A Different view?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Joined
Apr 14, 2010
Messages
237
Reaction score
35
Location
Home- Swinton, Work- Sheffield
When a fairly high profile position such as this becomes available it is not really that surprising that everyone and their granny is linked with it. By available (by the way) I mean that it has been opened up to applications, rather than the chairman picking someone who will do the job on the cheap, and then persuading them to take the plunge. McCabe appointed managers, he didn’t seek applications.

The last time we really invited applications for the manager’s job, when Warnock got the job, I understand one applicant impressed, but was out-pointed by others with more ‘experience’ and probably were willing to do the job cheaper.

I talk of course, of Keith Edwards.

I can hear both closeted and open guffawing even now, but just have a think about it.

Firstly he is passionate about the club; he is as big a Blade as you could meet. He played in teams that produced some of the best football that I have ever seen at The Lane (although it could be said that he and some of his colleagues should have been playing at a higher level). During his time at The Lane, the football was fast and free-scoring, hardly what we have seen in recent years/months.

Some will scorn his ‘expert summaries’ during matches, but, if you listen the guy does talk sense… most of the time, as with most of us fans, sometimes he talks complete hairy spheres! In addition, to those who did ridicule him, giving him the chance to prove himself would find him out, or not.

One stumbling block, he doesn’t hold his F.A. coaching badges (or should that be KER-CHING badges, they’re not cheap). I also know he is a BIG detractor from their value in the real world. Well, think of some of the great managers, the real greats. Bill Shankley, Alf Ramsey, Cloughy, Bassett (for us), the list can go on, did they need badges to conquer leagues, Europe, the world? No they didn’t. All they needed was some genuine football nouse… and a good physio!

Just imagine a coaching set up of Edwards, supported by TC, Colin Morris, and Paul Stancliffe with Morgs as the ‘apprentice’. I’d pay just to watch a staff kick about!
 



Firstly he is passionate about the club; he is as big a Blade as you could meet.

Before the Hull match we needed to win to get promotion back to The Premiership, to my disbelief Edwards said "I've got a foot in both camps, so I'm hoping for a draw!".
On that basis, I suspect he's not the biggest Blade I'll ever meet (I never have met him but spoke to his ex-wife in Henrys once (a good father, crap husband apparently)).
He was my childhood sporting hero, so I've no axe to grind with him but like all ex-players wanting to get into management (e.g. Speed) he should start at the bottom and work his way up.

First jobs in management:-
Alf Ramsay - Ipswich (Third Division South)
Bill Shankly – Carlisle (Third Division North)
Brian Clough – Hartlepool (Division Four)
David Bassett – Wimbeldon (Division Four)
 
Before the Hull match we needed to win to get promotion back to The Premiership, to my disbelief Edwards said "I've got a foot in both camps, so I'm hoping for a draw!".


The reason for saying this was because he fell out with radio sheffield for a year and spent a year commentating on Hull.
 
The reason for saying this was because he fell out with radio sheffield for a year and spent a year commentating on Hull.

I'm fairly sure this was before he left Radio Sheffield. He probably said it because he played nearly 300 times for Hull. However, this was a game we desperately needed to win to get back in The Premiership, win the £30M jackpot etc.. I'd expect any "passionate, big Blade" to want us to win that one regardless of the opposition.
 
interesting.. but since when did supporting the team become criteria for managing it?
seriously.. i like edwards and he makes some very valid points in his commentary, but he has no experience of football management so i'll have to pass on that one..
 
I'm a Sheffield United fan and I talk about football a lot.

I am also a more qualified coach than Kieth Edwards.

Who wants me to have the job?
 
just been on the gambling sites and some dude called presty is now the clear favourite :D
 
That's because I've just put mine & the Mrs' savings on him... I put the kids' piggy bank on him getting us promoted this season as I thought that MAY be a bit of a long shot ;-)
 

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

All advertisments are hidden for logged in members, why not log in/register?

Back
Top Bottom