Brewster

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?


Nick Jansky said:
Good to hear Wilder call out some of the derogatory comments he’s seen about Brewster as being “cheap & lazy” from people who have no idea of the journey he’s been on. Spot on.
Click to expand...

Absolutely spot on. His price tag was never his fault and if anyone seriously thinks he wouldn't rather have been playing and scoring goals instead of having his injury issues then they need to give their head a wobble.
 
Great to hear Wilder’s praising Brewster and saying he’s one of best in the dressing room in terms of attitude and popularity around the club with staff he’s ever dealt with - up there with Bash.

It’s been an open secret that he’s an absolutely cracking lad who is a credit to himself, so I’m so delighted he’s become a hero with the derby goal and he’s looking so good with Campbell as a duo.

Well done Rhian.
 
MadDad38 said:
If the choice was between signing BBD or re-signing Brewster in the summer I’d choose Brewster.
Click to expand...

I might be in the minority, but I'd sign both for next season. Both have more to show us what they can really do and for the relatively cheapish deals to get them both (im including wages and signing on fees as well as BBD transfer fee) they would both be a bargain at this time. To let Brewster go now after the money we have spent on him in these last 5 injury hit years would be just daft, especially when he's now getting fit and having an injury free run of games. Any new deal for Brewster to reflect the previous seasons though. He can't surely expect the same level of contract again.
 
Would offer Brewster a one year with option contract, but not on the wages he's on now, Diaz would depend on fee Saints want
 
Weasel said:
I might be in the minority, but I'd sign both for next season. Both have more to show us what they can really do and for the relatively cheapish deals to get them both (im including wages and signing on fees as well as BBD transfer fee) they would both be a bargain at this time. To let Brewster go now after the money we have spent on him in these last 5 injury hit years would be just daft, especially when he's now getting fit and having an injury free run of games. Any new deal for Brewster to reflect the previous seasons though. He can't surely expect the same level of contract again.
Click to expand...
If and its a big if we do get to the Premiership we would need better than BBD, especially if we don't want too get tonked every week.
Been a bit disappointed with BBD this time around he's certainly not been up to the levels of his first time here.
Brewster I would keep he is looking good in his new role.
 

I'm a big fan of Brewdog, he's grown a lot as a player this season. He also seems to be very well thought of at the club, and you can't help but admire his determination. Many would've quit or would've just sat there collecting a wage if they had to deal with his injury problems, but Brewster has always worked to come back stronger and with a smile on his face. Give him a new contract.
 
Pintor75 said:
Why bother asking
Click to expand...
Yeah, very good point. I think you probably answered that yourself....

But to humour you... because it highlights that saying you would reduce his wages when you don't know a) the budget, b) the wages hes on and multiple other factors is a bit pointless
 
SwissBlade said:
Yeah, very good point. I think you probably answered that yourself....

But to humour you... because it highlights that saying you would reduce his wages when you don't know a) the budget, b) the wages hes on and multiple other factors is a bit pointless
Click to expand...
We all know he’s on big wages as he’s on the contract when we signed him for £20+ million. He’s not the player we thought we were buying and still isn’t so will be offered a deal on less terms I would imagine.
 
Ranmoorblade said:
We all know he’s on big wages as he’s on the contract when we signed him for £20+ million. He’s not the player we thought we were buying and still isn’t so will be offered a deal on less terms I would imagine.
Click to expand...
Normally i find these discussions on wage speculation a little pointless. But for what it's worth i'll explain why, specifically to Brewster.

I don't think i've ever seen anything official as to what his wages are.

Football League world is not an official source. Not even close!

He was signed as a young player for a big fee, which we don't know how it was structured.
A big fee doesn't guarantee that he's on a big wage and we don't know the details of how that wage is structured.

We don't know the budget for next season, since we don't know the division we'll be in. We don't know where he sits in terms of earners at the club. Certainly performances this season would suggest that he's likely to be one of the top earners going forwards (with the current squad).
He's gone a long way this season to confirm the he can maintain his core fitness.

I'd suggest that we extend his contract for another 2-3 years based on this season. The wages, irrelevant to me as a fan. Pay him his worth to the club.
 
SwissBlade said:
Normally i find these discussions on wage speculation a little pointless. But for what it's worth i'll explain why, specifically to Brewster.

I don't think i've ever seen anything official as to what his wages are.

Football League world is not an official source. Not even close!

He was signed as a young player for a big fee, which we don't know how it was structured.
A big fee doesn't guarantee that he's on a big wage and we don't know the details of how that wage is structured.

We don't know the budget for next season, since we don't know the division we'll be in. We don't know where he sits in terms of earners at the club. Certainly performances this season would suggest that he's likely to be one of the top earners going forwards (with the current squad).
He's gone a long way this season to confirm the he can maintain his core fitness.

I'd suggest that we extend his contract for another 2-3 years based on this season. The wages, irrelevant to me as a fan. Pay him his worth to the club.
Click to expand...
The revisionism is good but he’s had 3 seasons of maximum 5/10 performances followed by this season where he’s been at best 7/10, probably 6/10 on average.

The money we’ve spent is now sunk but I wouldn’t be climbing over ourselves to give him 2 or 3 years when he’s only 6 half decent months out of 48.
 
Houston_Blade said:
The revisionism is good but he’s had 3 seasons of maximum 5/10 performances followed by this season where he’s been at best 7/10, probably 6/10 on average.

The money we’ve spent is now sunk but I wouldn’t be climbing over ourselves to give him 2 or 3 years when he’s only 6 half decent months out of 48.
Click to expand...
He's had some serious injuries which have played a huge part in the last 2-3 years. I don't get why people are so blinkered with this and just look at the money we've paid rather than the fact that he's come back multiple times and broken down with either the same injury or something else, only to come back and have the season he's had.
 
I didn't get the wow factor with brewster, he's a very ordinary player, who just happens to have been fit this season as he would be after a new contract..

This post is just for balance, and both of them wouldn't be good enough in the PL.

Stay in the championship, maybe Diaz..

I don't know but what's brewsters goals in his time here...remember he's a striker.

(I know he's been injured - but balance that out with he's been playing against some pretty bad defenders when he's actually fit)
 
Tezza1889 said:
I didn't get the wow factor with brewster, he's a very ordinary player, who just happens to have been fit this season as he would be after a new contract..

This post is just for balance, and both of them wouldn't be good enough in the PL.

Stay in the championship, maybe Diaz..

I don't know but what's brewsters goals in his time here...remember he's a striker.

(I know he's been injured - but balance that out with he's been playing against some pretty bad defenders when he's actually fit)
Click to expand...
Whilst we're posting for balance, he's played in behind often this season. Rotating with O'Hare, so, for shits and giggles, lets get ChatGPT's comparison

⚽ Goals & Assists​

PlayerAppearancesGoalsAssistsTotal Goal Involvements
Callum O’Hare45369
Rhian Brewster37437

📊 Per 90 Minutes Performance​


MetricCallum O’HareRhian Brewster
Goals per 900.060.25
Assists per 900.200.18
Goal Involvements/900.230.43
Non-Penalty xG/900.090.23
Key Passes per 901.191.17
Pass Completion Rate80.93%78.39%
Click to expand...

🎯 Shooting & Creativity​

  • Callum O’Hare: Registered 22 shots with a 50% accuracy, scoring once every 11 shots. footystats.org
  • Rhian Brewster: Took 21 shots with a 33.3% accuracy, netting a goal every 5.25 shots. footystats.org
Click to expand...

​

 
SwissBlade said:
He's had some serious injuries which have played a huge part in the last 2-3 years. I don't get why people are so blinkered with this and just look at the money we've paid rather than the fact that he's come back multiple times and broken down with either the same injury or something else, only to come back and have the season he's had.
Click to expand...
Would we be looking to sign someone like Brewster from another championship club, based on his performance / stats?

I'd say definitely not.
 
alcoblade said:
Would we be looking to sign someone like Brewster from another championship club, based on his performance / stats?

I'd say definitely not.
Click to expand...
There would be outrage if we did.

But would you also be looking to sign O'hare based on his performance stats this season? Doubt it. But it was a proper jizz fest over him signing last summer... And he's also had a good season this season
 
SwissBlade said:
There would be outrage if we did.

But would you also be looking to sign O'hare based on his performance stats this season? Doubt it. But it was a proper jizz fest over him signing last summer... And he's also had a good season this season
Click to expand...
If I applied the eye test, I'd personally rate O'Hare quite a bit above Brewster. Both are miles of premier league quality, but that's another story.
 
alcoblade said:
If I applied the eye test, I'd personally rate O'Hare quite a bit above Brewster. Both are miles of premier league quality, but that's another story.
Click to expand...
I know that O'Hare offers a different option to Brewster, but it's Brewster for me.

Lets face it, O'Hare has crap goal celebrations
 

You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

NAnstonblade
Brewster
2
Replies
59
Views
4K
Blademan89
Blademan89
GymClassHero
Will we sell out?
10 11 12
Replies
332
Views
19K
JJBlade
JJBlade
Slim Man
The BBD Conundrum
2
Replies
33
Views
2K
robbiez666
R
C
Absolute disgrace?
Replies
2
Views
836
Bladesince59
Bladesince59
ThatJa
The sad reality is..
2
Replies
39
Views
3K
BladeByChoice
BladeByChoice

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom