Outgoing? Brewster

[originaltrueblade]

Contract out very soon be surprised if he stays without the protection of Wilder

 

[Torrix1889]

Meh

 

[Aston max]

The lad definitely has heart ,but I think a change would do him good personally if I was him ( if he wants to stay in the area ) look at Barnsley, Rotherham or donny ,I think a drop would be advisable to reserect his career

 

[alcoblade]

You can't imagine a world where an AI model looks at Brewster's stats and suggests him as a target for us, so Id be amazed if he stayed.

 

[Mouth of the South]

The lad definitely has heart ,but I think a change would do him good personally if I was him ( if he wants to stay in the area ) look at Barnsley, Rotherham or donny ,I think a drop would be advisable to reserect his career

If he rejected Utd's offer/s, I can't see any of those clubs you mentioned offering more.
A lower Champ club would be my guess if he does leave Utd - someone like Derby or Hull

 

[3Cheers4Ramirez]

He should have signed the contract when we had the chance. He won't get a better offer. Hopefully the offer has now been withdrawn

 

[Richeee]

You can't imagine a world where an AI model looks at Brewster's stats and suggests him as a target for us, so Id be amazed if he stayed.

It makes you wonder just how many other players at the club would "pass" the AI test

 

[LBA_Blade]

It makes you wonder just how many other players at the club would "pass" the AI test

Just on the OP topic and using ChatGPT the question I asked it was is Rhian Brewster a Ruben Selles style player? Summary below

Bottom line: Brewster shows the mental and stylistic foundations Sellés values—pressing, spatial awareness, and build-up intelligence. However, to be a truly “Sellés-style” forward, he’d need to tighten team pressing coordination and develop more structured positional discipline.

So although Brewster shows some promise that Selles would look at he isn't the "full-package"

 

[alcoblade]

It makes you wonder just how many other players at the club would "pass" the AI test

We'll find out in the coming year or so. I'm concerned about how much decision making were planning to hand over to ai, and I suspect most will be. I've got a bit of an insight into this (which I won't go into). Of course, it could be a great thing too. But it's enormously experimental.

 

[3Cheers4Ramirez]

Guinea Pig FC

 

[TopBoy]

Brewster, JLT, Moore, and possibly based on last season, Cannon and Campbell don't fit Selle's system. The rest are a great fit I feel.

 

[alcoblade]

Brewster, JLT, Moore, and possibly based on last season, Cannon and Campbell don't fit Selle's system. The rest are a great fit I feel.

You might find that there isn't a Selles system, and that he's been brought in to implement a system generated by ai.

 

[ChipButtyBlade]

Brewster could be Selles' Gelhardt.

 

[Davalon]

Thought he was off to the SPL.

And these ignorant AI comments that literally drench every thread about us on every social media platform are boring as fuck.

 

[Charlieblade]

It makes you wonder just how many other players at the club would "pass" the AI test

I think a few members here have got the wrong end of the stick. AI is the quickest growth engine in any world, not just sports and recruitment.
In the COH case, they have some expertise at the highest level. Those selected, like the 3 most recent buys, are development players. They will each spend between one and three years in our academy development side.

Young players always develop differently, depending on age, experience and ability. Very few will make the first team, and the rest will be sold at a profit hopefully. At this level AI recruitment is still in its infancy, but growing rapidly. When it adjusted to the top levels of English football it will pay off well for the owners.

Adults and fully developed players will still be recruited directly, for first team squads, but any gaps can be filled in future, by developed academy players. This is the world that Arblaster and Peck come from. Very little changes except the breadth of choice for recruitment purposes.

Eventually, most first teamers will come through AI, but that is still years away now. In the mean time, traditional methods, probably supported by AI evidence will continue.

 

[ATL Recs]

I think a few members here have got the wrong end of the stick. AI is the quickest growth engine in any world, not just sports and recruitment.
In the COH case, they have some expertise at the highest level. Those selected, like the 3 most recent buys, are development players. They will each spend between one and three years in our academy development side.

Young players always develop differently, depending on age, experience and ability. Very few will make the first team, and the rest will be sold at a profit hopefully. At this level AI recruitment is still in its infancy, but growing rapidly. When it adjusted to the top levels of English football it will pay off well for the owners.

Adults and fully developed players will still be recruited directly, for first team squads, but any gaps can be filled in future, by developed academy players. This is the world that Arblaster and Peck come from. Very little changes except the breadth of choice for recruitment purposes.

Eventually, most first teamers will come through AI, but that is still years away now. In the mean time, traditional methods, probably supported by AI evidence will continue.

Exactly this good post

 

[Shadota]

Thought he was off to the SPL.

And these ignorant AI comments that literally drench every thread about us on every social media platform are boring as fuck.

Nice to see that someone has the same opinion that I do.

Any comment that features the phrase "I asked ChatGPT..." or some variant of that - I immediately am no longer interested.

It feels like "I'm incapable of forming my own opinion on this topic, so I got one from a glorified search engine".

 

[Blade58]

Nice to see that someone has the same opinion that I do.

Any comment that features the phrase "I asked ChatGPT..." or some variant of that - I immediately am no longer interested.

It feels like "I'm incapable of forming my own opinion on this topic, so I got one from a glorified search engine".

Phones and social media have ended the art of actual conversation

ChatGPT (and others) will end the art of thinking

 

[LBA_Blade]

Nice to see that someone has the same opinion that I do.

Any comment that features the phrase "I asked ChatGPT..." or some variant of that - I immediately am no longer interested.

It feels like "I'm incapable of forming my own opinion on this topic, so I got one from a glorified search engine".

For me as long as a bit of "human interactive sanity check" is done to the quote or opinion then I am not overly bothered by it and it interesting as to see how AI has developed so quickly, it is not only there but free to use at a drop of a hat. In my spare time I assess sports leaders courses and "train the trainers" and ChatGPT has been such a time saver. I can put a phrase in with the number of participants, the equipment I have got, the activity area and any time restraints and it will create several different options.

All I need to do is then sanity check them to make sure they aren't telling my guys to jump off a bridge or take over the world and jobs a good un'. In under a minute, I can have several activities with rules and clear explanation with no thinking, usually that would take me 15 minutes at least per activity to create and explain a new one from fresh. it has saved me hours so far.

I can see journo's definitely using it more and it won't be long before there is a solely generated AI website/app for news. When it comes to football unless an agent has a clear leak to the papers, the transfer rumours that are actually come true are very slim. On 31st May 2025 the odds for the next manager for us was a clear favourite of Sean Dyche at 5/2, with Selles not appearing on the list of front runners that went up to 25/1. Selles was still not favourite 2 days before appointment with some bookies. AI is a useful tool in balance, you can get quick data then sanity check it with some commentary (it's no different from quoting from a source such as Sky sports) If I have used ChatGPT in the past, in this forum, I always say I have and then put some commentary around it, I have found it is a useful tool to understand someone/something that you might not be too familiar with in a certain context.

But you can also do stuff like creating a Sheffield united new corner kick routine, on reflection, do we already do this or could this be something deployed. Although I know, what I put on here isn't exactly going to find it's way onto the training pitch, there is still a debate to be had about increasing scoring opportunities from set pieces. We don't score enough from corners, like most teams and quite often we aren't even getting a shot away.

Objective:

Create chaos in the box while pulling opposition defenders out of shape, allowing a late-arriving player to strike from a central shooting position.
Setup:

• Corner Taker: Left-footed on right side (in-swinger) or right-footed on left side (in-swinger)
• 3 Attackers in Box:
  
  • #Striker (e.g., Moore): Central, marked tightly
  • #CB (e.g., Anel Ahmedhodžić): Far post zone
  • #CB (e.g., Jack Robinson): Near post run
• 2 Distractors:
  
  • #Good striker of the ball (e.g., Gustavo Hamer): Just inside the D, feinting inward
  • #CM (e.g., Vinicius Souza): Outside the box, right side, seemingly idle
• 1 Blocker:
  
  • Attacking Mid (e.g., O'Hare): Starts inside the 6-yard box to set a subtle screen or block

---

Routine Sequence:​

1. Corner Taker gives a hand signal to indicate the routine.
2. On the run-up:
   
   • #4 and #6 CBs criss-cross in front of the 6-yard box: #6 pulls to near post, #4 loops wide to far.
   • #9 Striker makes a delayed curved run toward the penalty spot.
   • #10 sets a block on the opposition's strongest aerial threat to impede jumping.
3. Meanwhile:
   
   • #7 (Hamer) dummies a run into the box but actually holds back at the edge of the D.
   • #8 (Souza) suddenly darts in diagonally from outside the box—this is the trap!
4. Corner Taker curls it low and fast toward the penalty spot or just beyond, not toward the crowd.
5. #8 (Souza) strikes first time or lays it off to Hamer for a shot.

Key Features:

• Designed for a second-ball shot rather than a direct header.
• Uses deceptive positioning and timed movement to draw defenders out.

 

[Addison]

CW's departure probably puts paid to any attempt to offer another contract. The reality is Brewster's injury record lack of appearances and impact in the games he did play will count against him as will the fact it has previously reported he was one of the high wage earners at the club.

I don't see Selles pressing game suiting Brewster it was an area Ohare was far superior in.

Brewster is with a German football agency and they will be looking for top dollar on the wages front. For that reason I don't see any takers from championship clubs and his best option would seem to be abroad.

 

[Bladesman]

Contract out very soon be surprised if he stays without the protection of Wilder

If Brewster thinks about football over money then the wise move would be to go back to Swansea. Well liked there and will get time to get himself back up to speed.

 

[Th!stledo]

AI is a tool that can rapidly gather a lot of information, processed it and then present it's own unique analysis of that information.
As individuals we can absorb that information and then draw our own conclusions and form our own opinions.

Find below how one AI gathered, analysed and drew it's own conclusion on how to present the information:


Rhian Brewster's Fit with Selles Tactics


Found 14 results


Thought for 30 seconds


Hmm, let's tackle this question about whether Rhian Brewster is a good fit for Ruben Selles' style at Sheffield United. First, I need to understand what the user is asking. They want to know if Brewster suits Selles' tactical approach. I found many search results, so I'll start by reviewing those.

Looking at the search results, Brewster's contract situation is critical. His deal expires on June 30, 2025, and negotiations are ongoing but there's a gap in valuations 124. That's context, but the main question is about his playing style under Selles.

Next, I should outline Selles' preferred tactics. The user's question implies we need to infer Selles' style since he's newly appointed. Among these search results, it mentions Selles was at Hull City, but there's no direct info on his tactics. However, 7 notes that Selles' Hull conceded a late goal, which might hint at high pressing, but it's speculative. I'll have to base this on general knowledge or indirect clues.

Brewster's versatility is highlighted in multiple articles. He played as a striker, attacking midfielder, and on the wings last season 14. His positional flexibility is a plus. His stats show 4 goals and 3 assists in 36 appearances, with 16 starts 4. His best performance was scoring the derby winner against Sheffield Wednesday 13, which shows he can deliver in big moments.

Injuries have been a recurring issue for Brewster, affecting his consistency 34. However, last season was his healthiest, allowing him to contribute more. His transformation into a deeper role or winger under Wilder 1 might align with a high-pressing system if Selles employs one.

The new manager's impact is uncertain. 2 mentions that Wilder's departure might affect Brewster's willingness to stay, but the contract offer remains. Selles hasn't commented yet, so his valuation of Brewster is unknown. The club's delay in securing his contract might indicate they see him as a squad player rather than essential 4

Comparing strengths and weaknesses: Brewster's work rate and versatility are assets. His injury history and inconsistent scoring (only 8 goals in 106 appearances) 34 are drawbacks. Selles might appreciate his pressing and adaptability but could be concerned about fitness and output.

will structure the answer by covering Brewster's contract status, playing style, tactical fit under Selles, and the unresolved factors like the new manager's plans. Highlighting his versatility and recent role changes under Wilder as potential alignment with high-pressing systems. Also, mention the financial aspect where losing him for free isn't a huge loss given his original fee is already sunk 24.

Need to ensure references are correctly cited. For example, Brewster's deeper role is in 1, stats in 4, injury history in 3. Also, note that Selles' appointment is recent, so his style isn't detailed in the search results, requiring some inference.

In conclusion, Brewster's flexibility and work rate could suit Selles if he values adaptable forwards, but his injury record and the new manager's unknown preferences leave questions. The contract situation adds urgency, but the fit is plausible if Selles prioritizes versatility.
Based on the available information regarding Rhian Brewster's attributes and Ruben Selles' tactical profile, Brewster appears to be a potential fit for Selles' system, though with some caveats. Here's a detailed analysis:

Note: The numbers are references to the site where the information was taken from.


Below is how it chose to present it's answer:

​

1. Positional Versatility:
   Brewster has evolved from a traditional striker (#9) into a multi-functional forward under Chris Wilder. Last season, he frequently operated as a deeper-lying playmaker, right/left winger, or attacking midfielder. This adaptability aligns with Selles' preference for fluid, dynamic attacking setups 14. His heatmaps and positional data show significant work rate in wide and transitional zones, fitting systems emphasizing width and interchangeability 511.
2. Work Rate and Pressing:
   Selles' systems (notably at Southampton and Hull City) often prioritize high pressing and defensive contribution from forwards. Brewster's physical strength and willingness to engage in defensive duties—evidenced by his 1.7 tackles per 90 minutes in the Championship—suit this approach. His transformation into a "team player" beyond pure goal-scoring was highlighted in Wilder's tactics 14.
3. Big-Moment Impact:
   Despite limited starts (16 in 36 appearances in 2024/25), Brewster delivered crucial goals, including a Steel City Derby winner and a playoff-push decider against Millwall. Selles values players who thrive under pressure, and Brewster's clutch performances demonstrate this trait 137.

​

1. Inconsistent Output:
   Brewster's goal contributions (4 goals, 3 assists last season) remain modest for a forward. His career at Sheffield United has been marred by injuries and fluctuating form, with only 8 goals in 106 total appearances. Selles may need a more prolific focal point unless Brewster is deployed purely as a facilitator 34.
2. Injury History:
   Recurrent hamstring issues have disrupted his momentum. Selles' high-intensity system could exacerbate injury risks if Brewster isn't fully fit 311.
3. Uncertain Contract Status:
   With Brewster's contract expiring on June 30, 2025, and negotiations stalled over wage demands, Selles may not view him as essential. The club's reluctance to urgently secure his extension suggests he is seen as a squad player rather than a core asset 124.

​

• Tactical Value: Brewster's positional flexibility allows Selles to experiment with formations (e.g., 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3) without requiring multiple signings.
• Cost-Efficiency: Retaining Brewster on reduced terms could free funds for other reinforcements.
• Project Fit: At 25, Brewster fits the profile of a player who could thrive under a developmental coach like Selles—if he stays fit 24.

​

Brewster aligns stylistically with Selles' emphasis on versatility and work ethic but must overcome durability and productivity issues. His retention would offer tactical depth, but Selles is unlikely to build the attack around him unless his contract situation resolves soon. If released, Sheffield United's recruitment focus would shift toward a more reliable goal threat 14.

This might not be everyone's cup of tea. For me, it has saved me a lot of time trawling through the net and gave me it's analysis. I can then form my own opinion on what I agree or disagree with.

 

[Lowen]

His agent will be shopping him around as he will have been offered reduced terms here and could probably get a better contract elsewhere. He proved himself as a decent squad player last season so wouldn’t be upset to see him sign but that’s all he really is and will be no massive loss as a result if he decides to go.

 

[Harry's Game]

Can go for me

 

[originaltrueblade]

Can go for me

Agree

 

[LondonBlade89]

I’d love to ban AI-driven responses in here. We get the use of it and how it’s helpful. But equally, anyone can do it. It doesn’t take long.

 

[Toronto Blade]

It makes you wonder just how many other players at the club would "pass" the AI test

Wilder might be interested

 

[originaltrueblade]

If Brewster thinks about football over money then the wise move would be to go back to Swansea. Well liked there and will get time to get himself back up to speed.

Maybe a partnership with McBurnie at Swansea

 

[dellasthunderbolt]

Without being too harsh - surely pound for pound our worst ever signing

 

[Rochdaleblade]

For me as long as a bit of "human interactive sanity check" is done to the quote or opinion then I am not overly bothered by it and it interesting as to see how AI has developed so quickly, it is not only there but free to use at a drop of a hat. In my spare time I assess sports leaders courses and "train the trainers" and ChatGPT has been such a time saver. I can put a phrase in with the number of participants, the equipment I have got, the activity area and any time restraints and it will create several different options.

All I need to do is then sanity check them to make sure they aren't telling my guys to jump off a bridge or take over the world and jobs a good un'. In under a minute, I can have several activities with rules and clear explanation with no thinking, usually that would take me 15 minutes at least per activity to create and explain a new one from fresh. it has saved me hours so far.

I can see journo's definitely using it more and it won't be long before there is a solely generated AI website/app for news. When it comes to football unless an agent has a clear leak to the papers, the transfer rumours that are actually come true are very slim. On 31st May 2025 the odds for the next manager for us was a clear favourite of Sean Dyche at 5/2, with Selles not appearing on the list of front runners that went up to 25/1. Selles was still not favourite 2 days before appointment with some bookies. AI is a useful tool in balance, you can get quick data then sanity check it with some commentary (it's no different from quoting from a source such as Sky sports) If I have used ChatGPT in the past, in this forum, I always say I have and then put some commentary around it, I have found it is a useful tool to understand someone/something that you might not be too familiar with in a certain context.

But you can also do stuff like creating a Sheffield united new corner kick routine, on reflection, do we already do this or could this be something deployed. Although I know, what I put on here isn't exactly going to find it's way onto the training pitch, there is still a debate to be had about increasing scoring opportunities from set pieces. We don't score enough from corners, like most teams and quite often we aren't even getting a shot away.

Objective:

Create chaos in the box while pulling opposition defenders out of shape, allowing a late-arriving player to strike from a central shooting position.
Setup:

• Corner Taker: Left-footed on right side (in-swinger) or right-footed on left side (in-swinger)
• 3 Attackers in Box:
  • #Striker (e.g., Moore): Central, marked tightly
  • #CB (e.g., Anel Ahmedhodžić): Far post zone
  • #CB (e.g., Jack Robinson): Near post run
• 2 Distractors:
  • #Good striker of the ball (e.g., Gustavo Hamer): Just inside the D, feinting inward
  • #CM (e.g., Vinicius Souza): Outside the box, right side, seemingly idle
• 1 Blocker:
  • Attacking Mid (e.g., O'Hare): Starts inside the 6-yard box to set a subtle screen or block

---

Routine Sequence:​

1. Corner Taker gives a hand signal to indicate the routine.
2. On the run-up:
   • #4 and #6 CBs criss-cross in front of the 6-yard box: #6 pulls to near post, #4 loops wide to far.
   • #9 Striker makes a delayed curved run toward the penalty spot.
   • #10 sets a block on the opposition's strongest aerial threat to impede jumping.
3. Meanwhile:
   • #7 (Hamer) dummies a run into the box but actually holds back at the edge of the D.
   • #8 (Souza) suddenly darts in diagonally from outside the box—this is the trap!
4. Corner Taker curls it low and fast toward the penalty spot or just beyond, not toward the crowd.
5. #8 (Souza) strikes first time or lays it off to Hamer for a shot.

Key Features:

• Designed for a second-ball shot rather than a direct header.
• Uses deceptive positioning and timed movement to draw defenders out.

Who's the zone man?