My big question mark is why are certain players not repeating last season's form. During the second half of last season when the team won the ball our attacking players were off, there was movement everywhere and the man with the ball had options. Passing was easy when players were on the move and making space. That's not just about formations, it's about players so Scougall , Flynn ( when on the wing) and Baxter in particular should take a long hard look at themselves and, to a lesser extent, so should Murphy.
The manager has to find a way to rediscover their enthusiasm and optimism and increase the first three's work-rate by at least 30%.
I think those first three mentioned players above are reaching a tipping point in their careers with Clough. I know Scougall appears to be a manager's favourite but he is failing badly. Flynn was a revelation at full back and seemed to rediscover his confidence all of a sudden; he has to repeat that on the wing because I don't think Clough would persevere with him at full back once others are fit. Baxter is on borrowed time I fear.
Murphy has to find a way to get himself space when the opposition double up on him, that's the next stage of his development and it involves more movement off the ball, though I must say he does far more than the other three above.
Coady was not that influential last season for the manager not to expect all four of those players to come to the party in his absence this season too.
The players appear to be working hard each game but we know they can play with a lot more energy, tempo and optimism because they did it last season. What's up wi'em? and why can't Clough sort it out? Confidence is a factor and sheer determination is another factor; bottle! They have to get into the final third of the pitch and particularly into the penalty area more often in numbers.