Was Quinny offside?

[Micalijo]

Anyone in line with it? I'm at other end, no chance of telling.

I bet he was very, very close to being OK.

 

[yorkshirecoast]

Looked very close to me. I really hope he was offside. It's bad enough having to witness our piss poor defence - I couldn't cope if we were robbed by a poor decision as well.

 

[Student Blade]

i was also directly in line. it was a bit quick for me to see for sure but my gut reaction was that he was level, so onside!!

UTB

 

[Micalijo]

I get a horrible feeling we were robbed. He ran from a long way back and was miles quicker to react than any defenders.

I know it's only a point but unbeaten home record still worth having

 

[puppet]

Looked very close to me. I really hope he was offside. It's bad enough having to witness our piss poor defence - I couldn't cope if we were robbed by a poor decision as well.

the penalty seems to have taken care of us being robbed by a poor decision i think!

 

[Stafford Blade]

i thought he was off. plus the goal they had disallowed didn't look offside

 

[yorkshirecoast]

Bang in line with their offside goal & it looked well off

 

[Bakewell Blade]

I was stood at that corner on the kop and I thought he was off

 

[Student Blade]

i was bang in line with their offside goal, and it was deffo offside, no doubt it wasnt offside!!

UTB

 

[TonyAgana]

the penalty seems to have taken care of us being robbed by a poor decision i think!

Did you miss it? I don't understand how you think it wasn't a pen!

 

[Linz]

Did you miss it? I don't understand how you think it wasn't a pen!

I concur.

Henderson ought to have his arms amputated. He gets fouled as often as he fouls, but he should know that referees only see them one way so why bother grabbing at people in the first place?

As for Quinny, a bit quick for me to see. But the flag went up straight away so the linesman was sure.

 

[Wards]

can't believe the Beeb highlights didn't show it!!

 

[raul]

Was bang in line with it, didn't look offside when the shot came in, but 50/50 as to his positioning when the ball bounced back off their keeper. Would need to see it again, but the fact I didn't howl at the moon suggests instinctively I felt he was off.

 

[DazBlade88]

I thought he was offside, I looked at the linesman straight away and saw he had his flag up so I didn't bother celebrating.

Oh, and the pen was a cert.

 

[Guesty]

I'm exactly the same as you Daz, looked straight over to the linesman, didn't let out a cheer.

I can't say I saw the penalty very clearful but I'm not sure Boothroyd was offside, did any of our defenders appeal?

 

[judge]

never a pen hendo doesnt even touch him

 

[DazBlade88]

I'm exactly the same as you Daz, looked straight over to the linesman, didn't let out a cheer.

I can't say I saw the penalty very clearful but I'm not sure Boothroyd was offside, did any of our defenders appeal?

I was a bit surprised when their goal was disallowed actually. I don't think Boothroyd was offside, it was somebody else. Thought we got a bit lucky on that one, not that I was complaining

I don't think our defenders appealed for it, it was more of a look at the linesman in hope kind of thing I think.

 

[Micalijo]

Was bang in line with it, didn't look offside when the shot came in, but 50/50 as to his positioning when the ball bounced back off their keeper. Would need to see it again, but the fact I didn't howl at the moon suggests instinctively I felt he was off.

I aint sure of the rule but I think if he's onside when the ball is struck by Walker it doesn't matter where finishes it from.

 

[Guesty]

Exactly right Micalijo, the only thing that matters is where he was when Walker hit it.

 

[mattbianco1]

can't believe the Beeb highlights didn't show it!!

That's because that programme is quite possibly the worse programme ever to have made it onto television!

 

[Guesty]

That's because that programme is quite possibly the worse programme ever to have made it onto television!

You seem to hav forgotten ITV's The Championship with alarming haste!

 

[shorehamview]

You seem to hav forgotten ITV's The Championship with alarming haste!

And Noel's House Party. Mind you, any show that thinks a highlight will be Andy Townsend's Tactics Truck deserves all the shit it got.

 

[Lincoln Blade]

I was astounded when they didnt show the quinny non-goal... surely it would of been worth the extra 10 seconds it would of taken!!! Instead there was a an interview with the lead singer of The enemy - just because he went to a coventry game???

 

[DazBlade88]

There's normally more highlights on the BBC iPlayer in the week isn't there?

 

[JohnDenver]

Anyone in line with it? I'm at other end, no chance of telling.

I bet he was very, very close to being OK.

At the time I couldn't figure how a midfielder would get behind their defence before anyone else did - surely he'd be arriving from deep anticipating the rebound?

But given the complete lack of fuss I can only think he was a mile off.

 

[Come from away]

It's on the main site. Quinn offside when shot taken picks up rebound. Bothroyd offside when Morg hits Walkers bum. Both score but only one counts. Sucks really.

 

[Fiery Blade]

Not really It's called the Laws of Football

 

[GRUMPY BLADE]

CAN'T BE OFFSIDE IF THE BALL IS PLAYED BY THE OPPOSTION.

f**K me

 

[GRUMPY BLADE]

Can't believe you watch footie on the Beeb