Ayew or Marsh?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Who would you rather be giving minutes to this season?

  • Jordan Ayew

    Votes: 31 12.7%

  • Louis Marsh

    Votes: 214 87.3%
  • Total voters
    245



any time Marsh has played at our level, even in cups against lower opposition, he has looked like a kid in a mans game. Miles off it right now. Maybe he gets there but physically I don't think he has it. Look at a Louie Reed who has had a great career in the lower leagues type future I suspect.
 
Geordie Blade said:
Love seeing all the the outrage at something that is utter speculation.

I've heard that he's on £1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 per minute, and I'm furious.
Click to expand...
It’s based on what evidence is out there. There’s no outrage, just educated guesses.

Happy to here a logical counter argument if you have one.
 
We get to name 9 substitutes. Surely we could find space to include a couple of the better up and coming players from the under 21 squad without leaving ourselves exposed. Just take a look at our bench on Saturday and it is a pretty depressing read. Of the 9 only Donavon and at a push possibly Cannon could be classed as players who are an an upward career trajectory. Of the rest nearly all are past their prime and on a downward path and unlikely (hopefully) to be with us in 12 months time. Personally I would rather see the likes of Marsh who have the potential to improve and develop rather than waste money on the likes of Ayew, Rothwell, Shackleton etc.
 
Blade59 said:
We get to name 9 substitutes. Surely we could find space to include a couple of the better up and coming players from the under 21 squad without leaving ourselves exposed. Just take a look at our bench on Saturday and it is a pretty depressing read. Of the 9 only Donavon and at a push possibly Cannon could be classed as players who are an an upward career trajectory. Of the rest nearly all are past their prime and on a downward path and unlikely (hopefully) to be with us in 12 months time. Personally I would rather see the likes of Marsh who have the potential to improve and develop rather than waste money on the likes of Ayew, Rothwell, Shackleton etc.
Click to expand...
Subs vs Stoke; Wilder’s view:
Davies - solid backup keeper
Doherty - culture carrier; experience >>> youth
Rothwell - see Doherty
Cannon - Wilder’s big bet. #9. £10,000,000.
Ayew - see Doherty
Donovan - contractual obligation to have him in the Matchday squad
Shackleton - unlucky with injuries. Had we not given him a 3 year deal he’d be tearing up the PL with Hull.
Chongeh - good lad
McGuinness - well, we needed a 9th sub.
 
Wonder how having 3 recent + RND ( 27 now) ex academy players starting in the side compares to the rest of the league?
 
Balham said:
Subs vs Stoke; Wilder’s view:
Davies - solid backup keeper
Doherty - culture carrier; experience >>> youth
Rothwell - see Doherty
Cannon - Wilder’s big bet. #9. £10,000,000.
Ayew - see Doherty
Donovan - contractual obligation to have him in the Matchday squad
Shackleton - unlucky with injuries. Had we not given him a 3 year deal he’d be tearing up the PL with Hull.
Chongeh - good lad
McGuinness - well, we needed a 9th sub.
Click to expand...
😱
That subs bench is the definition of a club teetering on the edge of the abyss.
There is literally no hope for our future in there.
We are sleepwalking towards oblivion with Wilder's recruitment.
Where are the kind of signings he made in 16-19 ?
Unearthing young fit lower league players who put everything into our success coz they wanted to develop thenselves.
 
Proper Blade said:
I think you're being incredibly generous to Marsh in your assessment here.

'The most technically gifted attacker we've brought through the youth setup', 'bags of energy', 'bags of talent' - these are phrases I would reserve for generationally-gifted talents, not someone who is 22 and has 6 goals in 35 career appearances.
Click to expand...
Anyone remember Diego De Girolamo? Imagine if we'd have played him regularly in the Championship.
 
S64 Blade said:
It’s based on what evidence is out there. There’s no outrage, just educated guesses.

Happy to here a logical counter argument if you have one.
Click to expand...
The PL contract Leicester gave him should not be used to estimate the contract we have given him now. He could've been on £100,000 a week then, but if nobody wants to pay a tenth of that now it means nothing.
 
Geordie Blade said:
What ‘evidence’ is there?
Click to expand...
As mentioned in the earlier post; his previous salary, average salaries in the league, what salaries we pay players.

I see you chose not to provide your own counter evidence for why it’s somehow impossible we’d be paying him £20k a week.
 
S64 Blade said:
As mentioned in the earlier post; his previous salary, average salaries in the league, what salaries we pay players.

I see you chose not to provide your own counter evidence for why it’s somehow impossible we’d be paying him £20k a week.
Click to expand...

Ok, please can you show the evidence of:
  • his previous salary
  • the average salary in the league
  • what salaries we pay players

I’m saying that the above points are speculation - the evidence for something being speculation is the lack of evidence.
 
Geordie Blade said:
Ok, please can you show the evidence of:
  • his previous salary
  • the average salary in the league
  • what salaries we pay players

I’m saying that the above points are speculation - the evidence for something being speculation is the lack of evidence.
Click to expand...
Here are the sources you asked for:
  • His Leicester salary: SalaryLeaks lists £23,000 a week, while Salary Sport lists £45,000. The truth probably exists somewhere in the middle, or the former amount was maybe a reduced salary post relegation.
  • Championship salaries: Salary Sport puts the average at £18,140 a week across 481 senior players. Given we still have one of the highest wage bills in the league, it’s not a stretch to think we we will be around that or higher, for experienced players.
  • Salary Sport gives United’s senior players an average of £25,695, although that is inflated by its Phillips, Doherty and Hamza figures (plus randomly including Jack Rodwell, albeit on a very low value). It is missing current first team players though too, for balance.
These are published estimates, and I’m treating them as such. I haven’t claimed to have seen Ayew’s contract or established that he earns £20,000 a week. My point is that it’s a plausible figure in the context of his reported previous wages and the estimated wages at this level and at the club.

So, for the third time: what evidence do you have to say that £20,000 a week isn’t plausible? Pointing out that it hasn’t been confirmed doesn’t establish that it’s implausible.
 
Last edited:



From what I've seen of Marsh, he's going to be a L1/L2 player. Good talent but not physically up to higher levels or showing the decision making/class in the opportunities given.

Ayew might yet get fit and be an asset. He might not.
 
Admittedly I've only ever seen Marsh play in the daft cup games... but... at 22yo, id say there's probably a reason he's never played at a higher level than League 2.

For comparison, Tom Cannon was a full international at 21.
 
S64 Blade said:
Here are the sources you asked for:
  • His Leicester salary: SalaryLeaks lists £23,000 a week, while Salary Sport lists £45,000. The truth probably exists somewhere in the middle, or the former amount was maybe a reduced salary post relegation.
  • Championship salaries: Salary Sport puts the average at £18,140 a week across 481 senior players. Given we still have one of the highest wage bills in the league, it’s not a stretch to think we we will be around that or higher, for experienced players.
  • Salary Sport gives United’s senior players an average of £25,695, although that is inflated by its Phillips, Doherty and Hamza figures (plus randomly including Jack Rodwell, albeit on a very low value). It is missing current first team players though too, for balance.
These are published estimates, and I’m treating them as such. I haven’t claimed to have seen Ayew’s contract or established that he earns £20,000 a week. My point is that it’s a plausible figure in the context of his reported previous wages and the estimated wages at this level and at the club.

So, for the third time: what evidence do you have to say that £20,000 a week isn’t plausible? Pointing out that it hasn’t been confirmed doesn’t establish that it’s implausible.
Click to expand...

I haven’t said that it’s implausible.

I said that it’s speculation, which it is. The sources you cite are helpful for putting together a guess - but that’s exactly what it is. Even if the sources are correct, we still require a large degree of supposition to arrive at a value of £20,000 a week. It’s plausible that it’s £20,000 but it’s also plausible that it’s quite a lot lower given his age and situation.

My point is that people have jumped to conclusions and are angry about a speculative value, when they simply don’t know what it is.
 
Thinking if we are safe from relegation in January? Should look at gradually bringing both into the first team squad, with being given game time.
We are not going to be a high spending club, need to get our house in order.
The club need to set a stratergy for the next two to three seasons.
No matter what you think about our new owners. They are looking at trying to make this club secure. This comes with wise management, ask any business owner they will say the same.
 
Slim Man said:
Just another goal for Marsh yesterday in a loan spell that's doing his confidence the world of good, while we're paying an OAP 20 odd k a week to come off the bench, not be a goal threat and tire after 3 minutes.

Marsh is, by a distance, the most technically gifted attacker we've brought through the youth setup bar the obvious superstar at Man City. Bags of energy, bags of talent and despite being slight he finds pockets of space allover the pitch.

Ayew is 35, coming off the back of 2 relegations, has never scored double figures in his career, and put into an unfit, slow and lethargic team with no energy is the complete antithesis of what we need in the team right now.

Wilder's talk of 'needing experience' as a reason for signing Ayew just makes absolutely no sense to me and is a huge reason why I think he's done for. All he's signed is experienced past it has beens or never beens, the young players we have ARE experienced. The only one that isn't is on loan from Brentford and happens to be our best player 🤣

He doesn't like bringing youth through, he doesn't trust them. But if Marsh leaves the club without having a proper run in the team or chance to prove himself it would be the biggest damning indictment on both the manager and coaching staff yet. He has everything you'd want from a deep lying forward/number 10 at this level. He's basically a young Bamford, and it's crazy that we haven't just had him as his understudy for the season...
Click to expand...
Went to the Hallam game pre season. He didn’t look that slight on pitch compared to some of the Center backs he was up against. I’d have him back in that squad. We are a team screaming out for creativity
 
GeorgeDonis1889 said:
Osula is by some distance better than Marsh.
Click to expand...
I don't think you understand basic English words or football terminology

Osula is anything but a 'technical footballer' he's a genetic freak who is fast as fuck and physical as they come, the football has been coached into him but he couldn't trap a bag of cement even now
 
mattbianco1 said:
Admittedly I've only ever seen Marsh play in the daft cup games... but... at 22yo, id say there's probably a reason he's never played at a higher level than League 2.

For comparison, Tom Cannon was a full international at 21.
Click to expand...
For balance people were saying the same about Seriki until he started playing regularly when Mee picked up a knock and Tanganga had to go back to CB. He had a stinker of a loan at Rotherham the season before too.
 
Neither. The Ayew signing apart from 5 mins against Wolves has predictably been a shocker that needs knocking on the head. Marsh currently is miles off the champ, he is doing the right thing getting a season out on loan in league 2, hopefully he gets through it without any injuries as he does seem to pick a few up
 



FTPE said:
Nah, Osula was helped by phsical gifts. Just like Jebbo. Marsh is going to have to rely on ability, just like David Brooks did. I don't think he's on the same trajectory as Brooks, but technically he's one of the best we have produced in a long time.
Click to expand...
If our strength and conditioning people haven't managed to get him up to scratch for championship football then questions need asking. There's a reason they haven't sold him yet.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Slim Man
Baptiste / CB Situation
Replies
27
Views
2K
Lowen
Lowen
Champagneblade
Could Marsh be developed to be the next Didzy?
2
Replies
36
Views
3K
103SecondsOfMagic
1
INTERUNITED
Pace and Height
Replies
20
Views
762
metalblade
metalblade
Deadbat
Fleetwood 1 United 0 - summary / ratings
2
Replies
48
Views
3K
fifty shades of blade
F
Bergen Blade
Players you wanted to see fail before they left
2
Replies
51
Views
4K
Balham
Balham

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom