Deadly_D'Jaffo
Well-Known Member
Olsen - OK he's not had 10 games, but we've seen enough to say he's adequate. KEEP.
Foderingham - Not disgraced nor shone. Probably cheap cover. KEEP.
Verrips - no words needed. GET RID.
RND - Sorry, I'm not encouraged he's going to be anything above a squad player. Hope I'm wrong. That said, he's still got the benefit of time on his side. KEEP.
Enda - Again he's just coming back, but I can't see how his better days are ahead of him. Looked shot going forward tonight. GET RID.
Robinson - Dreadful. GET RID.
Osborn. Started poorly but shown enough since the international break to demonstrate he can be a handy player in this squad. KEEP.
Lowe - If 3 managers felt Robinson & Enda were ahead of him, only means one thing. GET RID.
Baldock - He's had better form at United and his crossing is dreadful but he's a good RWB overall. KEEP.
Bogle - Not had much chance to shine but we know his capability, I think if we decide to go 4-3-3 he'd be a decent shout for right side of attack. KEEP.
Basham - I might be blinded by Basham infatuation (inbashuation) but his leadership by example and bravery still has value. KEEP.
Egan - Excellent, championship CB. KEEP.
Davies - Think he is a classy CB but he is weak and casual. It worries me that we've put all our eggs in one basket with this signing. If we could cancel his loan and instead sign an experienced, athletic, ugly, physical CB then I would GET RID.
Norwood - I don't think he's as spent as people make out, but we do need to find the right foil for him and that raises the question, is he still good enough to build a side around? I'm 50/50 but for the squad I would KEEP.
Fleck - As much as I like Fleck, he's nowhere near the player or athlete that has been outstanding for us between 2016 to March 2020. I always expect he'll leave us for Rangers some day but until then I would KEEP.
Guedioura - Decent cameo vs. Hull and gives us a bit of bite & bravery that we lack in the middle. KEEP.
Hourihane - We haven't seen much and he's already got 2 assists. For the sake of quality within the squad I would KEEP.
Berge - He's going to be an excellent footballer somewhere, but definitely not at Sheff Utd and probably not in England. GET RID.
Freeman - A player I have always wanted to see at United so wanted him to do well, but I think it's fair to say after a bad injury last year and a new high-tempo style he simply isn't right for us anymore (If he ever really was). GET RID.
Ndiaye - An exciting footballer who I look forward to seeing play. KEEP.
Gibbs-White - As above with Ndiaye, any chance of success we have hinges on his creativity. KEEP.
Burke - Slav gave him a fair crack at a fresh start, but he still gets to the byline and loses the ball. GET RID.
Brewster - I don't think he's been offensively poor this season and shown some glimpses, but I get the impression we'll forever be stuck on someday aisle with him. GET RID.
McBurnie - Another player I've always wanted at United and thought he'd be a threat in the Championship. Unfortunately, he seem thick as whale spunk. GET RID.
Mousset - Doesn't have the dedication to be a professional footballer. GET RID.
McGoldrick - As with Bash, I think there's still a good enough reason to keep him around, could be good for Ndiaye & MGW. KEEP.
Sharp - We shouldn't need to depend on him as much as we currently do, but here we are. KEEP.
Foderingham - Not disgraced nor shone. Probably cheap cover. KEEP.
Verrips - no words needed. GET RID.
RND - Sorry, I'm not encouraged he's going to be anything above a squad player. Hope I'm wrong. That said, he's still got the benefit of time on his side. KEEP.
Enda - Again he's just coming back, but I can't see how his better days are ahead of him. Looked shot going forward tonight. GET RID.
Robinson - Dreadful. GET RID.
Osborn. Started poorly but shown enough since the international break to demonstrate he can be a handy player in this squad. KEEP.
Lowe - If 3 managers felt Robinson & Enda were ahead of him, only means one thing. GET RID.
Baldock - He's had better form at United and his crossing is dreadful but he's a good RWB overall. KEEP.
Bogle - Not had much chance to shine but we know his capability, I think if we decide to go 4-3-3 he'd be a decent shout for right side of attack. KEEP.
Basham - I might be blinded by Basham infatuation (inbashuation) but his leadership by example and bravery still has value. KEEP.
Egan - Excellent, championship CB. KEEP.
Davies - Think he is a classy CB but he is weak and casual. It worries me that we've put all our eggs in one basket with this signing. If we could cancel his loan and instead sign an experienced, athletic, ugly, physical CB then I would GET RID.
Norwood - I don't think he's as spent as people make out, but we do need to find the right foil for him and that raises the question, is he still good enough to build a side around? I'm 50/50 but for the squad I would KEEP.
Fleck - As much as I like Fleck, he's nowhere near the player or athlete that has been outstanding for us between 2016 to March 2020. I always expect he'll leave us for Rangers some day but until then I would KEEP.
Guedioura - Decent cameo vs. Hull and gives us a bit of bite & bravery that we lack in the middle. KEEP.
Hourihane - We haven't seen much and he's already got 2 assists. For the sake of quality within the squad I would KEEP.
Berge - He's going to be an excellent footballer somewhere, but definitely not at Sheff Utd and probably not in England. GET RID.
Freeman - A player I have always wanted to see at United so wanted him to do well, but I think it's fair to say after a bad injury last year and a new high-tempo style he simply isn't right for us anymore (If he ever really was). GET RID.
Ndiaye - An exciting footballer who I look forward to seeing play. KEEP.
Gibbs-White - As above with Ndiaye, any chance of success we have hinges on his creativity. KEEP.
Burke - Slav gave him a fair crack at a fresh start, but he still gets to the byline and loses the ball. GET RID.
Brewster - I don't think he's been offensively poor this season and shown some glimpses, but I get the impression we'll forever be stuck on someday aisle with him. GET RID.
McBurnie - Another player I've always wanted at United and thought he'd be a threat in the Championship. Unfortunately, he seem thick as whale spunk. GET RID.
Mousset - Doesn't have the dedication to be a professional footballer. GET RID.
McGoldrick - As with Bash, I think there's still a good enough reason to keep him around, could be good for Ndiaye & MGW. KEEP.
Sharp - We shouldn't need to depend on him as much as we currently do, but here we are. KEEP.