I know what you're saying, but obviously McCabe truely believed Robson was the right man to take us back in one season and took a gamble (and I'd agree that he was very naive in that view, not just in retrospect but even at the time of the appointment I thought he was the wrong man). Having said that, I'd say Robson's choice of players was first class, it's just a shame he's a shite manager with no man management skills, he can't/couldn't motivate his players and he has no tactical knowledge, apart from that he's possibly a great manager

(I agree with someone who posted earlier on another thread who said he'd have made a great director of football).
McCabe's biggest mistake in my humble opinion (and I know a lot of people will disagree) is letting Warnock go in the first place.