Andy Gidings what a clown

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

davidpinder

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Messages
4,222
Reaction score
1,151
Location
Dronfield
Was listening to the end of praise and grumble and noticed at exactly 10.24pm Andy was encouraging people to call in before the show finished (which is 10.30pm) He then went to an interview with John Sheridan after that he again encouraged people to call tonight and went to an interview with piggy Clinton Morrison after that they went to Ronnie Moore and finally to Mark Robins So by 10.30pm the show was done. Please Andy tell me why you wanted people to call as all the interviews were clearly recordings and not live.
 



can you just start one thread called 'davidpinder spouts bollox' and put all your postings there?

you are an attention seeker!
 
A bit strong radioblade but I know where you're coming from. I dont have a problem with dp's posts but it does make one's eyes roll into the back of one's head when you see the latest pointless thread. Usually a thread that is neither interesting nor Blades related.

Attention seeking? Hmm maybe, maybe not. I think its more an excuse for a moan, about what ever the person starting the thread can find. I normally just skim past them due to the lack of interest I mentioned before but I think its something that should be put to the administrators as a problem that needs addressing. I know it states in the forum etiquette somewhere that posts/threads should be topical and have a point to them but I think a number of people flout this rule/expectation.

It just becomes unpleasant when people get fooked off with it and start name calling as in this case. But the people who start these threads open themselves up to that so I have no sympathy.
 
It's a bit much dp to call the bloke a clown... did you not consider that at 10.24pm he didn't have word that he had interviews with Sheridan, Moron, Moore and Robins lined up? In that case he can't have dead air - although you could argue that most of the people who phone in are just that - so he has to make an allowance. Then the interviews roll in and the calls get bumped. Don't see a problem with that, the views of players and managers are always going to be a priority.

Radio Sheffield gets slated regularly on here but it's one of the best around when it comes to football. All you have to do is listen to football shows after away games for proof.
 
Paul Walker was arrogant and rude on last nights programme ,even prompting one caller to ask him if he'd upset him. He is so far up his own arse its beyond belief ,just try listening to him on Toby Foster in a morning.
 
Personally, I believe all three do an excellent job. Yes I do.
 
Personally, I believe all three do an excellent job. Yes I do.

Hmm I used to think that and dont get me wrong, it still offers great coverage but some things have started to irk me about that programme a little. Having said that I'm still not sure why this thread is in the Blades section :confused:
 
It may just be me , but i get the feeling they cannot afford to be pro-Blades , and go too far the other way , but i bet that deep down like most of us they would love the piggycheats to go under .
 
Paul Walker was arrogant and rude on last nights programme ,even prompting one caller to ask him if he'd upset him. He is so far up his own arse its beyond belief ,just try listening to him on Toby Foster in a morning.

He seems a decent chap off-air.

Given the parade of halfwittery on the phone lines, I don't blame him for being short with people. In fact, if I was Prime Minister, I'd ban all radio phone-ins in an attempt to instill some proper journalism back into the medium.
 
They can't do proper journalism because if they upset the clubs they have nothing to cover.
 
Precisely, and the reason they get so many complaints of being pro-Wednesday/pro-United is because people always hear the things they don't want to hear.

They're not perfect, and the devil's advocate routine can get tiresome, but there's a reason for it.
 
They are pro Wednesday though. How many times are they going to run the none investment story for starters.
 
Precisely, and the reason they get so many complaints of being pro-Wednesday/pro-United is because people always hear the things they don't want to hear.

They're not perfect, and the devil's advocate routine can get tiresome, but there's a reason for it.

That bit doesnt bother me. They can be pro-whatever they like. I just feel that they pedal certain myths about certain clubs that aren't true, but thats a story for another day.

They can't do proper journalism because if they upset the clubs they have nothing to cover.

Bingo! They know it as well.

---------- Post added at 01:19 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:16 PM ----------

They are pro Wednesday though. How many times are they going to run the none investment story for starters.

Think about one thing though.....if Wednesday go under (just saying if), what are they going to replace the pull of the Sheffield rivalry with???? I'm sure the derby and everything that goes with it is very valuable to them in terms of listeners and ratings etc.
 
Thanks guys some kind words, First Radio Blade i won't bite just annoyed say if i wanted to call in to the station and sit on the line to probably be told we can't get you on no attention seeking there. Steel city again as i say to radio blade if blades wanted to ring they wouldn't get on so thats what relevance it had to United especially as i didn't hear to many last night. Coily... referring to him as a clown isn't really that bad am sure he has been called worse.
 
Thanks guys some kind words, First Radio Blade i won't bite just annoyed say if i wanted to call in to the station and sit on the line to probably be told we can't get you on no attention seeking there. Steel city again as i say to radio blade if blades wanted to ring they wouldn't get on so thats what relevance it had to United especially as i didn't hear to many last night. Coily... referring to him as a clown isn't really that bad am sure he has been called worse.

Agree with the first comment. RadioBlade was a little harsh in the second post IMO but calling someone a clown is as well dp so I agree with coily on that. Why call him anything? He's at work, trying to do his job and bring coverage that all of the regions' fans want and they want to hear from their managers. I think we would all like it to be Blades.FM in an ideal world but its for everyone so I'm afraid they have to cover other teams as well, hence that includes feedback from managers.

So he asked people to call in and they didnt get on.....so what?! If they didnt ask anyone to call in then the show would soon go down the shitter. Are we to call someone a clown for doing their job? I'm quite sure the show's producers instruct him to say "call in" every so often dp so it hardly makes him a target for name calling.

Fair enough about the relevance dp but people will question the post if you dont mention the Blades or anything Blades-related once in your opening post (which you dont). All it mentions is callers and other teams' managers. I heard a couple of Blades on last night. Considering the amount of time they had on the programme I would say that is reasonable enough.
 



Personally, I believe all three do an excellent job. Yes I do.

Love the coverage in general. I know some on here have mixed views about RS but it offeres a better service than any I've heard while travelling.
Back to the point of the thread. The new guy they are blooding seems good but Andy Giddins is useless. He cuts people off at the wrong time most of the time and seems to want to cram as many in as poss which takes away from quality of controversy.
YES he does keep putting phone number out at late stage in show when people cannot get their point across because he says 'we've got to get more calls in'.
 
Love the coverage in general. I know some on here have mixed views about RS but it offeres a better service than any I've heard while travelling.
Back to the point of the thread. The new guy they are blooding seems good but Andy Giddins is useless. He cuts people off at the wrong time most of the time and seems to want to cram as many in as poss which takes away from quality of controversy.
YES he does keep putting phone number out at late stage in show when people cannot get their point across because he says 'we've got to get more calls in'.

Cheers Boo agreed i also love the coverage, i should have put useless instead of clown in my first post.
 
Can I point out that live radio isn't that easy? They may be three muppets but getting on their back for something as pedantic as this is, well, pedantic.
 
Can I point out that live radio isn't that easy? They may be three muppets but getting on their back for something as pedantic as this is, well, pedantic.

How long has Giddins been doing that show? You'd think he'd be a bit more proffessional by now?
It would be pedantic to pick up on the point that i only critised one of the three?
 
Football Heaven or Hell?

As an exile living in East Yorkshire I listen to Football Heaven but it is a bit like a tourettes for me I just can't help myself, I turn on most nights knowing what is going to happen and but hoping against hope it might be better than I thought.

I love football but quite simply think that having a football phone in 6 nights a week is a challenge to say the least as there ain't that much worth saying. Particularly in modern times with transfer windows there is bugger all to talk about between Monday and Thursday so we get the same old people ringing in every week saying the same old things most of which to put it politely is boring and repetitive.

It also gives a voice to people who because they ring in every week now see themselves as celebrities (a la Brian the idiot, sorry Blade) and actually think that they are respected pundits or comedians in some instances. Brian tonight was spouting about the youth policy he would employ if in charge and turned the subject round to the great players that had played for him, someone needs to remind how high he managed to climb in the game it might be somewhat different managing a pro club in the current times.

There is the odd caller like Clay Cross who is worth listening to, but they very much appear to be the exception. I believe DP is a regular caller, who whilst sounding vaguely intelligent pretty much always manages to come up with a criticism of SUFC which I find frustrating.

Cut it to Friday night previews and Saturdays and you might start to rebuild a show with worthwhile quality content that you don't feel like you have wasted an hour of your life listening to.

Whilst the stir is completely biased towards Wednesday I think Radio Sheffield are fairly impartial, but Paul Walker who is the leader of the gang has got an ego problem; however it is quite amusing listening to the breakfast show when he tries to keep up with Toby Foster in the comedy stakes and normally comes across as the works geek trying to be witty with the cool guy and failing miserably.

So in conclusion I must try harder not to turn the bloody radio on, so tomorrow I will go and spend an hour poking myself in the eye with a cocktail stick as it will distract me and probably be just as productive.

P.s There is the odd moment of classic comedy such as last saturday night, first caller a Blade ringing from Oxford, who hadn't been to the game and when asked about his opinion on Speeds tenure to date replied "I haven't got one" Which demands the question why the fook are you ringing a football phone in then!!

P.p.s Late night rant over, if anyone wants to discuss it further I will be the bloke with a pie, pint and eye patch in John Street on Saturday.
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom