United 3 Birmingham 0 - report/ratings

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Deadbat

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2009
Messages
6,468
Reaction score
37,757
The Blades got back to winning ways as they comfortably despatched a poor Birmingham City side at the Lane on the weekend before Xmas. An early Tyler Bindon goal gave the home side a perfect start and then ex Blade Tommy Doyle committed a horror tackle on Gus Hamer seeing him dismissed with less than 20 minutes played. Hamer then seized on Anderson’s back pass to fire home a second and after Patrick Bamford touched in Oli Arblaster’s driven shot, the three points were in the bag. After the set back of the defeat at the Hawthorns, this was a much-improved performance from Wilder’s man who won at a canter in the end.



There were several changes to the starting line up with Bindon, McCallum, Arblaster, Chong and O’Hare back in the starting lineup. Birmingham started both former Blades players, Doyle and Jack Robinson, in their first eleven.



Neumann was cautioned for a cynical pull back on Bamford, after only 2 minutes, as United started looking to find gaps in the Brum backline. Gray had an effort over the top for the visitors in an end-to-end start but United won an early corner which led to the opening goal after just 5 minutes. Hamer took it and the outswinger was inviting for BINDON, who came onto the ball and powerfully headed past Allsop and gave the Blades a perfect start. United gave away two silly free kicks from Hamer and McCallum and Cooper fumbled one delivery but the visitors could not fashion a clear chance.



Klarer then was booked for a late foul on O’Hare, leaving both centre backs in the referee’s book. United were looking to find gaps and were penning the visitors back. From a McCallum long throw, the ball was allowed to bounce and O’Hare met it to nod goalwards but Allsop made the save. On 18 minutes, the game threatened to boil over. The ball was loose on half way near the dug outs but Hamer got there first and Doyle completely took him out with an awfully late and high challenge. As the crowd shouted, ‘Off! Off! Off!’, referee Hooper duly obliged sending him down the tunnel. There were few complaints from the visiting bench or players as the midfielder trooped off, knowing that he had left his side with an uphill battle , trailing and now down to ten men.



Anderson then hauled down Chong before soon after his loose backpass saw HAMER steal in and round Allsop before firing the ball home – from a tight angle. It was an opportunistic piece of play by the Blades talisman and United were now in complete control. Anderson was taken off and replaced by Leonard, as the City coaching staff looked for even a foothold in a game they were completely best.



Tanganga made an excellent last-ditch tackle to deny Gray after a lovely thought ball from Stansfield put him in the clear. This was a reminder for the Blades defence to be on their guard, despite United largely completely dominating the contest.



United started the second goal, as they did the first, with a goal. The build up was patient as United move it across the pitch exploiting their man advantage. Chong set up the effort for Arblaster who fired it through bodies and BAMFORD got a touch to divert it home. There appeared more than a hint of offside but the flag stated down and despite the referee appearing to overrule his assistant at first, checked with his colleague and gave the goal. Replays suggested it was tighter than it appeared. Hamer then took a pop shot that was touched round the post and United were now in total control. Seriki and Chong linked well and Bamford nearly got on the end of another cross. Cannon and Ings came on for Hamer and Bamford before the hour mark before Koumas, Dykes and Cashin replaced Wilumsson, Gray and Robinson for the visitors. The latter got a mixed reception but more cheers than boos, although with United in complete control, this helped with the largely positive reaction. Bindon was having an excellent game and won the ball twice before also coming out with it and helping lead the charge.



Ings had a chance but was unable to divert it goalwards as O’Hare continued to be a pest for the Birmingham backline before Seriki and Chong combined well again leading to the cross being blocked. After more good work down the right, O’Hare nodded back and it dropped for Cannon but he fired badly wide when he should have probably converted. Soumare and Burrows entered the fray for Arblaster and McCallum as the game ticked into the final 20 minutes. Birmingham were offering little in response.



It resembled a practice match for the final period of the game and became quite scrappy. Dykes blazed badly off target before Ings tried a spectacular overhead kick but the contest was over and many visiting fans had headed for the exits long before the referee put up three minutes on the board – that seemed academic at this stage. A late Tanganga booking, after he slipped, was the only real negative, as United saw out time and in the final moments nearly created another chance as they broke at pace on the break. In the end, it was an easy win with the up tempo start in both halves key but United had been the better side even before Doyle’s indiscretion. After the set back of West Brom, the Blades looked at it from the off and individually and collectively, they were too strong for the Blues.



United – Wilder clearly was fuming after the absolute non show after the break at the Hawthorns. He was as mad as he has been for a long time and demanded a reaction – he got one as United were bang at it from the off winning loose balls, controlling possession and looking dangerous throughout. The early goal helped- another set play – it is mad how many more corners we have had then any other side (162 – Stoke next with 122 and league leaders Coventry are only on 119 – 43 less than us!) but finally look dangerous with the out-swinging crosses and variety of deliveries. We saw it v Stoke with McGuinness a constant threat and then today with a great towering header from Bindon – who was impressive throughout.



After this, they won a few free kicks but we continued to look dangerous with Bamford using his experience, O’Hare buzzing round and Hamer showing his quality with his clever passing and vision. We could have had more chances but then after they had shown a real cynical and overly physical side to their game (three yellows – including both centre backs and one after just over a minute!) they effectively threw away any chance of coming back. The tackle from Doyle was awful and seemed an easy red – I was right in front of it as it happened. Seemed out of character as he was competitive at the Lane but never dirty from what I remember? I was just pleased Hamer was ok.



After this we completely controlled a game – we had already been the better side. They made several mistakes with loose passes or where we nipped in and the goal came from such a moment. Anderson never saw Hamer and the midfielder was quick to react, read the mistake and then took it clinically. We could have had more with us getting behind them time after time. Seriki and Chong linked well and Riedewald and Arblaster were dominating the ball in the middle. They banked up and just tried to get to half time without more damage and we were content just to move the ball around and tire them out further. O’Hare had appeals for a penalty as he went down after working space in the box but nothing was given.



After the break we get a third (did look offside but replays were inconclusive) as Bamford scored again and that was it really. There were lots of changes but there was only us that looked like scoring more goals and a number of crosses or finals balls just evaded men in the box. The visitors were well beaten and it became a case of defence v attack. The subs made it scrappy and it was a bit of a nothing game for the final stages as both teams played out a game that had been decided effectively straight after the half – maybe even as early as the Doyle red card in reality.



A good win – the opposite of the West Brom game – as today we looked quick, hungry, and aggressive. We got about them, pressed their defence and stole the ball a number of times leading to opportunities. Our hard work and doing the basics, allowed us then to move it around confidently and they just sat back knowing we had an extra man and ultimately more quality. I think if United had not made so many changes and/or took their foot off the pedal – they could have gone and scored even more goals. In the end, conserving energy and rotating players was the most important thing. All the starters did their job and no one played badly – we had all the stand outs in the game and it was as comprehensive a win as you could wish to see.



Birmingham have struggled on the road but United still had to come out and apply a really good performance and they did that. We tweaked the line up and went with two off Bamford, rather than two up top, but it worked. Hamer and O’Hare played really well and Chong and Seriki were always in motion meaning they struggled to hold us down this side. An excellent three points but another game where you wonder how are lower than our opponents in the table! Hopefully we can get Peck back soon and then might make a few additions (Rothwell strongly linked) but we do have a trio of tricky games – with Wrexham (good at home and Moore will be a threat), Stoke and Leicester (who will both want to avenge poor defeats to us) so need to ensure we keep moving away from the bottom and stay at least in touch with the top half – we are still a fair way off the playoffs and talk of this is premature – we are not even half way yet. However, we are playing so much better, with the game being action packed and us finally scoring goals!
 



Ratings:



Cooper 5/10 – Not much to do really. He kind of dropped a cross early on in a scramble and a few other corners, was not totally convincing. Only had basic handling to do and nothing on target at all. Concerning they did keep putting corners right under his own bar and he did not convince on these but no real saves to make all game.



Seriki 7.5/10 - After a drop off v WBA, he was back to the player we had seen in the run of wins before this. So much energy all game as he got up and down, ran at them and always looked to find space and be direct. A few decent crosses that just evaded men in the box but a few where he maybe could have been a bit more precise. Defended well v a tough opponent in Gray – who eventually got taken off. He always wants the ball and never hides from trying to go at his man and make them turn around and have to face their own goal.



McCallum 7/10 – Another steady game where he proved why he is starting over Burrows. Won headers, interceptions and moved up and down the left-hand side. Few decent balls but also he fluffed a few, when played in really well by Hamer. He is winning the ball more and then when he is having it, is using it sensibly.



Bindon 8/10 – Was superb today. His goal set the tone, but after this he did not lose a challenge and looked so composed on the ball. He seemed physically more aggressive than I have seen before and got stronger as the game went on. Used the ball so sensibly and came out and played a lot of forward passes. Did the basics really well but looked a composed footballer today.



Tanganga 6/10 – Made one superb tackle as they looked to get in but a few other moments took too long and was looking for fouls that were not free kicks. Won a few headed balls and also got his foot in but a few moments where he took too long and dithered – as what happened with the late booking.



Riedewald 6.5/10 – Another quietly effective performance. He does not move around much, rarely gets into the away team’s box but he always seems to be in the right place at the right time. Used the ball without being flashy but just keeps it moving. Glad we have him tied down till the end of the season. We draw a drop off when him and Arblaster went off.



Arblaster 6.5/10 – Nothing remarkable but his ball retention and ability to keep the ball moving and come out of tight spots – with the turn he does – is a real asset. He will get stronger as the games go on but today was fine and did what he had to do.



O’Hare 7.5/10 – Energetic performance, where he led the press, snapped at them all game and helped us be a threat all game. He never stops and must be awful to play on. A few final moments did not quite come off but overall, he was excellent and continued right to the end.



Hamer 7.5/10 – He began by giving it away cheaply and conceding a free kick but the corner was very good and after he got kicked, this seemed to inspire him! He got on the ball, played some lovely balls that should have led to us creating even more but the final bits after his creative work, did not quite match it. He can be a bit frustrating but then finds big moments of quality or class. He ran things for long spells in the first half and then takes the goal – reading the error – clinically. After the break less involved and then rested with games to come over the Xmas period.



Chong 7.5/10 – He played well again and slowly is growing into a useful addition.



Bamford 6.5/10 – Mature performance where he held it up, won free kicks, and brought others into play. His actual final bits were poor as he had a few chances, where he could not quite keep it under control or find the surer touch but was in some really good areas. He got another goal – with an opportunistic finish and hopefully we can extend things till the end of the season. He is more suited than the others to play the role as just the one striker.



Subs -



Cannon 6/10 – He worked hard and was chasing and harrying. Showed a bit of strength at times too. Did miss a really good chance when well-placed but overall has been much better in the last month.



Ings 5/10 – Thought in contrast to Cannon, looked slow and off the pace. Had a few chances when the ball came in and could not quite react. He tried a few hard pieces of skill (overhead kick or on the stretch) near the end.



Soumare 4/10 – Big drop off in the middle after he came on but the game was done by this stage. Sloppy with the ball and positionally he sort of chases/roams rather than helping us keep a shape. Not sure he will play much if we get reinforcements in this area. Looks clumsy and lacking composure.



Burrows 5/10 – A few runs down the side but he took too long or his crosses were overhit.



Brooks – Not on for long but played central midfield (which we forget he did for us in the Premier League) as we saw things out.





Manager: Wilder 8/10 – A big win in a game we totally dominated. Had the players ready and the team responded superbly to the criticism. We pressed them, not gave them a moment, and looked a threat throughout. Not sure we created tons but more down to the final chances not being quite put in the right area but we had so much of the ball and dominated possession and territory. We scored three goals, kept a clean sheet, and managed to rotate some key men out for the final stages of the game. It was a perfect afternoon and response to the defeat and got us back on track. It was all about the intensity and determination to force the visitors into mistakes and we did that all game.



Birmingham – They were wretched from start to finish. Not only were they well beaten but they were also dirty and over physical leading to lots of tackles, yellows, and a wild and stupid red card. They have done well at home and struggled on the road and you could see why after seeing them today. Never got a foothold and made mistakes aplenty at the back. Awful marking on the first and then an error on the second but they had give it away a few times even outside of these moments. The red card is totally moronic. Hamer was not particularly going anywhere but made the referee’s decision an easy one. After this they never looked likely to ever remain in the game. We could and should have had more as they had no answer to wave after wave of attacks with our pace and running too much for a beleagued Brum side. In the end, they probably just wanted the full-time whistle.



They made some good signings over the summer and did have a few out but still a lot of players that cost a hell of a lot of money. This shows that even to compete at this level, you must upgrade as you move up. They have owners who will want things to happen almost yesterday. That is why I would worry about Chris Davies – who did an excellent job in League One – as the Americans will not hang around you would think – he may become a victim of his own success. This year, they will probably win a few, lose a few and I expect to stay around the middle by the end of the season. They will maybe spend again next summer and try and push on again.



Opponent Man of the Match – I thought that Stansfield looked lively – even if he had to play more down the side due to the red card. He played a cracking ball for a chance when Tanganga made the tackle and a few other decent runs but they had few bright spots.



Opponent Weak link – Robinson was poor and showed some of the weaknesses we remembered but the two centre backs even worse – clumsy, slow and putting themselves under pressure by both getting booked. However, Doyle had to take this award. He had a wild air shot early on but then the red card was extremely dangerous and made it so hard for his side with 70 minutes to play.



Referee / Officials – Thought the ref got the bookings/red card right – Birmingham were the most physical (dirty) sides to come to the Lane for a while and I was concerned we may get a bad injury or he may look to even things up but we kept out discipline. The rest of the game, he was decent with some good advantages and not always giving the obvious free kicks (both ways). He was not helped by an awful assistant on the South Stand side who never gave a decision all game – although a freeze frame of the Bamford goals suggests he could have actually been level and onside?!



Crowd/Day Out – Strange atmosphere, as a lot in – 28K+ but was quiet as the game was sort of done early and their fan then sort of lose interest. Made their feelings known of the performance, both on half and full time. Also gave Robinson a worse reaction than we did, when we went off!
 
thought Riedewald was worth at least a 7.5 did the dirty work so well throughout the game, even used his right foot effectively at times which was a bit of a surprise (loves the left footed poke though)
 
Spot on Deadbat

The only thing I’d have marked us down for is the lack of ability to break down their low block once they realised they we were likely to score every time we went forward. We are such a good side when we play a counter attacking style and much poorer when we don’t.
 
Nice one Deadbat. This prevalent corner tactic of flooding the goal mouth and putting the ball under the bar doesn’t suit cooper as he is not as tall or strong as many other goalies. Something he needs to work on as it’s usually a heart in mouth moment. We should move Mcguiness on - MOM Bindon looks real quality.
 
I’ll give them a pass after illness regarding Norwich and WBA,that was awful. Much better football and more refined and more movement,players look like they are in the right places. soumare needs too many touches and his first one isn’t a good one. Chong did well yesterday and held his position really well with a good engine to boot. Playing higher up the pitch suits us,as last week we were too deep and couldn’t get out with shite passing. Overall,players look happier ,It’s important we take these performances away as well,we do have better players than most teams but consistency is the key.
 
Referee / Officials – Thought the ref got the bookings/red card right – Birmingham were the most physical (dirty) sides to come to the Lane for a while and I was concerned we may get a bad injury or he may look to even things up but we kept out discipline. The rest of the game, he was decent with some good advantages and not always giving the obvious free kicks (both ways). He was not helped by an awful assistant on the South Stand side who never gave a decision all game – although a freeze frame of the Bamford goals suggests he could have actually been level and onside?!
Birmingham could have legitimately found themselves on 8 men after 25 mins. The Klarer incident looked very much from where I was sat like O'Hare was the last man when he was fouled. Keshi Anderson could legitimately have been sent off either for two consecutive yellow card challenges, or for violent conduct for grabbing Chong round the neck to wrestle him to the floor where he only got a yellow.

The Bamford goal made me laugh - the ref clearly assumed it was offside and looked to the assistant ref, and seemed really reluctant to give it. I think under VAR that's chalked off though.
 
I thought Redewald was our best player, with COH just behind.

The reason Jiro doesn;t move a long way, is beacause he doesn't need to; he reads the game sp well. His reading of the game, was up there with Coutts and Jake Wright.

All abaht opinions, innit,
 
Good write up again DB and excellent use of the word “aplenty”.

You could benefit from a proof reader though.
But only because I’m a pedant 😝
I'd had about 7 pints and been hosting the annual big Blades quiz after the game with Roygbiv Beans Eggy Webding etc...so was not fully with it!

Might pop the quiz on here next few days!
 



Thought McCallum was perhaps worth an extra 0.5 - looks so much better than Burrows at the moment. Rarely gets beat, athletic and a much better footballer than he's given credit for.

I think I was a bit harsh on McCallum and Jairo. Now I've sobered up, I'd give them 0.5 more probably
 
Birmingham could have legitimately found themselves on 8 men after 25 mins. The Klarer incident looked very much from where I was sat like O'Hare was the last man when he was fouled. Keshi Anderson could legitimately have been sent off either for two consecutive yellow card challenges, or for violent conduct for grabbing Chong round the neck to wrestle him to the floor where he only got a yellow.

Anderson had an interesting five minutes:-

25’ - booked for the pull back on Chong
28’ - back pass for Hamer’s goal
30’ - subbed

After he was booked for the foul on Chong, Trig Jnr (TY) said the ref should have booked the player for the body check on O’Hare just before where the ref waved play on as we had a breakaway. Watching the replay just now, that was Anderson as well, which makes me wonder whether he could have given Anderson two yellows, they were both worthy shouts.

I thought Redewald was our best player, with COH just behind.

The reason Jiro doesn;t move a long way, is beacause he doesn't need to; he reads the game sp well. His reading of the game, was up there with Coutts and Jake Wright.

All abaht opinions, innit,
I don’t think Riedewald needs a shower after the game. As you say, he doesn’t move very far or fast and most of his passes are short. He’s been a great signing, calm and with a fantastic football brain. I hope scores at some point, he’s been a bit unlucky in that area.
 
thought Riedewald was worth at least a 7.5 did the dirty work so well throughout the game, even used his right foot effectively at times which was a bit of a surprise (loves the left footed poke though)
Agree that Bindon merited player of match but I thought only by a whisker from Riedewald who was again superb. Maybe going to challenge Didsy as being the best free signing ever but a way to go yet.
 
Great performance, absolutely dire atmosphere, contrast with Elland Road where its wall to wall noise, we should be buzzing that we have players like Sereki, Arblaster, Hamer and O Hare and show support, it is akin to being sat in a library. Thats before the mass exodus on 85.
 
Thanks for the report Deadbat . Pretty much spot on despite the alcohol consumption 🤣

Our best players for me were; Bindon, McCallum and Riedewald. Bindon looks a different player to the one at the start of the season and he's really comfortable on the ball. Did anyone spot that drag back and turn he did in the first half, when he found himself on the wing on the edge of their box?
McCallum is a really good athlete with an incredible leap and as you said, he's using the ball so much better. Burrows is going to find it difficult to displace him, unless he gets injured.
Riedewald is class, he's almost Paul McGrath esque as he always seems to be in the right place to get his foot in, intercept and does the simple things really well. As Wilder said in his post match interview, it's not luck and he's a players player.
 
Anderson had an interesting five minutes:-

25’ - booked for the pull back on Chong
28’ - back pass for Hamer’s goal
30’ - subbed

After he was booked for the foul on Chong, Trig Jnr (TY) said the ref should have booked the player for the body check on O’Hare just before where the ref waved play on as we had a breakaway. Watching the replay just now, that was Anderson as well, which makes me wonder whether he could have given Anderson two yellows, they were both worthy shouts.
Yes, that was the one. Flattened O'Hare (who was getting fouled all over without any protection) who managed to pass out to Chong, then chased the latter down and pulled him down by the neck, with no attempt to play the ball. For me that's got to fall within the definition of violent conduct:

VIOLENT CONDUCT

Violent conduct is when a player uses or attempts to use excessive force or brutality against an opponent when not challenging for the ball, or against a team-mate, team official, match official, spectator or any other person, regardless of whether contact is made.

In addition, a player who, when not challenging for the ball, deliberately strikes an opponent or any other person on the head or face with the hand or arm, is guilty of violent conduct unless the force used was negligible.
 
The tackle from Doyle was awful and seemed an easy red – I was right in front of it as it happened.

Didn’t Soumare take Doyle out at their place in the cup game? Wonder if that was on his mind..🤔
 
Tanganga made an excellent last-ditch tackle to deny Gray after a lovely thought ball from Stansfield put him in the clear. This was a reminder for the Blades defence to be on their guard, despite United largely completely dominating the contest.
This one happened when it was still 1-0 rather than after Hamer’s goal – it was a great challenge, and could have changed Birmingham’s approach (and lifted their players) had there been an equaliser. Think his less good moments happened when the game was well and truly over. But a good performance from him and looked to be much happier switched back to the right side of the 2.

Thought the players went to great efforts to tidy up after teammates when there were stray passes yesterday, as happened with those moments with Tanganga but also with Arblaster a bit first half – a good sign re: the team’s mentality.
 
Riedewald was my MOTM . I was paying attention to him though. He was running the show in midfield. Braking up play and setting up our play also with nice simple passing . He did actually put through a couple of good through balls also ! 6.5 ! 7.5 easy !
 
Take note, kids, just because it's Christmas, Mr Deadbat aint gonna go soft and giving you good grades as a Christmas pressie. Indeed, he might Grinch the f... out of it and give you an 8 for a 'superb' performance ;)

Merry Xmas Deadbat , thanks for your reports this year!
 



All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom