‘Blame lies with who signed him’ – Arrival from Sheffield United goes from cult hero to flop within months

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

silver blade

Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2014
Messages
758
Reaction score
1,132

For all his positive qualities, he is ultimately a striker who can't strike.

Our first season back in the Championship, "McBurnie will score today" was a sick running joke.
 
Anyone else finding it impossible to read this? It just flashes from one advert to another repeatedly
 
Haven't seen any of his games this year, but man, 3 goals is rough. No wonder they're looking at him as a scapegoat.
 
Anyone else finding it impossible to read this? It just flashes from one advert to another repeatedly
Don't think you're missing too much to be honest! Pure click bait "journalism".

I've checked the articles in La Provincia and none of them seem to single out McBurnie at all, just that the recruitment overall was not good enough. Link to the article in question if interested. https://www.laprovincia.es/ud-las-palmas/2025/05/09/ud-palmas-cava-propia-tumba-117229669.html
 
It's the article facts or opinions?

I've opened it twice but closed due to the ads
 
Las Palmas "View From" is here from March

 
Amazing that when I slag off Wilders track record of spending big I am quickly corrected by those that think McBurnie was a success because he had six good games for us in four years
Second highest ever premier league goal scorer for United, wouldn't say he was unsuccessful from that statement.

Im not saying he's good or rubbish either, very much on the fence with MCB. He had good link play, was decent in the air (defending lol), but was the slowest player I've ever witnessed and missed some stinkers, was stop start due to injuries /suspensions.

Was he the correct signing at the time? Probably not, similar to brewster situation wrong signing at wrong time.
 

Absolutely not a surprise
Underperformed here, 20 odd goals in 5 yrs?
Given 'hero' status by the kop, apparently for wearing a nice bucket hat, being one of the lads and regularly warming the treatment table
Another 'culture carrier' and Wilder gave him the captaincy
He mugged us off and too many lapped it up
 
Second tallest dwarf then.

13 goals. Took him 3 seasons and 80 games to do that.

He did some good things but that's a poor return for a PL striker over 3 seasons.
Not saying it was any good, just stated that it wouldn't say he was unsuccessful from that statement, playing devil's advocate.
 
I liked him when he was fully fit, but we very rarely got that and it was probably the right decision in retrospect for us to part ways. Had a run of games with Ndiaye and he finally looked like the striker we thought we were getting.

Not a bad footballer truth be told but his inability to stay fit and suspension free hampered his entire time here.

It's a shit article by the way, absolutely nothing of any substance within it. Save yourself a few clicks and don't bother 🤣
 
Early season they were hailing him as the new Messiah.
What worries me is some on here wanted him back on loan.

Is Ollie McB the quality of player we are going to be looking at whatever league we are in?

Would imagine Data Anylitics and AI would………

1747035038897.gif
 
What worries me is some on here wanted him back on loan.

Is Ollie McB the quality of player we are going to be looking at whatever league we are in?

Would imagine Data Anylitics and AI would………

View attachment 210516
The thought reuniting him and diaz partnership was very exciting and would have tore this division a new one
 
Second highest ever premier league goal scorer for United, wouldn't say he was unsuccessful from that statement.
This stat sounds good until you realise the other top premier league scorers for us got all their goals within 2 seasons and McBurnie had 3 seasons. His goals per prem season average is a meagre 4.33.
 
All this sounds very familiar……..
Same people slagging off a striker that cost over 10mil…..
 
On the rare occasion that he was fit and firing, he was pretty useful.

It just never happened often enough when for the best part of 2 years he offered nothing whatsoever. Not fit and didn't look like he was making any sort of effort which seemed to coincide with all the bother he was getting himself into off the field.

He always seemed to me to look very awkward, akin to a newborn foal, all gangly and uneasy on his feet.
 
All this sounds very familiar……..
Same people slagging off a striker that cost over 10mil…..
Massive difference between MCB and Cannon imo. MCB had some form of edge to his game, he had great link up play, could defend well, and looked like a decent enough striker towards the end. Cannon has nothing. I personally liked MCB. Thought he were decent enough, likeable lad, had a stinker to start with but looked more mature and seemed to pick up on his game towards the end. He did however look like he ran in treacle at times, and missed some absolute sitters.
 
On the rare occasion that he was fit and firing, he was pretty useful.

He always seemed to me to look very awkward, akin to a newborn foal, all gangly and uneasy on his feet.

That was much of the problem…..has a similar ugly running style to Steve Claridge…..both didn’t wear shin pads either.
Not his fault but McBurnie couldn’t run properly, he ran with a limp as though he was always injured/ knackered.
He also often had a grimace on his face as though he was in pain. To be fair Chris Waddle had a lazy running style and he wasn’t a bad player.

My view on McBurnie was he has to be fully focussed, psyched up for a battle…..then he was pretty good. We saw that even at PL level…..when he was in the mood PL defences used to struggle coping with him….think it was becuase he was awkward and different from other PL strikers. Also he was a winner/ a character you would probably want around the training pitch due to his positive/ battling/ winning mentality.

However on the flip side….we’ve also seen with our own eyes McBurnie be no better than average…even at Championship level.
Some slate Brewster regards his goal scoring but at least you can see some quality regards his general play and ability.
However regards McBurnie…..at times….he looks like a parks player…..struggles to trap a ball.

I was on holiday about 3 years ago and met a gang of lads who were all Celtic fans from Glasgow.
When I told them I was a Sheff Utd supporter they asked me what I thought of Oliver McBurnie. Told them he splits the fanbase because at times he’e really low quality however at times he can be a handful and in a few games at PL level he was really good/ effective.

They all laughed and said that up there in Scotland…..McBurnie is famous for being one of the worse players seen in a Scotland shirt.
They said they can’t believe he’s a professional footballer and assume he must have continuously had poor games when playing for Scotland…and can’t be that bad.
 
Last edited:

My view on McBurnie was he has to be fully focussed, psyched up for a battle…..then he was pretty good. We saw that even at PL level…..when he was in the mood PL defences used to struggle coping with him….think it was becuase he was awkward and different from other PL strikers. Also he was a winner/ a character you would probably want around the training pitch due to his positive/ battling/ winning mentality.
I read something this morning on linkedin from a sports psychologist who picked something out of Roy Keane's interview with Kevin Kilbane from years ago, where Keane talks about his mentality saying “It’s an act. Of course I had self-doubts, but I kept an act up. The skinhead. A few sendings off. I fear nothing. Some sort of machine. Which is nonsense. You act, don’t you!”

Almost like wrestling kayfabe, it was one he's almost had to keep up and gradually adapt over the years. The sports psychologist guy talked about "game faces" and what players wanted to embody when they went onto the field with there being an England rugby player embodying an ‘Aggressive Energetic Lion.’

Maybe McBurnie needed some kind of act he put on when he stepped over the white line to keep his performance at a level each game, not once in a blue moon?
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom