I totally agree.
I only ever saw Hagan play once and that was at Joe Shaw's testimonial on March 29, 1965. It was the night before my seventh birthday so I think I can be forgiven for having only the haziest memory of his performance although I do remember him scoring direct from a free kick at the Kop end to general delight. Even at that age I had my suspicions that Ron Springett in the All-Stars XI goal hadn't done his absolute best to keep it out - he was grinning after it went in - but, to be fair, Hagan was 47 by then.
What does stay in my memory is something my dad said to me and my year older brother on the night. Dad was born in 1921 and was a Unitedite through and through although like many others in the thirties, forties and fifties he used to go one week to Bramall Lane and the next to Owlerton (as he called it). By 1965, he was no longer a regular at matches but Hagan coming out of retirement to play in Joe Shaw's game was always going to guarantee his attendance and he took us both and we stood near the front on the John Street terrace. After the teams came out but before the game started, he called the two of us over to him from the railings on which we were standing and he proceeded very seriously to make a little speech to us both, looking us in the eye and wagging his finger at us to make his point. It went something very like this: " now listen, you two, I want you to remember this night. I want you to remember that you saw Jimmy Hagan play. I want you, when the time comes, to tell your children and your grandchildren that you saw Jimmy Hagan, the great Jimmy Hagan, play. Never forget this night. Never forget that you saw Jimmy Hagan play."
It made such an impression on me. I had never seen him as serious about anything before and I don't think I ever saw him as serious about anything again (and he lived until he was 84). He revered Hagan and he clearly wanted his sons to try and understand just how good Hagan was.
So, when Silent criticises the voting system and laments Jimmy Hagan's failure to get in the first three, I think he has a very valid point.