Its the inconsistency in their comments which gets me or the fantasy land comments. Yes, i agree, if all those things that they talk about come together, then they're a top side, but the truth is that none of those things happened, they sacked their manager, brought in a new one (and he struggled initially) and they finished closer to relegation than promotion (just).
Next season, its all about what they can do to change that. Yes the likes of Forestieri, Bannan and others being fit will help. Those players being in form will be a boost too. But looking at patterns over the last couple of years, there is a lower probability of those things happening.
So then there is FFP, they're stuck with Rhodes, from what i've picked up they don't have much room to manoeuvre, so bringing in new signings will be tough unless they shift some of the players out. And this to me will be the players like Forestieri, Bannan, Reach.... because they have a value.
End of season predictions from me (with exactly what us and them have now) i have put them at 15th next season. I'd put us at 8th with Wilder, 17th or below without Wilder.