Blades 1-11 using one player from 2013-2023

[JackSUFC]

Saw this thread on Twitter and thought it could be some Tuesday fun. Busy morning in the office, obviously.



Quite happy with my effort. Reckon anyone can beat it?

 

[Tarqs]

Id have duffy in there over Gibbs-White (purely cos imo MGW only did it for 4 months, he was annoying as fuck his first half of the season).

 

[JackSUFC]

Id have duffy in there over Gibbs-White (purely cos imo MGW only did it for 4 months, he was annoying as fuck his first half of the season).

Aye but MGW is the player used from 21/22 season. If you put Duffy in then you've got to take one of Stevens, Coutts or Fleck out and they were the better options from those years IMO.

 

[Cheesebored]

Henderson, whilst being a cunt and at his peak, blinds Ramsdale (also a cunt). I appreciate this means you having to jig around your outfield players.

 

[nopigfansintown]

​

Starting 11: 3-5-2 - Henderson; Stevens, O'Connell, Maguire, Basham, Baldock; Fleck, Coutts, Duffy; Sharp, Ndiaye.

Bench: Jamie Murphy, Coady, Egan, RND, Mcattee, Ahmedhodžić, David Brooks, Berge, Gibbs White, Norwood, Clarke, Brayford, Foderingham, Ramsdale, Jake Wright snr, Mousset (Prem season one) , Lundstram.


The toughest ones to leave out of starting eleven for me were Egan, Berge, Norwood, Wright and Anel. At a push MGW.

 

[nopigfansintown]

Henderson, whilst being a cunt and at his peak, blinds Ramsdale (also a cunt). I appreciate this means you having to jig around your outfield players.

Ramsdale was terrible until October-November time. If he had had his form after that for the whole season he'd have been a shoe in imo. Having said that goalkeepers in relegation sides are often overrated due to the volume of work they have to deal with.

 

[Carlton Blade]

Harry Maguire 12/13
John Brayford 13/14
Need a CM so it'll have to be Bash because Coutts wasn't Coutts yet 14/15
Sharp 15/16
JOC 16/17
Fleck 17/18
Henderson 18/19
Stevens 19/20
Egan 20/21
MGW 21/22
Ndiaye 22/23

Henderson
Brayford Egan Maguire JOC Stevens
Fleck Bash (or future Coutts)
Ndiaye MGW
Sharp

Honourable mentions

Jamie Murphy 14/15
Mark Duffy 16/17, 17/18, 18/19
AA - 22/23
Baldock 22/23
Norwood 18/19, 19/20
Mousset 19/20
Coutts 16/17, 17/18

 

[sufc323]

Saw this thread on Twitter and thought it could be some Tuesday fun. Busy morning in the office, obviously.



Quite happy with my effort. Reckon anyone can beat it?

View attachment 160731

More or less got same as this, the 20/21 season was a killer cos there's only 2 players you could have, Ramsdale or Didzy and even Ramsdale is a push with how bad he was that first half.

 

[Carlton Blade]

Saw this thread on Twitter and thought it could be some Tuesday fun. Busy morning in the office, obviously.



Quite happy with my effort. Reckon anyone can beat it?

View attachment 160731

I'm calling cheat here. Bash wasn't playing as a wide CB in 14/15

 

[nopigfansintown]

Forgot Didzy. For shame.

 

[S64 Blade]

---------------------------Wes (21/22)-----------------------------
------Basham (14/15)----Maguire (12/13)---O'Connell; (17/18)------
---Brayford (13/14)-------------------------------------Lafferty (16/17)
------------Norwood (18/19)------Fleck(19/20)-----------------
------------------------McGoldrick (20/21)----------------------
----------------Sharp (15/16)---------Ndiaye (22/23)------------


It got tricky around the League One era! Had to shoehorn Bash in (realise he didn't play here in 14/15).

 

[JackSUFC]

I'm calling cheat here. Bash wasn't playing as a wide CB in 14/15

Fine we’ll have to sub him for Jay McEveley.

Christ, only joking.

Bash would move into midfield in a 4-3-3 in that case. Still be a decent side.

 

[Carlton Blade]

No love for Egan (other than me). I thought he was head and shoulders the best (I know this is a relative term) player in 20/21

 

[Argentinemanager]

If you had to pick the worst team using the same criteria who would get in, could be some real dross 2013 but would get difficult for the last few years

 

[Champagneblade]

11 Bashams!