if only one was to sign who would you prefer?

[davidpinder]

KMAC OR WILLO

Some may say no brainer but take everything into account, goals, creating chances, injury record, easy of replacement. etc etc

 

[SwissBlade]

Definitely Willo for me. He contributed a hell of a lot more over the season

 

[gavtheblade]

k.mac for me,he`s naturally gifted albeit on the unfit side,but he doesnt need to be 100%fit to thread killer passes into the box,quinny and monty can do the running for him.

 

[metalblade]

I'd have told both of them to feck off long before now.

 

[Chris1012]

Kmac for me also. Only 23 compared to Williamsons 30 years.
They are both crocks!

 

[TopBoy]

KMAC for me. One of the few footballers in recent times I'm happy to pay to watch at Bramall Lane.

 

[sheffielder]

Kmac. I would be interested to see how many goals were scored by Willo when McDonald wasn't playing. If you want Willo over McDonald I think you don't realise how much space McDonald's passing and awareness creates even if it wasn't the 'killer pass'

 

[Jim Chimmerney]

Reading between the lines, I think Zoko is down for the 'Willo role' for next season. I think we would find it easier to replace a Willo type of player, there aren't many KMacs around at this level.

 

[Balham]

McDonald for me. Class act; always seems to have time on the ball.

Williamson is good but always has the air of arrogance about him - and there's also a question mark over his application at times (although he seemed to knuckle down last season)

 

[Latters]

McDonald every time for me. He's the midfield player we've waited so long for. The one that can actually dictate the flow and pace of a game. We should avoid losing him at all cost.

 

[Houso]

McDonald.

As much as Willo was a big player for us last season and chipped in with plenty of goals, I much prefer pace on both flanks and that's certainly something that he doesn't offer.

 

[super_pig]

KMac for me.. the only player in years that has made me 'want' to go to the Lane.. worth the entry fee on his own

 

[stannyblade]

Mcdonald for me for the same reasons as mentioned

 

[Trafford]

Both made a difference in most games that they played but I would choose McDonald on the basis that we missed him most when he didn't play.

 

[georgebernardshaw]

Kmac for me also. Only 23 compared to Williamsons 30 years.
They are both crocks!

"Sheffield United today announced their signing of Nigerian striker Lance Ambu Bupa from Bayern Munich - no fee has been disclosed, but the Northern General Hospital has been informed".

 

[Bladesman]

Kmac despite Willo's goes last year I think Kmac was the better all rounder and provided the service for most of the goals anyway.