I think it might be more that a lot of our decent players in the last five years or so are now over 30 like Egan, Stevens, Mcgoldrick, Bash, Fleck etc.
In their prime they were adequate PL players. O'Connell was the pick but he got injured of course.
I think our fans appreciate class players like Berge but he's a much more improved player now with more years experience than he was with us as a 21 year old.
Glynn Hodges was definitely a favourite as was Borbokis and Fjortoft just to name a few. They weren't muck and nettles. Mark Patterson was but he got some stick as did Monty for lacking class. I loved Patto myself, not as keen on Monty but each to his own. I know what you mean but I think fans criticise players whatever they are style wise often.