Player Suggestion Souttar played and scored last night

[GeorgeDonis1889]

We lost games in the run up to Xmas that we shouldn't have lost

We lost to Leeds and Boro in October

So you made up the games we lost in the run up to Christmas just like you made up me claiming the owners being embarrassing will impact signings.

Not worth responding to now. You're just making nonsense claims then moving on to something else when it's pointed out.

Do us some tactical analysis of the games we lost in the run up to Xmas and come back when you've done it

 

[NerdyBlade]

So you made up the games we lost in the run up to Christmas just like you made up me claiming the owners being embarrassing will impact signings.

Mate - we lost to Leeds and Boro. If you're wanting to get promoted, you shouldn't be losing games like that. I think that's a pretty clear statement

But again - explain to me how going negative against Leeds, Boro and Burnley is the sign of success and that Wilder had the tactics figured out correctly?

 

[tommy]

I truly don't get why souttar post has got into this ! At the end off the day we are fans we all want said player ect but it's out off our hands and we could sign any player in the world and spend silly money but if that player doesn't turn up in our shirt that's not Wilders fault not the club ...it's the player not wanting to produce what is expected.....it's not football manager...it's real life and if souttar signs hopefully he comes in with them proformaces we had when he was us before....end off the day we are all fans and all have our views....and this forum is here for us to say our views...if people don't like it then leave ...don't start at each other....we are all blades

 

[NerdyBlade]

I truly don't get why souttar post has got into this ! At the end off the day we are fans we all want said player ect but it's out off our hands and we could sign any player in the world and spend silly money but if that player doesn't turn up in our shirt that's not Wilders fault not the club ...it's the player not wanting to produce what is expected.....it's not football manager...it's real life and if souttar signs hopefully he comes in with them proformaces we had when he was us before....end off the day we are all fans and all have our views....and this forum is here for us to say our views...if people don't like it then leave ...don't start at each other....we are all blades

"HEY. STOP ARGUING, OR I WILL TURN THIS CAR AROUND AND THERE WILL BE NO SOUTTAR FOR ANYONE!"

 

[GeorgeDonis1889]

you're wanting to get promoted, you shouldn't be losing games like that.

Wtf are you talking about. Leeds won the league with 100 points you loon

 

[NerdyBlade]

Wtf are you talking about. Leeds won the league with 100 points you loon

And this is how we set up to try and beat them.

You genuinely think that CW in big games like this had the tactics right? And that following the collapse in the run in, considering he'd shown he struggled in the big games, he immediately deserved more money and another crack at it?

 

[GeorgeDonis1889]

View attachment 241051
And this is how we set up to try and beat them.

You genuinely think that CW in big games like this had the tactics right? And that following the collapse in the run in, considering he'd shown he struggled in the big games, he immediately deserved more money and another crack at it?

You just said we shouldn't be losing like that. Away at the champions who finished on 100 points Ridiculous

 

[tommy]

Let's get this back to souttar comments not all this rubbish having at go at each other

 

[NerdyBlade]

You just said we shouldn't be losing like that. Away at the champions who finished on 100 points Ridiculous

Were they on 100pts at that time? No

Were they beatable? Yes

So again, I'll ask - is that how we should go into big games that we need to win if we wanted to keep pace

 

[GeorgeDonis1889]

Were they on 100pts at that time? No

Were they beatable? Yes

So again, I'll ask - is that how we should go into big games that we need to win if we wanted to keep pace

It was the team that won the league with 100 points away from home and apparently we "shouldn't be losing games like that". That implies we shouldn't lose any games which does actually seem to tally your opinion. But of course you're not an entitled brat or anything

 

[Wards]

Just bookmarking the last few pages in case my glass eye is struggling to nod off later.

 

[Berkshire Blade]

Where have I said this wasn't good enough? We lost games in the run up to Xmas that we shouldn't have lost

Takeover delay + injuries meant we went into December period basically hoping to limp through to January window where incomings could help. Unfortunately Souttar got injured too!

 

[Berkshire Blade]

Players gone to Germany today so I suspect it it isn't done already it will be a few more days now

 

[NerdyBlade]

It was the team that won the league with 100 points away from home and apparently we "shouldn't be losing games like that". That implies we shouldn't lose any games which does actually seem to tally your opinion. But of course you're not an entitled brat or anything

But they weren't on 100 points. They weren't running away with it. They were beatable. And Wilder decided to sit back against them.

But sure, criticising Wilder for putting that squad out is entitled and spoilt.

Explain to me why that squad that he put out isn't a tactical misstep

 

[NerdyBlade]

Takeover delay + injuries meant we went into December period basically hoping to limp through to January window where incomings could help. Unfortunately Souttar got injured too!

We were pretty much full strength for the Leeds game - stacked bench, really weird starting 11

 

[ComedyClub]

Some very fair points. I’d heard that Brewster wasn’t Wilders first choice… he wanted an experienced Prem striker but as ever with United, we wouldn’t push the boat out on wages so he had to settle for a youngster with huge potential. Always lots more than we get to see going in to these decisions I guess.

Whoever told you that parts talking shit. Was obvious from the get go it was Brewster or nobody.

 

[EddieColquhoun]

One didn't get a minute of preseason

Except for the minutes he played.

 

[NerdyBlade]

View attachment 241051
And this is how we set up to try and beat them.

You genuinely think that CW in big games like this had the tactics right? And that following the collapse in the run in, considering he'd shown he struggled in the big games, he immediately deserved more money and another crack at it?

This actually highlights something else - Souttar is an integral player, sure, but we need the right team around him

 

[NerdyBlade]

Except for the minutes he played.

45mins against Chesterfield and nothing else since?

 

[EddieColquhoun]

45mins against Chesterfield and nothing else since?

He was injured and then played on Saturday.

 

[GeorgeDonis1889]

One didn't get a minute of preseason

Except for the minutes he played

45mins against Chesterfield

Perfect

 

[NerdyBlade]

Perfect

Seem to be ignoring the point about the Leeds line up there mate

 

[NerdyBlade]

He was injured and then played on Saturday.

When did he come on on Saturday? Can't see him as any of the players that came on

 

[GeorgeDonis1889]

Seem to be ignoring the point about the Leeds line up there mate

Seem to have made another nonsense claim, been called out, so changed the claim and are carrying on like you were correct all along.

 

[NerdyBlade]

Seem to have made another nonsense claim, been called out, so changed the claim and are carrying on like you were correct all along.

I've asked outside of the 45mins when he played, I'm willing to be corrected

Explain to me how Wilders line up against Leeds was the right tactical decision?

 

[Boxer Blade]

I think some folk on here have got too much time on their hands.

 

[NerdyBlade]

I think some folk on here have got too much time on their hands.

The alternative is making friends and being social

...ew

 

[MartBlade]

Whoever told you that parts talking shit. Was obvious from the get go it was Brewster or nobody.

The guy who told me that would have been very well placed to know at the time … and I certainly wasn’t saying Chris didn’t want Brewster… but his ideal was an experienced prem striker… it was quickly realised our wage budget would not stretch to that.

 

[Bladesman]

"HEY. STOP ARGUING, OR I WILL TURN THIS CAR AROUND AND THERE WILL BE NO SOUTTAR FOR ANYONE!"

 

[Gin&Juice]

Scootah or Souttar? Either way it’s been an endless summer of speculation.