Permanent managers since June 2005

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

ThatJa

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2005
Messages
5,937
Reaction score
9,200
Location
Gleadless
Weve had the 2nd highest number of managers in the last 10 years.

Beaten only by Leeds.

WHEN it comes to football, you learn not to be surprised by most things these days, somewhat sadly.

Especially when it comes to the rapid changing of the guard in dug-outs across the land, with the latest managerial/head coach departure arriving on Thursday evening when Stuart Gray was brutally sacked by Sheffield Wednesday.

3103732506.jpg

Such changes turned into a morale-sapping procession in 2014-15.

Forty-seven dismissals arrived last season and a 48th came to pass when Gray was dispensed with for the perceived crime of finishing 13th in the Championship – and seemingly not having enough style points and being a marketing dream either.

The timing of Gray’s exit was a shock, but not a surprise in the greater scheme of things in a world where the management industry has never been as precarious and cut-throat.

Only last month, the League Managers Association revealed that the number of sackings in the top four divisions had reached its highest levels in 13 years, while the average tenure of axed managers during 2014-15 stood at 1.23 years, the shortest since 1992.

3325459009.jpg

Stuart Gray is the latest head coach to lose his job.
It will not be any consolation to Gray that his 18-month stint with the Owls exceeded that figure.

Security of tenure in the dug-out is a misnomer these days, with the transient nature of the management game seen starkly in Yorkshire last season – and before that.

Six Broad Acres clubs have now changed managerial ‘horses’ since August 2014, with Leeds United owner Massimo Cellino showing the door to three separate head coaches in that time-span.

David Hockaday lasted 70 days at the start of the season, but it was an eternity compared to his full-time successor Darko Milanic, axed after just 32 days in charge in the autumn.

3617847483.jpg

Nigel Clough lost his job as Sheffield United manager last month.
The overall picture over the past decade in the county is not a particularly edifying one, albeit with some exceptions with Phil Parkinson, Steve Evans and Steve Bruce among just 11 serving managers who have been in their jobs for three years or longer.

In the past decade, no Yorkshire club has had fewer than five permanent managers/head coaches, with no club boasting an average tenure of over two years.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, Leeds – with ten bosses since June 2005 – lead the way thanks in no small part to the arrival on the scene of Cellino, complete with his Italian moniker of ‘mangiallenatori’ (manager-eater) from his time at Cagliari where he hired 36 managers in 22 years at Cagliari.

Sheffield United are not far behind with nine managers in the same time-frame, with it all being a world away from the late eighties and first half of the nineties when Dave Bassett and Howard Wilkinson, up the M1 at Leeds, were as safe-as-houses.

Bassett took charge of the Blades for almost nine years from January 1988 to December 1995.

Compare that with now, with Nigel Adkins recently named as the club’s eighth manager in the past eight years, as the Blades’ continue to attempt to escape from the straitjacket of League One football.

But in truth, when it comes to sticking or twisting in terms of replacing or keeping a manager in tough times, the default position of most clubs – not just in Yorkshire – is to get rid.

Even when it comes to dispensing with figures who have sampled glory in the not too distant past; think Simon Grayson at Leeds, Gary Mills at York City.

Patience is certainly thinner on the ground these days in boardrooms and in the stands. At every Yorkshire club in this past 10 years, one manager, for one reason or another has lasted just a year or less.

The names of David Flitcroft, Peter Jackson, Brian Flynn, Phil Parkinson, Stan Ternent, Hockaday and Milanic, Gordon Strachan, Andy Scott, David Weir, Alan Irvine and Colin Walker will not fill too many pages in the respective teams’ annals.

While Leeds and the Blades have seen a veritable plethora of different faces in the dug-out, the situation at Rotherham, Doncaster, Middlesbrough and Bradford has at least been a little less chaotic. The Millers have been on an upward curve for a fair few seasons, with just two managers sacked in the past decade; Andy Scott and Millers legend Ronnie Moore both paying the price for failing to clear a path to promotion from the bottom division.

Doncaster have also enjoyed a fair few champagne moments since 2005 and while they, like the Millers, have had reason to keep the sackings to a minimum, it did not stop Sean O’Driscoll – arguably the most successful and influential manager in Rovers’ history – being replaced in September 2011.

Over at Middlesbrough, chairman Steve Gibson is someone who has garnered that rare reputation for backing and supporting his man in the old-school traditions – with just two managers sacked in among five departures since the summer of 2005.

Although, try telling that to Gareth Southgate when he was told his services were no longer required after Boro’s 2-0 win over Derby on October 21, 2009, which put them fourth in the embryonic Championship table. He was sacked a few hours later.

Learn to expect the unexpected sometimes.

http://www.yorkshirepost.co.uk/spor...set-the-pace-in-the-race-for-change-1-7307490
 

Attachments

  • 3103732506.jpg
    3103732506.jpg
    71.5 KB · Views: 22



Its just a part of modern football, its more competitive then ever with the ridiculous amount of money involved, everyone wants a piece of the cake.
The main problem with our club as been the recruitment side, we have brought in a lot of average or plain awful managers in the last 10 years, all who have got a good whack of cash for doing a poor job.
What I really don't understand is why the club gives managers such long contracts.
 
Its not just football though. We have become less patient and want it all now. It goes from personal finances, to careers, through our cars and houses and football is just part of the impatient machine that is modern day life. I want it now because I am apparently worth it.
 
Its not just football though. We have become less patient and want it all now. It goes from personal finances, to careers, through our cars and houses and football is just part of the impatient machine that is modern day life. I want it now because I am apparently worth it.

Great post. If something breaks down, don't fix it, just throw it out and buy a new one.
 
Yes , we should not crave for anything our masters do not wish to grant us and be grateful we still have a team to support.
 
Out of all of them, who would have seen us higher up the leagues given the time? Maybe Wilson if we hadn't been cost cutting and maybe Speed if he hadn't gone to manage Wales - and died.
 
Hopefully, we now have a manager who can take us where we want to be & see us drop down that list over the coming seasons.
 
Out of all of them, who would have seen us higher up the leagues given the time? Maybe Wilson if we hadn't been cost cutting and maybe Speed if he hadn't gone to manage Wales - and died.
'Tbf' to the other managers Wilson did get the cream of the crop compared to the them after dropping to league one. That's not to say they could'nt have done a decent job though compared to Wilson, i'm simply pointing out that you have to see what players they have at their disposal and what funds they'd have to compare them properly, admittedly, that would propably be impossible to judge.
 
'Tbf' to the other managers Wilson did get the cream of the crop compared to the them after dropping to league one. That's not to say they could'nt have done a decent job though compared to Wilson, i'm simply pointing out that you have to see what players they have at their disposal and what funds they'd have to compare them properly, admittedly, that would propably be impossible to judge.

Know what you're saying but they only became the cream of the crop after relegation to league 1 and Wilson becoming manager. They were shit before albeit in a higher league. Dunno. Wilson best of a bad bunch for me though.
 
Wilson is the only one that could lay claim to being hard done to. The rest were architects of their own downfall (Aside from Speed obvioulsy)
 



Yes , we should not crave for anything our masters do not wish to grant us and be grateful we still have a team to support.

Who said anything approaching that then?
 
Wilson is the only one that could lay claim to being hard done to. The rest were architects of their own downfall (Aside from Speed obvioulsy)

I think Clough could argue he could have been granted another season with some justification. Its arguable I know but I wouldn't say he got a fair crack of the whip with only one full season in the job.
 
When we appoint a manager who does the job right all of us will realise just how bad this string of managers have been. Just one manager capable of lifting the club from the downward spiral since the Tevez affair would have made all the difference. Instead we have suffered a series of mediocrity and ineptitude.

McCabe may be able to recognise a commercial opportunity in property but he got all his football managerial appointments wrong. Some say he sacked a couple too soon but after about a year in post there are signs if any manager is making progress. Come the end of next season let's hope we forum members are debating marginal issues not fundamental ones which both Wilson and Clough did not have the capability to tackle.

Both those managers were experienced managers with years and years of non-achievement on their C.V., not bad managers but nothing more than also-rans. They had obvious good qualities but were nowhere near the "real deal" needed here. At Bramall Lane they simply reinforced their record and another year would likely have just extended their non-achievements but even with a promotion they would have been under even more pressure at the higher level.

What we need is a man who can alter fundamentals in a club and create a new mood, a new culture if you like, at all levels. He needs to have the capacity to gain promotion with a bit to spare and progress in all areas and which will serve us well at the higher level and even beyond. When we have that man we will look back and wonder why so many of us yearned for Wilson and Clough to be given even more time to fail.

Is Adkins that man? Well he is a proven winner. Will a year be enough to judge? Yes, but promotion is only one objective in that time, there is loads more to do in S2 if we are to use these bad times to build for the future. It will only take one big man to do a very big job. Otherwise we will be scratching around year after year.
 
Its not just football though. We have become less patient and want it all now. It goes from personal finances, to careers, through our cars and houses and football is just part of the impatient machine that is modern day life. I want it now because I am apparently worth it.
This
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom