Would you......

[Stevo]

Swap Ndiaye for mcatee & Doyle

 

[Dark muffy]

no....based on Ndiaye is the best player i've ever seen, and the Manc lads arn't.

 

[Cappy]

Swap Ndiaye for mcatee & Doyle

Great question. And I really don’t know…

 

[ISZA ⚔️]

I wouldn’t swap Ndiaye for McAtee, Doyle and Haaland.

 

[Brownieblade]

Yes if we get both for 3 years or longer. Illy is gone next year most likely if not the summer so I’m guessing in this scenario he goes to city

 

[Nick Jansky]

I wouldn’t swap Ndiaye for McAtee, Doyle and Haaland.

I would.

 

[Edgar Allan Poo]

Throw in a fun size pack of maltesers and I'll have my people talk to your people when I have a window.

 

[Torrix1889]

In answer to your question, no.

Another question though is Pep says we can have either Doyle or McAtee on loan again next season, which one do you have? Ideally we would buy one and loan the other though!

 

[MightyBlades]

No!

Ndiaye will go far, but sadly United won't see the final product.

However, just enjoy the lad whilst you can and appreciate his exceptional talent.

Hopefully we can keep hold of him for another few seasons.

 

[Davalon]

....prefer to burn to death, or freeze to death?

 

[coolasanidiot]

No-

Ndiaye- Value 60 million- and worth it

Doyle- Value 15 million

McAtee- Value 15 Million

= Bad deal

They could have McBurnie for them though.

 

[bartman]

no....based on Ndiaye is the best player i've ever seen,

Not been watching The Blades long then ? He is very good at Championiship level with potential to improve further( which i am sure he will) but needs a long stint in a top league( either here or abroad)

 

[Swannyblade]

No - there's plenty of other Doyle's out there and a few McAtee's as well. There's only one NDiaye

 

[bramptonblade]

Swap Ndiaye for mcatee & Doyle

Yes

 

[SUFC Guy]

I'd swap:

Ndiaye for Scarlett Johansson
Fleck for KDB
Brewster for Haaland
Basham for Kyle Walker

oh and...
Fallowfield for Pep

 

[ForgeBlade]

From a purely practical standpoint...probably. Lose 1 player, but gain 2. If we got Doyle and McAtee permanently in a swap, then that's a big chunk of our midfield sorted at a stroke.

However, my heart says no. Iliman is the best I've ever seen for United. At times he is unplayable, and there is not a single defence in the prem that will think "yeah we can easily deal with him." If we can persuade him to give us another season, he could be the difference between survival and relegation.

 

[SUFC Guy]

At times he is unplayable, and there is not a single defence in the prem that will think "yeah we can easily deal with him." If we can persuade him to give us another season, he could be the difference between survival and relegation.

Absolutely.

Just got to hope that no club comes in with ludicrous offer that we can't turn down

 

[FMBlade1]

Ndiaye is closest player to Messi we'll ever get to see play for us.

 

[ForgeBlade]

Absolutely.

Just got to hope that no club comes in with ludicrous offer that we can't turn down

It would have to be really daft for me.
If I held the purse strings, I'd be saying to any suitors, "Unless you are here to make an offer that is 8 figures, and starts with at least a "5" then fuck off."

Sadly, we're probably not in the position to be that obstinate.

 

[Dark muffy]

Not been watching The Blades long then ? He is very good at Championiship level with potential to improve further( which i am sure he will) but needs a long stint in a top league( either here or abroad)

Since 1990 ish, so 33 years. In that time I've never seen anyone do what he does with the ball with his skill, pace and close control. He runs his blood to water, works his bollocks off, and takes no shit off anyone. I think he is much better than Championship level already. We are just lucky that is where he finds himself at this moment.

 

[Bell4]

Not been watching The Blades long then ? He is very good at Championiship level with potential to improve further( which i am sure he will) but needs a long stint in a top league( either here or abroad)

This

Very good prospect and gets you off your seat .

Work ethic is excellent as is his attitude

Seen people post that he is the best player they have seen in the red and white - which is their opinion and fair enough - but he is nowhere near the best imo , currently , but it depends what you’re judging .

Good player and all that but as the above post says - let’s see what he’s like in the top league over a consistent period