We could probably do a big shop at Morrison's and get a tank of fuel!
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom