You have set me going asking a question like that

First, I don’t think the problems started with the goalkeepers last season, and by the time Grbic arrived, the defence had lost it, and he was the unfortunate icing on the cake. And the poor guy never showed us what his strengths as a keeper were. As a lifelong member of the goalkeepers union, I prefer to leave it at that.
The question of Hodgy v Cooper is a much more pleasant debate, as their presence in the goal has been enough in itself to justify watching United from behind that goal. I am very much prejudiced in favour of Hodgy, as he was my childhood hero, had a brilliant connection with the kids behind the goal (whichever team they supported), and was one of the reasons I have spent so much of my life watching and playing football. Cooper has already become the keeper I have most enjoyed watching since Hodgy retired, but it is very early days yet. He is very different (and of course the game is very different); he is calm, yet an organiser, but is not yet a big personality. Ever since keepers have had to use their feet more, I have been a nervous wreck behind the goal, but I am now calm when he has the ball at his feet. I relax when we do short goal kicks, or when he has to kick the ball with his left foot. Even if occasionally he is not accurate, he has not yet (touch wood) created a disastrous situation. Like Hodgy he is below average height for a keeper of his era, but unlike Hodgy who relied on agility and bravery, Cooper uses judgment, anticipation and positional sense to minimise the number of spectacular saves he has to make. Like Hodgy, he might not get the recognition he deserves because of his height. I am really looking forward to seeing how his career develops.