Make it happen

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?




He was worth more than we got for him, the transfer arbitration mob would have ordered Hull City to pay more than we got if even we'd let his contract run out.
Arbitration only takes place when two parties can’t agree a fee

Our valuation at the time was met. So he was worth what our owners valued him at and Hull met that.
 
He was worth more than we got for him, the transfer arbitration mob would have ordered Hull City to pay more than we got if even we'd let his contract run out.


1) Where were the other bids?

2)You know this how?
 



He was worth more than we got for him, the transfer arbitration mob would have ordered Hull City to pay more than we got if even we'd let his contract run out.
Arbitration figures are notoriously low.
 
So what is your exact point then? You got more for him on Championship Manager?


My point is agreeing with you that the arbitration sets the price if two clubs don't agree a fee.
But we didn't have to agree to anything, Maguire was under contract, Hull City should have been told he's not for sale.
Maguire's contract would have expired a year later, then we'd have got compensation because he was one of our academy players.

Any club on the planet would have got more for him let alone Championship Manager, we even went back to Hull with the begging bowl after they threatened to pull out of the deal and ended up with less.
Even the compensation would have been more than we got for him because it would have been set by people living and working in 21st century football
 
My point is agreeing with you that the arbitration sets the price if two clubs don't agree a fee.
But we didn't have to agree to anything, Maguire was under contract, Hull City should have been told he's not for sale.
Maguire's contract would have expired a year later, then we'd have got compensation because he was one of our academy players.

Any club on the planet would have got more for him let alone Championship Manager, we even went back to Hull with the begging bowl after they threatened to pull out of the deal and ended up with less.
Even the compensation would have been more than we got for him because it would have been set by people living and working in 21st century football
The point is that at that time we had a valuation on Harry and Hull met it... I’m not quite sure what you’re not getting about it.

Sure other clubs could set the fee higher, they may have also said no to all bids. But what good would that have done.

It’s clearly done Harry a lot of good as he’s now one of the best centre halves in the country
 
The point is that at that time we had a valuation on Harry and Hull met it... I’m not quite sure what you’re not getting about it.

Sure other clubs could set the fee higher, they may have also said no to all bids. But what good would that have done.

It’s clearly done Harry a lot of good as he’s now one of the best centre halves in the country
world.. you'e welcome ;)
 
My point is agreeing with you that the arbitration sets the price if two clubs don't agree a fee.
But we didn't have to agree to anything, Maguire was under contract, Hull City should have been told he's not for sale.
Maguire's contract would have expired a year later, then we'd have got compensation because he was one of our academy players.

Apart from having an unhappy player potentially refusing to play, you are correct.

Even the compensation would have been more than we got for him because it would have been set by people living and working in 21st century football

You are a million miles away!

By moving to the Premier League, compenation is covered by the Elite Player Performance Plan. This was set up in 2011 to allow the big boys to steal any players from the lower leagues, for a pittance.

If he joined us at 12 and played to 16 we would get £12.5k per year for these years (we were a catergory II academy) - a total of £50k.

For his 134 league appearances we would get the princely sum of £1m (max no of games is 100 and as a L1club its is £10k per game).

So total compensation of £1,050,000 rather than the £2.5m + sell off that we negotiated.

As usual it is the agenda driven slag the club first rather than bother to check the facts.

www.thefa.com/~/media/C2FB1444624F4367AA477A72D94B50BF.ashx
(pages 98 & 99 for the approproiate tables of compensation)
 
  • Like
Reactions: AJS
The point is that at that time we had a valuation on Harry and Hull met it... I’m not quite sure what you’re not getting about it.

Sure other clubs could set the fee higher, they may have also said no to all bids. But what good would that have done.

It’s clearly done Harry a lot of good as he’s now one of the best centre halves in the country
Are people so fucking dumb they don’t understand what the ‘sunstroke’ shit was about? And so fucking tedious they still go on about shit that happened years ago?
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom