Billy should be dropped

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?




dc_blade said:
I think it's just because literally every creative player we have is out at the same time: Coutts, Fleck, Duffy, and Brooks. Get two or three of them back and Wilderball will return with a vengeance. No need for Hanson in my book.
Click to expand...
Until they're back then I think he should be in the team. Duffy and brooks should be back next game and fleck back in just 2 games now instead of 3 :) :)
 
Deadbat said:
I have to agree. He scored 2 at Burton but over the last couple of months he has been really poor. Sadly we have only Donaldon, Lavery as options and not sure they are good enough. He may have to go to Brooks-Clarke again and persist with it for a few weeks.
Click to expand...


Spot on as usual.
 
Lmaobob said:
Tyler Durden can you defend him today? What's so good about Billy? Was a fantastic pass to Lafferty out wide for sure in last 5 mins and saw him on arse for nearly the whole 90 minutes

He needs dropping. He's not good enough

Screw the goal statistics, he offers us barely anything

Strikers are either small and fast or tall and strong and good in the air. Billy is none of those except small
Click to expand...

TIme to show a bit of respect to the man who chose him to be captain and picks him every week. Is Sharp the reason we lost today?
 
Lmaobob said:
Until they're back then I think he should be in the team. Duffy and brooks should be back next game and fleck back in just 2 games now instead of 3 :) :)
Click to expand...

I think he's likely to move on In January but if he can do a job for us until then, why not?
 
sheffielder said:
TIme to show a bit of respect to the man who chose him to be captain and picks him every week. Is Sharp the reason we lost today?
Click to expand...
I have the utmost respect for Wilder however not putting Wright
back in the team yet again is genuinely bonkers

In terms of Wilder's philosophy, it's based on form - Billy is out of form so why is he still playing?
 
Lmaobob said:
Did you go the match today? We played lump ball the whole match. If you didn't go to the match today then clearly you didn't see us playing lump ball and are probably one of those moaners about the loyalty point system when the big matches come round the corner.
Click to expand...

Yes I went to the game today and yes we did play lump ball at times second half and look how it paid off? if you honestly think that Hanson is a better option than sharp at the minute I think you should lay off the beer because there's no way Hanson should be starting games in the championship. We had to play lump ball at times today because we was missing Duffy and fleck yes it's hard times but to change everything just to get Hanson in the team and play lump ball up to him then i seriously think you need to consider what your saying. Wilder plays the way he does and can't see him agreeing with your opinion thankfully because we are in 6th place and just going through a tough patch which we knew we would go through at some point. I personally would prefer to see us go at it and attack it and go and give it a go not just lump it up front and hope Hanson can get on it. I know let's go for madine in January and play like Bolton and lump it up to madine i am sure that's our best option.
 
Lmaobob said:
I have the utmost respect for Wilder however not putting Wright
back in the team yet again is genuinely bonkers

In terms of Wilder's philosophy, it's based on form - Billy is out of form so why is he still playing?
Click to expand...

Well today, what were his options? Basically it was Donaldson. He's tried this before at QPR and didn't work. If Carruthers even thought about playing then maybe CLarke and SHarp could have been effective
 
dc_blade said:
I think he's likely to move on In January but if he can do a job for us until then, why not?
Click to expand...
We have him so we may aswell use him. If he is wanting to try lafferty in centre midfield then surely he will try Hanson again
 
biggey blade said:
Yes I went to the game today and yes we did play lump ball at times second half and look how it paid off? if you honestly think that Hanson is a better option than sharp at the minute I think you should lay off the beer because there's no way Hanson should be starting games in the championship. We had to play lump ball at times today because we was missing Duffy and fleck yes it's hard times but to change everything just to get Hanson in the team and play lump ball up to him then i seriously think you need to consider what your saying. Wilder plays the way he does and can't see him agreeing with your opinion thankfully because we are in 6th place and just going through a tough patch which we knew we would go through at some point. I personally would prefer to see us go at it and attack it and go and give it a go not just lump it up front and hope Hanson can get on it. I know let's go for madine in January and play like Bolton and lump it up to madine i am sure that's our best option.
Click to expand...
1) I didn't say Hanson is better than sharp. He is just more useful in the air
2) Oh okay, so you went to the match. Did you watch the football match?
3) I don't drink alcohol :)
4) WE LUMPED IT UP TODAY. IT IS NOT HOW I WANT US TO PLAY. I AM SAYING THAT IF WILDER IS RESORTING TO THAT TACTIC THEN BILLY ISN'T THE ANSWER.
5) next time you don't fucking read my reply, I'm not going to waste another second on replying
 
sheffielder said:
Well today, what were his options? Basically it was Donaldson. He's tried this before at QPR and didn't work. If Carruthers even thought about playing then maybe CLarke and SHarp could have been effective
Click to expand...
Lavery was on the bench too also you know
 



Lmaobob said:
1) I didn't say Hanson is better than sharp. He is just more useful in the air
2) Oh okay, so you went to the match. Did you watch the football match?
3) I don't drink alcohol :)
4) WE LUMPED IT UP TODAY. IT IS NOT HOW I WANT IS TO PLAY. I AM SAYING THAT IF WILDER IS RESORTING TO THAT TACTIC THEN BILLY ISN'T THE ANSWER.
5) next time you don't fucking read my reply, I'm not going to waste another second on replying
Click to expand...

4) WOrked well last season Sharp and Hanson..
 
sitwell said:
Why single sharp out ? Apart from slater Moore and maybe stearman every plAyer was awful. Sharp wasn’t in the same league as awfulness as carruthers
Click to expand...
Because to win a match you have to score more goals than the other team. We didn't score any goals, And it's the job of the strikers. Not blaming clarke at all as he battled through everything and has been sublime this season, however it felt like passing the ball to Billy ended up in them retrieving the ball
 
Lmaobob said:
Tyler Durden can you defend him today? What's so good about Billy? Was a fantastic pass to Lafferty out wide for sure in last 5 mins and saw him on arse for nearly the whole 90 minutes

He needs dropping. He's not good enough

Screw the goal statistics, he offers us barely anything

Strikers are either small and fast or tall and strong and good in the air. Billy is none of those except small
Click to expand...

Fucking stupid post ... if the team creates chances he scored goals ... he didn't get a chance today
 
Drunk blade said:
Fucking stupid post ... if the team creates chances he scored goals ... he didn't get a chance today
Click to expand...
It shoudlnt get handed to him on a plate. A championship striker should be doing more than waiting for a pass that gets him 1 on 1 with the keeper. He needs to actually get past players, which he NEVER does.

The ball got played to him earlier, outside to the box, on the left and on a counter attack. He didn't do shit with it apart from give them the ball back
 
Tyler Durden said:
This thread is proof that it's not only Billy who's had a shocker...
Click to expand...
Sorry let me just edit the title with the following

DISCLAIMER; I AM TRYING TO SAY THAT BILLY IS THE WHOLE REASON WE LOST TODAY AND WAS THE ONLY PLAYER WHO PLAYED POORLY.

is that okay with you Tyler? Do I get your approval for that?
 
Lmaobob said:
1) I didn't say Hanson is better than sharp. He is just more useful in the air
2) Oh okay, so you went to the match. Did you watch the football match?
3) I don't drink alcohol :)
4) WE LUMPED IT UP TODAY. IT IS NOT HOW I WANT IS TO PLAY. I AM SAYING THAT IF WILDER IS RESORTING TO THAT TACTIC THEN BILLY ISN'T THE ANSWER.
5) next time you don't fucking read my reply, I'm not going to waste another second on replying
Click to expand...

1) Last time I checked you play your best 11?
2) No i thought I'd go to the game and not watch it?
3) Maybe you should do then
4) I am not saying we didn't lump it up today in the second half but it's not how we play and it shouldn't even be an option. And if you have just listened to wilder on radio sheffield then I'd say he wasn't happy with the way the players played and I am pretty sure there's no way he is going to go to lump ball tactics. But as for Billy for lump ball yes I agree he isn't good for this but I don't want to see us playing lump ball so I'll stick to sharp over Hanson.
5) I read your reply but I just don't understand where your coming from because we shouldn't even be considering playing lump ball at all. We are still 6th in the championship just having a bad run at the minute but I didn't see you slagging sharp off last Friday night when he played well and hit the bar 2x and forced there keeper into making a wonderful save from a corner.
6) Also save me time and don't bother replying because I think your talking rubbish even considering playing lump ball.
 
Lmaobob said:
Sorry let me just edit the title with the following

DISCLAIMER; I AM TRYING TO SAY THAT BILLY IS THE WHOLE REASON WE LOST TODAY AND WAS THE ONLY PLAYER WHO PLAYED POORLY.

is that okay with you Tyler? Do I get your approval for that?
Click to expand...

I'm sure you don't need my approval to stick the boot into Billy. By all means carry on.
 



Lmaobob said:
It shoudlnt get handed to him on a plate. A championship striker should be doing more than waiting for a pass that gets him 1 on 1 with the keeper. He needs to actually get past players, which he NEVER does.

The ball got played to him earlier, outside to the box, on the left and on a counter attack. He didn't do shit with it apart from give them the ball back
Click to expand...

He did fuck all against Brentford appart from score the winning goal and stick another in which was wrongly ruled out for offside, would you rather have had him on the bench in that game? ... he scored 30 goals last season getting good service ... if the 1st team midfield are out we are going to struggle to create chances
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

joe casey
Rob Holding and his magical returning hairline
2 3
Replies
80
Views
8K
Kevincarterversion2.0
Kevincarterversion2.0
Maurice Maurice
It's that time again
Replies
5
Views
939
LBA_Blade
LBA_Blade
Coolblade
Striker stats - Campbell stands out!
Replies
13
Views
2K
Barmyblade
B
Deadbat
Preston 3 United 2 - report/ratings
2
Replies
55
Views
4K
Rodley
Rodley
Silkblade
We will be fine
Replies
8
Views
1K
Pintor75
Pintor75

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom