Which of the signings are you most disappointed with Metal?
Kitson not questioning his ability but does he have the desire and how big a chunk of the wage budget goes to him ? Was he even a Wilson signing ???
Blackman Ok
Hill Ok as back up I suppose
McMahon Other than the last two games he has been a shockingly bad signing
Miller at £60k we took a chance on him and it paid off, very unfortunate to pick up a long term injury
Westlake A replacement for Lowton ? never been a full back, says it all when McMahon is preferred over him
Howard a keeper who has never made it even in Scotland where Lee Baxter would look good Long is a much better option
Williams simply useless
Flynn a scapegoat for many but he has more assists than anyone and chips in a few goals not our worse player by a long way
McDonald Ok if we have someone at his side to do the ugly bits
LJF he can't come back quick enough better than Hill or Williams even if he is no world beater
Porter just an average player even in this poor division not sure why we extended his contract maybe at the time we thought Cresswell was Scunny bound
I've put the questionable ones in italics. Westlake is young and could improve.